Skip to main content

Full text of "The tragedy of Bitlis"

See other formats


'mM 


HKiiiipp 


BRARY  OF  CONGRESS 


DODO'=3bD3 


Class 

Bcok__l_i 


COFmiGHT  DEPOSm 


^^^H                                  ^   MttKKwM^m^Bs         j£la         ^^^Hl 

^^^^^^^ft^          x]fliC!'jVf[i    ^H^L  ^^H 

^^^^HM^  1  fl 

^^^iHiyiBf^fj^ 

i  i 


a 


C/i 


The  Tragedy  of  Bitlis 


By 
GRACE  H.  KNAPP 


Being  Mainly  the  Narratives  of 
GRisELL  M.  McLaren 

AND 

MYRTLE  O.  SHANE 


ILLUSTRATED 


New    York  Chicago 

Fleming      H.      Revell      Company 

London  and  Edinburgh 


Copyright,  1919,  by 
FLEMING  H.  REVELL  COMPANY  / 


<\,(, 


f 


1^ 


m  29  ifift 


New  York:  158  Fifth  Avenue 
Chicago:  17  North  Wabash  Ave. 
London:  21  Paternoster  Square 
Edinburgh:      75     Princes    Street 


©CU535r)18 


To  the  memory  of  those  dear  to  me. 

Father,  Mother,  Brother,  **Aunt  Charlotte  and 
Aunt  Mary  "  Ely,  who,  in  the  name  of  Christ, 
spent  their  lives  for  the  Armenians  of  Bitlis, 
this  story  of  the  sufferings  ayid  heroism  of  the 
people  whom  they  loved  and  worked  for  is 
affectionately  dedicated 


Preface 

AFTER  their  return  to  this  country  in 
October,  1917,  Miss  McLaren  and  Miss 
Shane  each  wrote  an  account  of  what 
occurred  in  BitUs  during  the  summer  and  early- 
autumn  of  1915.  A  harmony  of  the  two  nar- 
ratives constitutes  two-thirds  of  the  present  vol- 
ume, entire  paragraphs  or  pages  being  quoted 
word  for  word  where  this  was  feasible.  Every 
incident  is  absolutely  authentic,  for  the  two 
American  ladies  have  related  without  exaggera- 
tion what  they  have  seen  with  their  own  eyes 
or  experienced  in  their  own  persons. 

I  happened  to  be  in  Van  when  the  war  began 
and  shared  the  fortunes  of  the  Americans  and 
Armenians  there  during  the  events  briefly 
sketched  in  the  chapter  entitled  "  The  Besieged 
City."  But  Bitlis  was  my  birthplace  and  child- 
hood's home,  and  I  had  taught  there  for  nine 
years.  So  the  scenes  I  have  described  are  dear 
and  famihar  scenes  and  the  "  Ely  residence," 

5 


6  PEEFACE 

now  looted,  deserted  and  bare,  my  old  home, 
once  filled  with  relics  of  my  parents'  long  life 
within  its  walls  and  endeared  by  a  thousand  ties 
of  association.  Pastor  Khachig,  Deegeen  Lu- 
centag,  Deegeen  Heghene,  and  Kevork  Effendi 
were  old  and  valued  friends,  together  with  many 
others  whose  names  are  not  mentioned  in  these 
pages,  and  Miss  Shane's  pupils  had  once  been 
mine.  One  of  them  a  few  weeks  ago  related  to 
me  the  sequel  of  Miss  McLaren's  and  Miss 
Shane's  narrative  and  the  story  of  her  own 
strange  romance. 

The  last  chapter  also  describes  the  present 
condition  in  the  Russian  Caucasus  of  the  refu- 
gees from  the  Van  and  Bitlis  provinces  and  the 
wonderful  work  of  relief  and  rehabilitation  un- 
dertaken by  the  American  Committee  for  Ar- 
menian and  Syrian  Relief. 

Grace  H.  Knapp. 


Contents 


I. 

BiTLIS 

9 

II. 

The  Besieged  City  .        .        .        . 

15 

III. 

An  American  Woman  in  a  Turkish 
Hospital 

21 

IV. 

During  the  Siege    .        .        .        . 

29 

V. 

Across  the  Lake  to  Bitlis 

35 

VI. 

Twelve    Thousand    Refugees    in 
Bitlis 

44 

VII. 

Massacre  of  the  Men 

49 

VIII. 

Deportation  of  the  Women    . 

59 

IX. 

The  Russian  Army  Approaches 

69 

X. 

The  Passing  of  Miss  Charlotte  Ely 

74 

XI. 

After  the  Russian  Retreat   . 

82 

XII. 

Sister  Martha        .         .         .         . 

93 

XIII. 

The   Pioneer    Parents   of   George 
Perkins  Knapp      .         .         .         . 

96 

XIV. 

Greater  Love  Hath  No  Man  . 

112 

XV. 

Miss  McLaren  Falls  III  ;  German 
Officers  Visit  Bitlis  . 

127 

XVI. 

MusTiFA  Bey  and  the  Schoolgirls 

133 

XVII. 

Miss    McLaren    and    Miss   Shane 
Obliged  to  Leave  Bitlis 

140 

XVIII. 

Sequels    

144 

Illustrations 


Sister  Cities  With  Interwoven  Destinies 
A  nook  in  Bitlis 
Van — from  the  citadel 


Charlotte  E.  Ely  ,         ,         • 

Mary  A.  C.  Ely    .         .         •         , 

Alzina  Churchill  Knapp 

George  Perkins  Knapp  . 

Home  Life  in  an  Armenian  Village 

Life  in  an  ArxMEnian  Refugee  Camp — Port  Said 


Industrial  Relief  of  the  American  Committee  for 
Relief  in  the  Near  East     .... 
Shoe-making 
Lace-work 


Frontispiece 

FACING  page 
74 


74 
74 
74 

I02 
I02 

148 


1 

BITLIS 

SPRING  in  a  little  Armenian  town  in  the 
heart  of  Kurdistan :  hills,  bleakly  bare 
and  brown  the  rest  of  the  year,  were 
faintly  green  with  a  sparse  evanescent  herbage ; 
poplars  lining  streets  and  waterways  were  spires 
of  pale  green  smoke  bursting  into  beryl  flame 
where  the  sun  shot  through;  fruit  trees  behind 
high  garden  walls  were  masses  of  white  bloom. 
Everywhere  there  was  the  sound  and  scent  of 
running  water,  for  the  city  was  a  city  of  streams 
and  waterfalls  and  fountains,  a  city  high,  high 
up  among  the  mountains,  so  enfolded  within  its 
hills,  so  swallowed  up  in  deep  narrow  ravines 
that  the  whole  of  it  could  not  be  seen  at  once 
from  the  top  of  any  of  the  surrounding  peaks. 

The  most  densely  built  part  was  like  an 
amphitheater,  flat-roofed  stone  houses  climbing 
tier  above  tier  half-way  up  one  face  of  Water 
Tower  Hill,  a  hill  as  triangular  and  steep  as  a 
pyramid  and  crowned  by  an  old  tower  whose 
surmised  purpose  had  given  it  its  name. 

9 


10  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

In  the  center  of  the  amphitheater  was  an 
enormous  ancient  fortress,  picturesque  with 
towers  and  battlements,  rising  cHff-like  above  a 
hive  of  low-roofed  bazaars.  Around  its  base 
and  under  half  a  score  of  arched  stone  bridges, 
rushed  a  mountain  torrent  that  had  entered  the 
city  by  one  narrow  gorge  and  left  it  by  another, 
the  western  side  of  which  was  covered  with  the 
orchards  and  gardens  of  squatter  Kurds.  A 
smaller  stream  leaped  down  a  crevice  in  the  hills 
to  meet  it  here,  turning  perforce  on  its  way 
primitive  grindstones  in  a  mill  that  looked  like 
a  feudal  baron's  stronghold  atop  its  pinnacle  of 
peninsulated  rock. 

The  eastern  side  was  a  high  bluff  into  the  face 
of  which  was  cut  a  highway  leading  from  the 
center  of  the  city  to  the  south.  The  top  of  the 
bluff  was  a  small  plateau;  near  its  northern  edge 
the  buildings  of  the  American  Mission  looked 
down  sheer  two  hundred  feet  into  the  well  of 
the  amphitheater  with  its  mosques  and  mina- 
rets, fortress  and  bazaars. 

The  Merchant  in  Persia,  visiting  Bitlis  early 
in  the  sixteenth  century,  found  this  fortress  or 
castle  occupied  by  a  Kurdish  prince  owning  only 
nominal  allegiance  to  the  Shah  of  Persia. 


BITLIS  11 

Tavernier  a  century  later  was  impressed  by 
the  power  of  the  Bey  of  Bitlis,  "  who  acknowl- 
edged neither  the  Shah  of  Persia  nor  the  Sultan 
of  Turkey  and  was  courted  by  both  on  account 
of  the  strategical  value  of  his  city  barring  the 
communications  between  Aleppo  and  Tabriz, 
He  also  resided  in  the  castle  approached  by 
three  successive  drawbridges  and  could  place 
in  the  field  20,000  to  25,000  horsemen  besides  a 
quantity  of  good  infantry.  In  the  eighteenth 
century  the  Padre  Maurizio  Garzoni  speaks  of 
the  dynasty  of  Bitlis  as  one  of  the  five  consider- 
able principalities  which  divided  between  them 
the  Kurdistan  of  his  day.  The  last  of  this  old 
order  of  princes  at  Bitlis  was  a  man  of  many- 
sided  and  remarkable  character,  whose  romantic 
history  one  peruses  with  breathless  excitement 
in  the  dry  reports  and  correspondence  of  Consul 
Brant,  the  eye  and  ear  of  the  famous  Stratford 
Canning.  After  a  life  of  chequered  fortune  and 
fox-like  resistance  to  the  Turkish  power  he  was 
finally  overwhelmed  by  the  operations  of  Reshid 
Pasha  and  taken  a  prisoner  to  Constantinople 
in  1849/' ' 

This  prince,  Sherif  Bey,  built  a  fortified  castle 
*H.  F.  B.  I,ynch,  "Armenia,"  Vol.  II,  Chap.  VI. 


12  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

long  ago  razed  to  the  ground,  on  an  emi- 
nence, still  bearing  his  name,  which  links  the 
small  plateau  to  Water  Tower  Hill. 

Once  since  the  rule  of  Turkish  pashas  began 
have  the  Kurds  of  the  region  attempted  to  re- 
gain their  old  power.  In  the  spring  of  1914  they 
marched  into  the  city,  a  harlequin  mob  in  their 
gay  native  costumes,  and  armed  chiefly  with 
short  swords,  scimitars  and  knives.  Chanting 
weirdly,  they  took  up  a  position  on  Sherif  Bey's 
Hill  in  full  view  of  the  government  buildings 
and  within  direct  range  of  fire  from  the  bar- 
racks. They  did  not  fear  the  enemy's  bullets, 
for  these  would  be  warded  ofif  by  the  magic 
power  of  their  religious  leaders,  the  sheikhs. 

The  machine  guns  startled  them  and  they 
scurried  to  cover  in  an  old  Armenian  church, 
from  which  for  a  while  they  returned  the  fire 
with  a  few  old  muskets.  But  when  cannon-balls 
began  to  demolish  the  walls  of  their  shelter  and 
it  was  discovered  that  the  invulnerable  sheikhs 
had  deserted  them  and  were  in  hiding  they  fled 
in  utter  rout. 

More  than  a  year  had  passed  since  then  and 
Turkey  had  for  months  been  at  war  with  Russia, 
but  the  little  town  was  quiet  and  peaceful  this 


BITLIS  13 

bright  May  morning.  Why  not?  It  had  known 
such  terrible  massacres  during  the  past  quarter 
century  that  a  war  with  a  foe  from  without,  a 
war  in  which  the  Armenians  themselves  were 
fighting  and  proving  their  bravery  and  loyalty, 
seemed  by  comparison  a  thing  not  to  be  so 
greatly  feared.  And  the  governor  of  the  prov- 
ince had  thus  far  proved  himself  able  to  keep  in 
order  the  turbulent  elements  within  his  vilayet. 
So  there  seemed  no  good  reason  why  three  of 
the  small  circle  of  American  missionaries  should 
not  now  take  their  furloughs  which  were  due 
and  for  which  a  more  convenient  season  might 
never  occur.  Mr.  and  Mrs.  H.  A.  Maynard  had 
worked  for  seven  years  in  Bitlis,  seven  strenu- 
ous years  filled  with  difficult  problems,  anxie- 
ties, sorrows,  which  only  calm  good  judgment, 
devotedness  and  courage  such  as  theirs  could 
face  and  endure;  they  greatly  needed  now  a 
year  at  home.  With  them  was  leaving  Miss 
Mary  D.  Uline,  who  had  begun  her  missionary 
life  in  Erzerum  but  who  had  taught  for  four 
years  in  the  Mt.  Holyoke  Seminary  of  Bitlis  and 
had  been  its  principal  for  two  years. 

It  was  the  Armenian  Ascension  Day,  and  the 
streets  were  filled  with  people  in  gala  attire. 


14  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

Hundreds  of  Armenian  friends  "  set  the  travel- 
lers on  the  road,"  according  to  their  custom. 
After  these  turned  back,  Miss  Ely,  Miss  Shane, 
Mr.  Knapp  and  the  Armenian  pastor  and  head 
teacher  of  the  boys'  school  prepared  a  farewell 
picnic  lunch  in  a  shaded  spot  by  the  side  of  the 
road  within  sight  and  sound  of  the  river.  With 
hopeful  prophecies  concerning  the  future,  with 
laughter  and  with  jest,  the  members  of  the  little 
group  tried  to  hide  from  each  other  the  doubts, 
misgivings  and  sense  of  loss  with  which  the 
approaching  separation  filled  their  hearts. 

Yet  they  did  not  dream  that  at  this  very  mo- 
ment their  American  friends  of  the  nearest  sis- 
ter mission,  ninety  miles  away  across  Lake  Van, 
were  in  a  besieged  city,  cut  off  utterly  from 
communication  with  the  outside  world;  a  be- 
sieged city  that  had  held  out  gallantly  against 
desperate  odds  for  nearly  four  weeks  but  had 
now  lost  all  hope  and  was  fighting  grimly  but 
to  put  off  a  little  longer  the  inevitable  end. 


II 

THE  BESIEGED  CITY 

DJEVDET  BEY,  the  Governor-General 
of  Van,  brother-in-law  of  Enver  Pasha, 
Minister  of  War,  had  planned  for  April 
19,  1915,  a  general  massacre  of  his  Armenian 
subjects.  On  that  day  soldiers  and  Kurds,  in 
some  instances  taking  cannon  with  them,  at- 
tacked the  smaller  towns  and  the  villages  of  the 
province,  and  met  with  little  or  no  resistance 
because  most  of  the  able-bodied  men  had  been 
drafted  into  the  Sultan's  army  and  those  who 
were  left  had  very  little  ammunition.  Fifty-five 
thousand  men,  women  and  children  were 
slaughtered;  thousands,  wounded,  managed  to 
escape  and  flee  to  the  capital,  while  their  homes 
were  looted  and  burned  behind  them. 

In  the  city  of  Van  itself  Djevdet  Bey's  plans 
met  with  an  unexpected  check.    He  had  endeav- 
oured by  exorbitant  demands  and  by  acts  of 
treachery  to  incite  the  Armenians  to  "  rebel- 
's 


16  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

lion "  which  would  justify  putting  them  to 
death.  But  the  Armenians  were  exceedingly 
careful  not  to  precipitate  trouble  by  any  overt 
act  of  their  own,  which,  they  very  well  knew, 
would  be  made  an  excuse  for  massacres  all  over 
the  Empire.  At  the  same  time  they  determined 
to  put  up  a  light  in  case  of  attack,  and  they  dis- 
covered that  lines  of  entrenchment  were  being 
secretly  drawn  around  the  Armenian  quarter. 

This  Armenian  quarter  was  about  a  mile 
square  and  was  separated  by  a  Turkish  quarter 
from  the  business  section  in  the  old  walled  city 
two  miles  distant.  In  the  walled  city  was  the 
famous  Castle  Rock,  a  citadel  that  could  pro- 
tect— or  threaten — the  bazaars  and  dwellings 
huddled  around  its  base. 

Most  of  the  Armenian  men  had  enlisted  or 
had  been  drafted  into  the  army.  Between 
twelve  and  fifteen  hundred  young  men  were  left, 
trained  riflemen,  though  they  possessed  but 
three  hundred  rifles  among  them.  They  manned 
and  barricaded,  secretly,  positions  all  around  the 
Armenian  quarter,  then — waited.  "  If  the  Ar- 
menians fire  one  shot,"  Djevdet  Bey  had  told 
the  Americans,  "  I  will  destroy  the  city  utterly, 
leaving  not  one  child  as  high  as  my  knee." 


THE  BESIEGED  CITY  17 

The  Armenians  did  not  fire  that  first  shot. 
Turkish  soldiers  fired  it,  and  within  an  hour  the 
Armenian  quarter,  with  its  thirty  thousand  in- 
habitants, was  in  a  state  of  siege. 

At  the  same  time  the  Armenians  in  the  walled 
city  were  put  on  the  defensive.  Cannon  on  Cas- 
tle Rock  were  fired  down  upon  their  sun-dried 
brick  houses,  wrecking  the  upper  stories.  Al- 
though there  were  only  thirty  fighting  men  here 
they  held  out  bravely  to  the  very  end. 

The  story  of  the  siege  of  Van,  together  with 
the  events  that  preceded  and  followed,  is  fully 
told  in  Dr.  C.  D.  Ussher's  "  An  American  Physi- 
cian in  Turkey."  '  It  is  very  briefly  related  here 
on  account  of  Miss  Grisell  McLaren's  connec- 
tion with  the  tragedy  of  Van  and  the  tragedy  of 
Bitlis. 

When  Turkey  entered  the  war  in  the  autumn 
of  1914,  a  military  hospital  was  opened  on  the 
outskirts  of  the  city  about  a  mile  from  the 
American  premises.  The  Governor  asked  the 
missionaries  to  send  one  of  their  number  to  help 
in  this  hospital,  and  Miss  McLaren  was  chosen. 

Not  far  from  the  American  premises  was  an 

"Ambassador  Morgenthau  also  devotes  considerable 
space  to  it  in  his  book. 


18  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

Armenian  orphanage  under  the  management  of 
a  Swiss  gentleman,  Herr  Sporri,  his  wife  and 
daughter,  and  three  German  ladies.  Hundreds 
of  the  orphans  of  the  1895-96  massacres  had 
been  taken  care  of  for  some  years  by  the  Ameri- 
can missionaries.  Later  these  Germans  had 
come  in,  and  it  had  been  thought  best  in  order 
not  to  duplicate  and  waste  effort  to  turn  over  all 
of  the  remaining  orphans  to  their  care.  Frau- 
lein  Kleiss  (Schwester  Marthe,  or  Sister  Martha 
as  we  called  her),  was  also  asked  to  help  and 
consented  to  do  so.  The  two  ladies  worked 
during  the  day  at  the  hospital,  returning  at 
night.  Some  of  their  pre-siege  experiences  are 
related  by  Miss  McLaren  in  the  following 
chapter. 

Although  the  Americans  did  not  know  that 
Djevdet  Bey  was  planning  a  massacre,  it  was 
quite  evident  on  April  lYth  that  there  was  going 
to  be  serious  trouble  of  some  sort,  so  when  he 
asked  Sister  Martha  and  Miss  McLaren  to  stay 
at  the  hospital  night  and  day  for  ten  days,  they 
understood  there  was  to  be  no  going  and  com- 
ing and  they  must  either  accede  to  his  request 
or  stay  at  home  for  that  length  of  time.  The 
Armenian  workers  begged  them  not  to  leave* 


THE  BESIEGED  CITY  19 

their  presence  might  save  these  men  from  death. 
The  thought  of  the  way  in  which  the  poor  pa- 
tients would  be  neglected  during  their  absence 
also  strongly  influenced  them  and  they  decided 
to  remain  at  their  post.  But  throughout  the 
siege  they  held  no  communication  with  their  as- 
sociates nor  did  the  Vali  vouchsafe  any  informa- 
tion to  the  Americans  concerning  Miss  McLar- 
en's well-being,  although  during  the  early  part 
of  the  siege  there  was  occasional  communication 
between  him  and  their  official  representative, 
the  Italian  consular  agent. 

Djevdet  Bey,  indeed,  in  spite  of  the  fact  that 
hitherto  he  had  had  most  friendly  relations  with 
the  missionaries,  in  spite  of  the  fact  that  scores 
of  Turkish  soldiers  had  been  cared  for  in  their 
Red  Cross  hospital  and  that  he  was  assured  they 
were  maintaining  an  attitude  of  strict  neutral- 
ity— which  as  Americans  they  were  bound  to  do 
— was  enraged  by  their  humanitarian  efforts  in 
behalf  of  the  non-combatants.  They  housed  six 
thousand  refugees  on  their  own  premises,  or- 
ganized a  city  government  and  a  system  of  food 
distribution,  and  cared  for  the  sick  and  wounded. 
Epidemics  raged,  for  over  ten  thousand  villagers 
escaped  to  the  city,  provisions  ran  very  low,  and 


20  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

crowding,  exposure  and  privation  brought  the 
usual  consequences  in  their  train.  Djevdet  Bey- 
threatened  to  bombard  the  American  premises 
and  he  fulfilled  his  threat  on  the  twenty-fourth 
and  twenty-fifth  days  of  the  siege.  Shells 
entered  every  building  in  the  compound. 

This  proved  to  be  a  burst  of  foiled  spite,  how- 
ever, for  in  the  afternoon  and  evening  of  the 
15th  of  May  the  Turkish  troops  were  with- 
drawn from  the  city  and  it  was  soon  discovered 
that  practically  its  entire  Turkish  population 
had  already  fled  in  boats  across  the  lake  to 
Bitlis. 

The  Americans  hastened  the  next  morning  to 
the  military  hospital  only  to  find  that  Miss 
McLaren  and  Sister  Martha  had  been  sent  with 
their  patients  to  Bitlis  four  days  earlier. 

On  the  18th  the  Russians,  whose  approach 
had  put  to  flight  the  Turks,  entered  the  city. 


Ill 

AN  AMERICAN  WOMAN  IN  A  TURKISH 
HOSPITAL 

{Miss  McLaren^ s  Story) 

**^TI  ^HE  Van  hospital  was  used  to  serve  the 
I  portion  of  the  Ottoman  army  that 
was  fighting  against  the  Russians  be- 
tween Van  and  the  Persian  border.  Of  those 
who  reached  the  hospital  many  were  wounded, 
many  had  feet  or  hands  frozen  by  lying  day  and 
night  in  the  snow  and  many  others  were  ill  from 
exposure  and  improper  food  and  shelter.  There 
was  no  well-organized  Red  Cross  or  Red  Cres- 
cent ambulance  service — in  fact,  there  were 
scarcely  any  roads  over  which  four-wheeled 
vehicles  could  have  travelled  even  if  there  had 
been  any  such  vehicles  available.  The  patients 
were  cared  for  first  in  the  field  hospitals,  which 
were  usually  in  dark,  dirty  stables,  and  from 
these  a  few  at  a  time  were  sent  to  the  central 
hospital  at  Van.  They  had  to  come  on  the 
backs  of  donkeys,  horses,  or  even  oxen.  Any 
who  were  unable  to  sit  up  and  hold  on  were 

21 


22  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

bound,  face  down,  on  the  back  of  the  animal. 
Often  when  they  arrived  some  poor  fellows 
would  be  hanging  over  the  side  head  down, 
sometimes  with  their  heads  between  the  ani- 
mal's front  feet.  No  nurses  were  ever  sent  with 
such  a  caravan,  and  the  muleteers  did  not  care 
what  happened.  Such  a  journey  required  from 
four  to  ten  days,  and  stops  were  made  each 
night  in  a  village,  where  the  men  had  to  lie  with- 
out beds  on  some  earthen  floor.  Lucky  they 
were  if  they  had  a  roof  over  their  heads. 

"  Where  the  roads  were  good  ox-carts  were 
used,  but  only  for  the  worst  cases,  and  the  poor 
men  had  to  lie  for  days  on  these,  clad  only  in 
miserable  rags,  sometimes  with  a  little  hay 
under  them  and  an  overcoat  for  covering,  some- 
times with  nothing  as  protection,  either  below 
or  above.  On  arrival  the  dead  had  to  be  re- 
moved first  before  the  living  could  be  gotten  at, 
and  more  of  these  ox-cart  passengers  w^ere  sent 
to  the  morgue  than  to  the  hospital.  Few  of 
those  who  were  living  when  they  arrived  re- 
covered. 

"  At  first  we  wondered  why  we  received  so 
few  heavily  wounded  men,  but  our  wondering 
soon  ceased  when  we  heard  the  patients  tell  of 


IN  A  TUEKISH  HOSPITAL  23 

how  their  companions  were  left  dead  or  dying 
by  the  roadside.  Enver  Pasha  is  credited  with 
having  said  that  Turkish  soldiers  had  no  identi- 
fication cards  or  discs  at  the  beginning  of  the 
war  because  the  dead  Turk  is  of  no  use  to  the 
Turkish  Government.  The  severely  wounded 
soldier  was  often  left  to  die  uncared  for  on  the 
battle-field  or  by  the  roadside,  probably  because 
he  could  be  of  no  further  use  to  the  government 
and  surgical  supplies  were  too  precious  to  waste 
on  such. 

"  During  the  early  weeks  of  the  war  our  pa- 
tients were  anxious  to  be  made  *  tabourdji ' 
(discharged  and  returned  to  the  front).  They 
were  all  eagerness  to  fight  to  help  their  allies, 
the  Germans.  One  young  officer  said,  *  No  mat- 
ter what  we  sacrifice,  it  will  still  be  little  when 
we  think  of  what  we  owe  to  Germany.'  A  few 
weeks  later  a  companion,  who  had  heard  this 
remark,  was  in  the  operating  room  watching  as 
the  surgeon  amputated  the  foot  of  a  poor  fellow 
who  had  already  lost  one  leg  and  would  lose  a 
hand  also.  He  said,  'May  the  curse  of  God 
rest  upon  the  man  who  began  this  war,  whether 
he  is  in  London  or  Berlin  or  wherever  he  is.* 
We  soon  found  that  men  were  removing  their 


24  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

bandages,  and  doing  things  to  get  their  wounds 
infected  and  thus  delay  their  departure  from 
the  hospital.  The  spirit  of  loyalty  to  their  allies 
had  changed,  except  in  a  few  cases,  to  bitter 
hate,  and  more  than  one  German  officer  has  said 
to  me,  '  If  the  war  goes  against  Germany  the 
Turks  will  rise  up  and  kill  every  German  in  the 
Turkish  Empire.' 

"  The  hospital  was  a  large,  new  building,  with 
comfortable  accommodations  for  200  patients. 
The  beds  were  of  iron,  each  provided  with  one 
mattress  of  straw  and  one  of  cotton,  which  soon 
grew  lumpy  and  hard  as  brick.  Sheets  were  too 
narrow  and  short  to  protect  the  mattresses;  pil- 
lows were  used  for  months  at  a  time  without 
cleansing;  there  was  not  enough  clothing  to 
keep  the  patients  clean  and  no  bathing  facilities 
— men  were  put  to  bed  in  the  condition  in  which 
they  came  off  the  road;  they  were  covered  with 
vermin  and  the  work  in  the  laundry  was  so 
poorly  done  it  was  not  safe  to  handle  the  gar- 
ments that  had  been  washed. 

"  Sister  Martha  and  I  made  up  our  minds 
that  there  must  be  some  radical  changes  in  the 
management  of  affairs  or  we  could  not  work. 
A  hospital  committee  was  formed  of  prominent 


IN  A  TUEKISH  HOSPITAL  25 

Turks  and  foreigners.  For  a  few  days  members 
of  this  committee  haunted  the  place,  holding 
conferences  with  the  staff,  finding  out  what  was 
needed  and  promising  to  have  everything  com- 
plete in  a  very  short  time.  Two  members  were 
to  spend  several  hours  each  day  going  about  the 
wards,  watching  the  dressing  of  wounds  and 
attending  operations.  They  began  bravely,  but 
it  was  really  funny  to  see  how  quickly  they 
sought  the  open  air  after  a  visit  to  a  ward. 
They  *  did  not  like  the  smell,'  they  said,  and 
left.  The  life  of  this  committee  of  high  ideals 
was  painfully  short,  but  before  it  went  out  we 
were  given  an  adequate  supply  of  the  most  nec- 
essary things,  and  a  small  room  was  fitted  up 
for  bathing,  each  patient  being  allowed  one  pail 
of  water  and  one  small  piece  of  poor  soap. 

"  The  officials  were  very  free  with  their  hands 
or  whips,  maintaining  that  a  common  soldier 
would  do  his  duty  only  through  fear  of  physical 
suffering.  Patients,  too,  who  writhed  when  the 
doctor  cruelly  probed  a  wound  or  used  a  knife 
freely,  were  often  struck  to  make  them  keep 
still.  We  put  a  stop  to  the  beating  of  servants, 
and  after  one  patient  died,  from  shock  appar- 
ently, after  undergoing  a  very  painful  operation 


26  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

without  anesthetic,  dressings  and  operations 
were  more  humanely  done. 

"  Sister  Martha  was  a  splendidly  trained 
nurse,  with  several  years  of  experience  in  Ger- 
man hospitals  and  clinics.  She  had  all  the  quali- 
ties of  a  German  general  and  ordered  everybody 
about  from  the  head  doctor  to  the  humblest 
nurse.  Inferiors  almost  worshipped  her,  and  to 
them  her  word  was  law,  but  men  who,  because 
of  their  military  rank,  should  have  been  manag- 
ing affairs,  resented  being  ordered  about  by  a 
woman.  Jokingly  they  called  her  *  Bin  bashi 
(Major)  Martha.'  However,  they  realized  that 
the  things  she  demanded  were  reasonable  and 
necessary  for  the  good  of  the  work. 

"  In  spite  of  seemingly  insurmountable  difH- 
culties,  in  a  short  time  there  was  a  marked 
change  in  the  comfort  and  efBciency  of  the  hos- 
pital. The  patients  could  not  find  words  to  ex- 
press their  gratitude,  and  it  was  not  uncommon 
to  hear  an  old  patient  telling  a  new  one  in  re- 
gard to  one  or  the  other  of  us  that  there  was 
*  no  better  doctor  in  the  whole  country  than 
she.'  I  knew  little  about  nursing,  but  I  kept 
the  nurses,  and  even  the  doctors  sometimes,  at- 
tending to  business,  and  I  administered  to  the 


m  A  TUEKISH  HOSPITAL  27 

poor  men  generous  doses  of  cheer  and  encour- 
agement which  I  am  sure  often  did  them  more 
good  than  the  stuff  the  doctors  prescribed  with- 
out knowing  what  was  the  matter  with  them. 
The  medicines  ordered  were  given  or  not,  ac- 
cording to  the  temper  of  the  head  druggist,  who 
altered  prescriptions  to  suit  himself.  Some  days 
no  medicines  were  given  at  all  because  there 
was  no  one  in  the  drug  room  who  had  skill  or 
inclination  to  prepare  them. 

**  One  of  the  duties  I  enjoyed  most  was  choos- 
ing patients  to  be  sent  to  the  American  hospital. 
Dr.  Ussher  had  Red  Cross  funds  for  caring  for 
a  certain  number  of  soldiers  in  his  hospital  and 
I  had  to  see  that  the  number  wafe  kept  filled  up. 
Sister  Martha  and  I  usually  chose  the  ones  who, 
we  thought,  had  little  chance  of  recovery  if  they 
remained  where  they  were.  The  doctors  were 
always  glad  to  get  rid  of  troublesome  cases. 

"  Every  evening  I  went  to  see  how  the  men 
liked  their  new  quarters.  After  a  real  bath, 
clean  bed,  clean  clothes,  they  looked  like  differ- 
ent beings.  As  soon  as  I  appeared  all  would 
begin  to  talk  at  once.  *  We  never  knew  there 
was  such  a  place  as  this  on  earth.  This  is 
heaven.    Just  look  at  us,  we  are  clean  and  we 


28  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

have  had  enough  to  eat  to-day.  They  give  us 
all  we  want,  and  it  is  so  good !  God  grant  you 
life  for  your  kindness  to  us ! ' 

"  We  had  been  told  at  the  beginning  that  we 
must  make  no  attempt  to  change  the  religion  of 
the  Moslem  patients,  but  for  a  long  time  we 
were  allowed  to  give  out  portions  of  Scripture 
to  them  to  read.  These  were  very  eagerly 
sought  for,  and  the  few  who  could  read  were 
kept  busy  reading  aloud  to  the  others.  The 
doctor  who  had  permitted  this  left  for  the  front 
after  a  time  and  the  next  morning  the  superin- 
tendent of  the  hospital  collected  all  the  books 
and  tracts  and  would  not  allow  us  to  give  others. 
The  men  often  asked  us  what  salary  we  were 
receiving  from  the  government  for  our  services, 
and  they  could  not  comprehend  why  we  should 
be  working  for  nothing  for  the  Turkish  Gov- 
ernment. This  gave  us  the  opportunity  we 
sought  of  telling  them  of  the  love  of  Christ,  and 
that  we  were  serving  them  because  of  that 
love." 


IV 

DURING  THE  SIEGE 

"^"^  THEN,  in  compliance  with  Djevdet 
^y^  Bey's  request,  we  decided,  April 
I7th,  to  stay  both  night  and  day 
at  the  hospital  for  a  time,  we  were  given  very 
comfortable  quarters,  a  large,  sunny  room 
in  a  house  next  the  hospital.  The  superintend- 
ent was  obliged  to  furnish  rugs  from  his  own 
home  and  I  believe  some  of  the  furniture  was 
his.  A  soldier  was  assigned  to  wait  on  us,  which 
he  did  very  nicely,  when  he  was  not  away  bury- 
ing his  father-in-law  or  attending  to  some  other 
business.  Of  food  we  did  not  have  a  great  vari- 
ety— meat,  milk  and  cooking  butter  in  abun- 
dance, and  occasionally  other  things.  We  had 
to  eat  the  hospital  bread,  there  was  no  other — 
dark,  half-baked  stuff  full  of  straw  and  grit.  Our 
enjoyment  of  it  did  not  increase  when  we  saw  it 
thrown  upon  the  ground  in  dirty  sacks  from  the 

same  wagon  in  which  the  bodies  of  the  dead 

29 


30  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

soldiers  were  taken  to  the  graveyard.  We  fried 
it  and  ate  it  and  tried  to  forget.  We  knew  that 
Djevdet  Bey  was  anxious  to  have  us  made  as 
comfortable  as  possible,  but  we  did  not  know 
until  it  was  too  late  that  he  occasionally  sent  us 
dainties  for  our  table.  The  chief  doctor  ate 
them  and  told  us  afterwards  what  a  good  dinner 
he  had  had. 

"  The  siege  of  Van  began  on  the  20th  of 
April,  1915,  early  in  the  morning.  We  could 
hear  the  cracking  of  the  rifles,  seemingly  from 
every  direction,  and  the  booming  of  the  cannon 
as  they  fired  from  the  old  city  '  Castle '  down 
onto  the  houses  in  the  walled  city  in  a  vain 
effort  to  destroy  them.  The  singing  of  the  bul- 
lets at  night  as  they  came  near  our  quarters 
forced  us  to  abandon  our  beds  near  the  win- 
dows and  sleep  on  the  floor.  During  the  first 
day  or  two  we  found  it  hard  to  work  or  to  rest. 
We  pictured  our  Armenian  friends  as  being 
driven  from  their  homes  and  cruelly  murdered 
without  being  able  to  defend  themselves.  Then 
an  Armenian  doctor,  who  was  being  held  at  the 
hospital  as  a  prisoner,  told  us  how  the  Arme- 
nians had  prepared  themselves  for  what  they 
knew    must    come    before    long.      Later    the 


DURING  THE  SIEGE  31 

wounded  Turkish  soldiers  who  were  brought  to 
the  hospital  often  said,  '  This  is  no  way  to  fight. 
We  can  do  nothing  against  these  Armenians. 
They  fight  from  behind  the  walls  of  their  houses 
where  we  cannot  see  them  and  we  don't  know 
where  to  shoot.  We  are  in  plain  sight  in  the 
streets  and  they  shoot  us  down.'  Upon  that  we 
felt  better. 

"  During  the  siege  we  received  a  call  or  two 
from  a  man  calling  himself  a  German  officer. 
As  I  remember  him,  he  wore  the  uniform  of  a 
Turkish  captain.  He  told  us  that  he  was  a  na- 
tive of  Venezuela,  had  been  in  Alaska  and  had 
been  a  cowboy  on  our  own  Western  plains.  He 
had  also  been  to  school  in  Germany  and  claimed 
to  have  a  commission  in  the  German  army. 
One  day  he  sent  a  note  to  Sister  Martha,  who 
immediately  said,  '  This  settles  it.  He  is  not  a 
German  officer,  for  no  man  who  writes  German 
like  this  would  ever  receive  a  commission  in  our 
army.' 

"  From  his  own  story  we  knew  that  he  di- 
rected the  bombardment  of  the  walled  city,  but 
he  acknowledged  that  it  had  not  been  a  very 
successful  piece  of  work. 

"  *  The   cannon-balls   go   through   the   thick 


32  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

mud  walls  of  the  houses  without  destroying 
them,  and  the  Armenians  are  grateful  to  us  for 
having  made  another  opening  for  them  to  shoot 
us  through/  His  contempt  for  the  Turks  was 
great,  and  we  could  not  keep  from  laughing  as 
he  told  how  the  men  went  about  carrying  ex- 
plosives in  their  arms  and  lighted  cigarettes  in 
their  mouths.  Some  of  the  awful  wrecks  of  men 
we  saw  who  had  been  blown  up  by  their  own 
cannon  or  ammunition  proved  that  the  common 
soldiers  did  not  fully  understand  the  nature  of 
the  materials  with  which  they  had  to  deal. 

"  Captain  de  Nogales,  as  he  called  himself, 
was  evidently  a  '  soldier  of  fortune,*  adding  to 
his  already  varied  experiences  by  helping  the 
Turks  exterminate  the  Armenians.  There  was 
a  large  mirror  in  the  room.  At  the  close  of  each 
call  the  captain  would  bid  us  good-bye  with  a 
handshake  and  a  low  bow,  then  straighten  up, 
click  his  heels  in  true  German  fashion,  salute 
his  own  reflection  in  the  mirror,  turn,  bow  to  us 
again  and  march  out.  His  stay  in  Van  was 
short,  and  then  he  was  off  in  search  of  new 
adventures. 

"  The  one  spring-wagon  was  kept  busy  bring- 
ing the  wounded   to  the  hospital   and   Sister 


DTJEING  THE  SIEGE  33 

Martha  and  I  were  often  kept  in  the  operating 
room  until  nine  or  ten  at  night  without  any 
supper,  working  with  the  Armenian  surgeon  on 
the  men  who  needed  immediate  operations. 
The  Turkish  doctor,  who  was  supposed  to  be  at 
the  head  of  things,  usually  left  before  dark. 
Sister  Martha  never  thought  about  herself,  but 
always  and  only  how  she  could  relieve  the  suf- 
ferings of  others,  and  often  she  was  so  weak 
that  she  could  scarcely  climb  the  stairs  to  our 
room.  Sometimes  she  was  in  such  great  pain 
that  she  would  sink  to  the  floor  unable  to  stand 
up.  No  one  besides  myself  knew  of  the  trouble 
that  caused  this  suffering,  and  she  never  allowed 
it  to  interfere  with  her  work. 

"  The  Turks  were  furious  against  the  Arme- 
nians, and  always  glad  to  find  some  new  proof 
of  their  *  treachery.'  The  doctors  said,  *  See 
what  kind  of  men  your  Armenians  are  *  when 
one  or  two  were  brought  in  wounded  by  dum- 
dum, or  by  poisoned  bullets.  They  stopped 
talking  when  we  told  them  that  each  one  of  the 
men  thus  wounded  had  been  shot  by  mistake  by 
Turkish  soldiers. 

"  Djevdet  Bey's  *  ten  days '  passed,  and  still 
another  ten,  and  the  end  seemed  no  nearer  than 


34  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

at  the  first.  Suddenly  there  began  the  hurried 
transfer  of  patients  across  the  lake  to  Bitlis, 
We  were  told  that  this  was  only  to  make  room 
for  other  patients,  but  before  many  days  they 
said  that  the  hospital  was  to  be  abandoned,  and 
asked  Sister  Martha  and  me  if  we  would  go  to 
Bitlis  to  help  there.  Before  making  our  decision 
we  called  on  the  Governor,  who  expressed  deep 
appreciation  of  all  we  had  done  and  a  desire  that 
we  might  see  fit  to  continue  our  services  in 
Bitlis.  However,  he  promised  to  do  all  in  his 
power  to  get  us  safely  through  to  the  Armenian 
Hnes  if  we  wished,  where  a  white  flag  would  in- 
sure safe  conduct  to  our  homes.  One  of  the  of- 
ficials suggested  that  we  would  be  obliged  to 
sign  a  paper  to  the  effect  that  we  went  at  our 
own  desire,  thus  absolving  the  Turkish  Govern- 
ment from  all  responsibility  in  case  anything 
happened  to  us.  The  remark  helped  us  to  de- 
cide that  it  was  best  to  go  with  the  patients. 
On  our  return  to  the  hospital  this  decision  was 
strengthened  by  the  Armenian  workers  who 
came  and  begged  us  again  not  to  leave  them  or 
they  would  all  be  killed.** 


ACROSS  THE  LAKE  TO  BITLIS 

"  X  SEEM  to  be  unable  to  recall  dates,  but  I 
I  know  we  left  Van  on  a  Thursday  or  Fri- 
day night  about  the  middle  of  May,  1915. 
We  had  very  little  baggage — only  one  change 
of  clothing  and  a  little  bedding.  Our  food  con- 
sisted mostly  of  a  lot  of  hospital  bread  fried. 
We  left  the  hospital  in  the  ambulance  and  had 
to  go  a  roundabout  way  to  get  to  the  place 
where  the  boats  were  waiting  in  order  to  avoid 
passing  too  near  the  city  gate,  where  the  enemy 
might  be  lying  in  wait.  It  was  dark  as  Egypt 
and  we  had  to  walk  a  long  way  through  the 
sand  on  the  lake  shore  before  we  finally  found 
the  boats.  By  the  aid  of  a  feeble  lantern  we 
clambered  up  one  gangplank  across  a  sailboat 
and  down  another  narrow,  springy  board  onto 
the  deck  of  the  little  gasoline  launch  that  was 
to  carry  us  across  the  lake. 

"  Although  we  were  told  that  they  had  been 
35 


36  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

waiting  only  for  us,  it  was  after  two  o'clock  in 
the  morning  before  we  were  under  way.  What 
caused  the  delay  we  never  knew,  but  the  cap- 
tain had  to  go  several  times  to  consult  with  the 
Governor,  who  lived  some  distance  away. 

*'  Djevdet  Bey  had  given  written  orders  that 
no  one  was  to  be  carried  on  the  motor-boat  ex- 
cept the  two  Schwesters  and  the  two  doctors, 
but  we  found  the  cabin  occupied  by  a  Turkish 
family  who  also  had  private  permission  from 
the  Governor  to  go  with  us  and  naturally  they 
intended  to  avail  themselves  of  it.  Sister 
Martha  and  I  were  invited  to  share  the  cabin 
with  them,  but  as  there  seemed  to  be  not  even 
standing  room  inside  we  declined  as  politely  as 
possible.  But  our  bedding  was  on  one  of  the 
sailboats,  it  was  bitterly  cold  and  we  did  not 
look  forward  with  any  enthusiasm  to  a  night  on 
deck  sailing  across  Lake  Van.  Finally  the  cap- 
tain gave  us  his  cabin.  It  was  a  tiny  place  with 
wooden  benches  a  foot  wide  on  three  sides  and 
not  long  enough  to  let  one  stretch  out.  How- 
ever, we  managed  to  get  a  little  sleep,  and  at 
daylight  we  were  on  deck  again.  The  sea  was 
calm  and  beautiful  and  as  a  good  breeze  was 
blowing,  the  eight  large  sailboats  with  us  (fiv^ 


ACROSS  THE  LAKE  TO  BITLIS  37 

filled  with  hospital  patients  and  three  with 
Turkish  families  fleeing  from  the  oncoming 
Russians)  went  along  at  a  good  pace. 

"  Later  our  boat  stopped  at  an  island  on 
which  there  was  a  large  Armenian  monastery. 
We  climbed  the  hill  eagerly  with  visions  of  a 
good  breakfast  of  eggs  and  milk  and  bread, 
which  the  priests  always  willingly  prepared  for 
travellers  stopping  there.  We  had  difficulty  in 
gaining  admission  into  the  building,  which  was 
a  most  unusual  experience ;  when  we  got  in  we 
found  two  aged  priests  who  seemed  dazed  and 
either  unable  or  unwilling  to  talk,  and  who  re- 
fused to  give  us  anything  to  eat.  At  last  we 
gathered  that  the  day  before  a  lot  of  Turkish 
soldiers  had  come  to  the  island,  killed  one  or 
more  of  the  priests  and  some  of  the  orphan  boys 
and  carried  off  all  the  sheep  and  chickens  and 
everything  eatable  in  the  place.  In  the  church 
we  found  everything  overturned.  Vestments 
and  other  articles  used  in  the  church  services 
were  scattered  about  on  the  floor,  torn,  broken 
and  destroyed.  Silver  crosses  had  been  carried 
away,  every  scrap  of  silver  or  gold  had  been 
torn  ofiF  the  mitres  and  other  articles;  not  one 
thing  of  value  was  to  be  found  anywhere. 


38  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

"  As  we  sorrowfully  walked  back  to  the  boat, 
the  captain,  who  was  furious  at  the  ruin  we  had 
seen,  told  me  that  on  his  last  trip  he  had  carried 
orders  from  Djevdet  Bey  to  the  soldiers  that 
the  island  and  its  inhabitants  were  to  be  left 
unmolested.  Evidently  this  was  one  of  the 
orders  of  which  we  heard  more  later,  issued 
with  the  additional  information  that  the  recipi- 
ent was  free  to  use  his  own  judgment  about 
obeying  it. 

"  The  morning  was  not  very  far  advanced 
when  the  wind  died  down  entirely,  a  very  com- 
mon occurrence  on  Lake  Van,  and  the  sailboats 
were  unable  to  go  on.  Leaving  the  sails  un- 
furled to  catch  any  little  breeze  that  might  come 
along,  the  sailors  plied  the  heavy,  clumsy  oars 
in  a  vain  attempt  to  reach  Tadvan,  the  seaport 
of  Bitlis,  before  night.  Had  it  not  been  for  the 
motor-boat  the  poor  men  would  have  had  to  go 
hungry  all  day,  as  all  the  bread  for  the  trip  was 
on  one  boat.  We  went  back  and  forth  distribut- 
ing bread,  and  then  stopped  the  motor,  for 
strict  orders  had  been  given  the  captain  that  he 
was  to  remain  with  the  sailboats  until  they 
reached  their  destination.  Not  a  drop  of  water 
had  been  provided  for  the  journey,  and  as  the 


ACEOSS  THE  LAKE  TO  BITLIS  39 

sun  grew  hotter  the  cries  of  the  men  that  they 
would  die  of  thirst  grew  more  and  more  insist- 
ent. Finally  the  captain  declared  he  could  stand 
it  no  longer,  and,  orders  or  no  orders,  he  was 
going  for  water.  In  a  short  time  we  reached 
Tadvan,  where  he  gathered  up  all  the  jugs  he 
could  find  in  the  town,  filled  them,  and,  leaving 
us  on  shore,  returned  to  the  sailboats  and  their 
passengers. 

**  Tadvan  was  full  of  soldiers,  some  of  them 
displaying  and  mocking  at  the  crosses  and  other 
dedicated  things  they  had  taken  from  the  island 
monastery.  The  villagers  were  frightened  and 
crowded  around  us.  We  tried  to  calm  them  by 
saying  that  the  government  had  assured  us  that 
there  would  be  no  massacres  in  the  Bitlis 
province.  Armenians,  like  the  Van  Armenians, 
who,  according  to  official  report,  had  rebelled, 
must  be  punished,  but  those  who  were  loyal  to 
the  government  had  nothing  to  fear.  Some  of 
the  people  had  escaped  from  near-by  villages  in 
the  Van  province  and  their  minds  were  full  of 
the  horrors  through  which  they  had  lived. 

"  The  sailboats  anchored  at  a  village  not  far 
from  Tadvan.  We  went  over  there  the  next 
day  to  do  what  we  could  for  our  patients  while 


40  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

waiting  for  ox-carts  to  take  us  to  Bitlis.  We 
took  up  our  abode  in  one  end  of  a  large  stable, 
billeted  our  men  in  village  homes  and  fixed  up 
a  place  out-of-doors  for  dressing  wounds.  One 
man  was  found  whose  arm  had  to  be  amputated 
at  once.  We  contrived  a  table  just  inside  the 
stable  door  from  the  two  boxes  which  contained 
instruments  and  other  supplies.  The  man  was 
not  very  tall,  but  in  order  that  his  head  might 
rest  on  the  '  table/  his  legs  had  to  hang  over 
the  other  end.    The  operation  was  successful. 

"  During  the  day  Sister  Martha  and  I  were 
startled  by  a  strange  sound  that  seemed  to 
come  from  behind  a  hill  some  distance  away, 
and  drew  nearer  and  nearer.  Then  a  crowd  of 
fifty  or  more  people  appeared  approaching  the 
village,  half  chanting,  half  wailing,  in  the  pecul- 
iar way  Armenians  have  of  showing  grief  and 
telling  their  troubles.  When  they  saw  soldiers 
about  they  left  the  road,  sat  down  on  the  hillside 
and,  rocking  back  and  forth,  and  wringing  their 
hands,  they  repeated  over  and  over,  after  the 
manner  of  their  race,  the  story  of  the  awful 
massacre  that  had  taken  place  in  their  village 
the  day  before.  Wives  and  mothers  told  how 
their  little   babies  had  been   killed   and   their 


ACEOSS  THE  LAKE  TO  BITLIS  41 

bodies  thrown  into  the  lake  and  others  had  been 
thrown  in  alive,  and  how  their  attractive  brides 
and  daughters  had  been  carried  off  by  the 
Kurds.  When  they  were  calm  enough  to  speak 
coherently  they  said  that  the  attacking  party 
had  not  been  one  of  Turkish  soldiers  but  of 
Kurds  who  claimed  to  have  come  from  the 
Erzerum  region  and  who  said  that  the  Russians 
had  carried  off  their  sheep  and  cattle,  and  so 
they  were  making  good  their  losses  by  carrying 
away  the  property  of  the  Armenians.  Russians 
and  Armenians  were  both  Christians,  so  it  was 
all  the  same. 

"  There  was  but  one  man  in  this  group  of  sur- 
vivors, and  he  was  badly  wounded,  as  were  most 
of  the  women  and  some  of  the  children.  After 
having  their  wounds  dressed  they  went  on  their 
way  again  towards  Bitlis,  where  they  expected 
to  complain  to  the  government  and  demand  pro- 
tection and  redress.  They  had  no  idea  that  the 
affair  had  been  ordered  by  the  government. 

"  We  were  obliged  to  spend  several  days  in 
this  village.  One  day  we  saw  a  small  party  of 
Kurds  evidently  reconnoitering  above  the  place. 
A  soldier  was  sent  out  to  inquire  their  business, 
and  then  they  went  back  in  the  direction  from 


42  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

which  they  had  come.  They  had  come  to  raid 
this  village  also,  but  postponed  it  on  account  of 
our  presence.  They  did  not  go  far  away,  for  we 
were  hardly  out  of  sight  on  our  return  to  Tad- 
van  before  they  began  their  work  of  murder 
and  destruction. 

"  Another  night  had  to  be  passed  in  Tadvan. 
The  people  were  even  more  terror  stricken  than 
before,  and  several  crowded  into  the  stable 
where  we  spent  the  night,  hoping  for  greater 
protection.  All  night  long  we  heard  shooting 
and  were  assured  that  it  was  only  the  soldiers 
fighting  to  protect  the  Christian  villagers  from 
attacking  parties  of  Kurds. 

"  Our  caravan  during  the  last  stage  of  our 
journey  to  Bitlis  consisted  of  several  ox-carts 
loaded  as  heavily  as  possible  with  boxes  and 
bedding,  a  patient  or  two  on  top,  the  weakest 
bound  on.  It  was  fearful  to  watch  the  carts  in 
front  of  us  lurching  this  way  and  that  as  the 
wheels  went  over  big  stones  or  into  ruts  in 
the  road.  The  poor  fellows  with  no  strength  to 
help  themselves  cried  out  in  fear.  We  were 
powerless  to  help  matters. 

"  We  kept  passing  groups  of  mounted  Kurds 
going  to  or  returning  from  their  work  of  de- 


ACEOSS  THE  LAKE  TO  BITLIS  43 

struction.  Upon  the  hillsides  groups  of  men 
were  making  trenches.  At  the  entrance  to  the 
city  we  were  stopped  and  taken  to  a  poHce  sta- 
tion, where  a  very  careful  account  was  recorded 
of  each  one.  Sister  Martha  and  I  were  regis- 
tered as  '  German  doctors.'  The  question  of 
how  to  dispose  of  us  properly  seemed  to  be  an 
embarrassing  one  until  I  announced  that  I  was 
an  American  and  we  expected  to  be  cared  for  at 
the  American  mission. 

"  We  had  sent  a  telegram  the  day  before  from 
Tadvan  telling  of  our  coming,  and  Miss  Ely  and 
Mr.  Knapp  had  ridden  out  in  the  afternoon  to 
meet  us.  Naturally  our  failure  to  appear  had 
caused  some  little  anxiety,  and  when  we  did  ar- 
rive, wet,  hungry  and  exhausted,  we  received  a 
hearty  welcome.  No  one  who  has  not  been 
through  a  similar  experience  could  possibly  im- 
agine what  it  meant  to  us  to  be  once  more  in  a 
quiet  Christian  home,  eating  a  well-cooked, 
nicely  served  dinner  after  four  weeks  of  con- 
stant association  with  Turkish  soldiers  and 
officers." 


VI 

TWELVE  THOUSAND  REFUGEES  IN  BITLIS 

MISS  McLaren  and  Sister  Martha  ar- 
rived in  Bitlis  five  days  after  the 
departure  of  Mr.  and  Mrs.  Maynard 
and  Miss  Uline.  In  that  short  interval  deporta- 
tions and  massacres  had  begun  in  the  province, 
and  Armenians,  mostly  women  and  children, 
driven  from  their  homes  by  Kurds  acting  under 
the  orders  of  the  government,  began  pouring 
into  the  city.  About  seven  hundred  took  refuge 
on  the  American  premises. 

The  compound  was  rather  small  and  sur- 
rounded by  a  high  stone  wall  with  gabled  top. 
A  great  arched  gateway  opened  upon  the  street; 
its  huge,  double-leaved  wooden  doors  were 
closed  at  night,  barred  with  four  heavy  iron  bars 
and  bolted  with  a  wooden  beam  about  six  inches 
square.  This  form  of  safeguarding  homes  or 
schools  was  common  throughout  the  city,  and 
windows  everywhere  were  cross-barred  with 
inch-thick  iron  rods. 

44 


REFUGEES  IN  BITLIS  46 

There  were  four  buildings  in  this  enclosure; 
the  large  church,  the  girls'  schoolhouse,  the 
boys*  schoolhouse  and  the  Maynards'  residence, 
occupied  after  their  departure  by  Mr.  Knapp. 
Unfortunately  the  other  missionary  residence, 
though  very  near  the  compound,  was  separated 
from  it  by  the  right  of  way  of  a  Turkish  neigh- 
bour so  that  its  occupants  had  to  pass  through 
the  public  street  to  schools,  church  and  the 
home  of  their  associates,  a  procedure  most  in- 
convenient and  even  unsafe  in  times  of  political 
unrest. 

This  house  had  belonged  to  Rev.  and  Mrs. 
George  C.  Knapp,  who  had  been  missionary 
pioneers  in  Bitlis,  and  it  had  also  been  the 
home  of  Miss  Charlotte  Ely  for  the  greater 
part  of  the  forty-seven  years  she  had  spent  in 
this  city.  With  her  lived  Miss  Myrtle  O.  Shane, 
now  in  charge  of  the  girls*  school,  and  Miss 
McLaren  and  Sister  Martha  became  her  guests. 

Reports  came  in  every  day  of  the  destruction 
of  this  village  and  that  in  the  neighbourhood  of 
Bitlis.  The  Governor,  when  appealed  to  by  the 
missionaries,  pretended  to  be  greatly  troubled 
by  all  this  lawlessness,  which  he  attributed  to  a 
noted  Kurdish  brigand,  and  declared  he  was 


46  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

making  every  effort  to  put  an  end  to  it.  Yet 
crowds  of  old  men,  women  and  children  con- 
tinued to  flee  terror-stricken  to  Bitlis  until  there 
were  about  12,000  in  the  city.  Some  were  cared 
for  in  an  Armenian  church,  and  the  chief  priest 
of  the  city  had  rehef  funds  which  he  distributed 
every  day.  Eight  thousand  were  allotted  to  the 
Americans;  Mr.  Knapp  soon  used  up  what  relief 
funds  he  had  and  telegraphed  Constantinople 
for  more.  Even  when  this  was  received  there 
was  only  enough  to  allow  each  person  a  very 
small  sum  daily,  barely  enough  to  keep  her  alive. 
Many  of  these  refugees  were  wounded;  one 
little  fellow  six  or  seven  years  old  had  four  or 
five  wounds,  some  penetrating  the  lungs,  made 
by  a  dagger  in  the  hand  of  a  Moslem;  a  little 
girl  had  her  arm  shattered  by  a  Turkish  bullet — 
instances  could  be  many  times  multiplied.  The 
superintendent  of  the  hospital  gave  the  neces- 
sary supplies  for  treating  these  wounded  people 
and  a  place  to  house  them.  The  "women's 
hospital  "  was  known  to  the  police  and  so  was 
never  molested,  and  the  number  of  poor  crea- 
tures who  sought  refuge  and  healing  increased 
until  larger  quarters  had  to  be  found. 

The  wounded  Turks  brought  from  Van  had 


EEPUGEES  IN  BITLIS  47 

been  put  into  an  old  monastery  outside  the  city, 
but  the  arrangement  did  not  prove  satisfactory; 
the  monastery  was  turned  into  a  convalescent 
home  and  the  surgical  cases  brought  into  Ar- 
menian houses  near  the  mission  premises,  from 
which  the  owners  were  ejected.  The  chief  doc- 
tor sent  orders  that  the  Protestant  church  was 
to  be  turned  over  to  the  hospital  authorities  at 
once.  Mr.  Knapp  refused  to  do  this  without  a 
written  request  from  the  VaH.  Later,  the  mis- 
sionaries invited  the  doctor  to  an  afternoon  tea 
at  the  Ely  residence,  and  when  some  of  Miss 
Ely's  delicious  cake  had  made  him  relax  a  little 
from  his  unfriendly  attitude,  they  formally  of- 
fered him  the  use  of  the  church  for  hospital  pur- 
poses. Miss  McLaren  and  Sister  Martha  con- 
tinued to  work  among  these  patients  as  they 
had  in  Van. 

Early  in  June  the  refugees  were  gathered  up 
and  driven  through  the  streets  by  gendarmes. 
From  the  bluff  overlooking  the  southern  road 
great  numbers  of  them  could  be  seen  herded  to- 
gether in  readiness  to  be  sent  south. 

"  These  ignorant  village  Armenians  are  not 
fit  to  live — they  ought  to  die/'  said  a  Turkish 
doctor  to  Mr.  Knapp  in  the  presence  of  all  the 


48  THE  TEAGBDY  OF  BITLIS 

Americans.  And  very  soon  reports  were 
brought  back  by  women  and  children  who  es- 
caped that  the  refugees  were  being  killed  by 
Kurds  on  the  road.  One  woman,  fingers  shot 
off  and  a  gash  on  her  face,  said  that  the  gen- 
darmes had  told  the  party  in  which  she  was 
taken  that  at  a  certain  point  farther  on  the 
Kurds  would  attack  them.  This  was  not  a 
warning,  for  those  who  tried  to  escape  were 
shot  down.  Mr.  Knapp  and  the  native  pastor 
asked  the  Vali  to  allow  these  deported  people  to 
go  by  the  Moush  road  to  avoid  Kurdish  attacks. 
He  replied  that  the  Moush  region  was  quiet  and 
must  remain  so. 

There  was  an  epidemic  of  typhus.  Five  or  six 
of  the  refugees  on  the  mission  premises  died 
every  day;  at  first  their  bodies  were  buried  in  a 
garden  across  the  street,  but  later  this  was  not 
permitted  and  they  had  to  be  buried  in  the 
mission  compound.  In  digging  these  graves  the 
bones  were  unearthed  of  many  who  had  lost 
their  lives  in  the  massacre  of  1895  and  who  had 
been  buried  here  to  keep  at  least  their  dead 
bodies  inviolate  from  their  murderers. 


VII 

MASSACRE  OF  THE  MEN 

THE  government  officials  constantly  as- 
sured the  Americans  that  only  the  vil- 
lages near  the  border  wert  being 
evacuated  and  that  no  harm  would  come  to  any 
one  in  the  city. 

The  Russians  v^rere  reported  to  be  drav^ing 
nearer  every  day;  the  authorities  had  made 
their  preparations  to  set  fire  to  the  principal 
buildings  and  leave  on  short  notice.  A  band  of 
Kurds  from  Motgan,  notorious  as  men  who  had 
always  defied  the  government,  came  to  the  city 
one  day,  and  when  they  left  each  was  equipped 
with  a  modern  rifle  and  plenty  of  ammunition. 

Neither  the  Americans  nor  the  Armenians 
then  suspected  a  massacre  ordered  by  the  gov- 
ernment, but  they  had  no  doubts  as  to  what  the 
Motgan  Kurds  would  do  as  soon  as  the  garrison 
should  be  withdrawn.  Armenians  begged  to  be 
allowed  to  come  to  the  American  premises  for 
protection.     A   general   permission   to   do   so 

49 


60  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

would  inevitably  have  created  a  panic  and  pre- 
cipitated trouble  with  the  authorities,  but  the 
famiUes  of  the  pastor  and  teachers  and  a  few 
others  were  allowed  to  come  quietly  and  others 
were  promised  admittance  in  case  of  actual 
danger.  The  condition  was  made  that  all  fire- 
arms of  those  admitted  should  be  turned  over 
to  Mr.  Knapp. 

On  June  22d  Rev.  Khachig  Vartanian,  who 
had  been  pastor  of  the  Protestant  church  and 
ofhcial  representative  of  the  Protestant  commu- 
nity before  the  government  for  many  years,  one 
of  the  most  influential  and  deeply  respected  citi- 
zens of  Bitlis,  was  seized  and  imprisoned  while 
on  his  way  to  the  Vali  on  behalf  of  some  refu- 
gees. 

On  June  23d  the  American  premises  were  sur- 
rounded by  armed  soldiers  and  police.  Mr. 
Knapp  was  in  the  Maynard  house,  now  his  own 
residence,  and  the  four  ladies  in  Miss  Ely's 
house.  Feeling  that  if  anything  was  going  ta 
happen  her  place  was  in  the  girls'  school,  Miss 
Shane  started  to  go  there,  but  the  guard  at  the 
gate  leading  to  the  street  forced  her  to  return 
at  the  point  of  a  gun. 

Officers  and  soldiers,  armed  to  the  teeth  as  if 


MASSACEE  OF  THE  MEN  51 

they  were  after  a  band  of  robbers  instead  of  a 
few  law-abiding  Armenians,  now  appeared, 
sought  out  and  arrested  every  man  and  every 
boy  over  ten  years  of  age  on  the  mission  prem- 
ises and  Hned  them  up  in  the  school-yard, 
guarded  by  gendarmes  as  if  they  were  criminals. 
One  soldier  was  stationed  on  the  roof  opposite, 
where  he  kept  jumping  about  like  a  monkey, 
his  gun  constantly  pointed  at  the  group. 

Resistance  would  have  been  worse  than  use- 
less; the  possession  and  use  of  firearms  would 
have  sealed  the  fate  not  only  of  the  men  but  of 
the  women  and  children.  The  latter  crowded 
around  their  husbands,  brothers  and  fathers, 
clinging  to  them  and  crying  bitterly. 

"Why  do  you  make  such  a  fuss?  They  are 
only  going  to  be  examined  about  something. 
Of  course  they  are  all  innocent  and  will  soon  be 
back,"  said  the  soldiers. 

Mr.  Knapp  hurried  to  the  Vali,  taking  Sister 
Martha  with  him  in  the  hope  that  a  German 
might  get  at  the  true  meaning  of  the  affair  and 
perhaps  secure  the  men's  release.  The  Vali  re- 
ceived them  in  his  usual  polite  way,  listened 
quietly  to  their  story  and  request  and  then  said 
that  the  government  kn^w  ^hat  letters  from  the 


62  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

enemy  in  Van  had  been  received  by  some  Ar- 
menian or  Armenians  in  Bitlis  and  the  object  of 
arresting  all  the  men  was  to  discover  who  these 
recipients  were.  When  found,  they  would  be 
treated  as  traitors,  while  all  others  would  be  set 
free  as  soon  as  their  innocence  was  established. 
No  resistance  would  be  tolerated;  if  any  were 
attempted  it  would  put  in  immediate  danger  all 
on  the  premises. 

The  men  were  marched  off  to  prison.  A  good 
old  man,  who  had  taught  in  the  school  for  many 
years,  comforted  his  terrified  pupils: 

"Do  not  be  afraid;  they  are  persecuting  us 
for  our  religion,  but  we  shall  remain  faithful  to 
Christ."  A  few  boys  were  sent  back  as  too 
young. 

Throughout  the  city  men  and  boys  were  ar- 
rested, on  the  street,  in  their  shops,  in  their 
homes.  If  a  man  resisted  he  was  killed.  Those 
who  hid  themselves  in  their  houses  and  refused 
to  come  out  were  burned  with  their  families. 

On  one  occasion  a  man  was  discovered  to  be 
hiding  in  a  house,  part  of  which  was  visible  from 
the  windows  of  the  girls'  school.  It  was  as  if 
hounds  had  scented  a  fox.  Turks  ran  yelping 
from  all  directions.    Some  climbed  upon  the  flat 


MASSACRE  OF  THE  MEN  63 

roof  and  leaned  over  with  their  guns  pointing 
downward  in  order  to  have  a  good  chance  at 
him  should  he  try  to  escape.  The  commotion 
lasted  about  two  hours,  but  Miss  Shane,  who 
saw  its  beginning,  did  not  see  its  end. 

In  one  house  where  there  was  a  large  house- 
hold, many  sons  living  with  their  famiUes  in 
their  fathers  home,  according  to  the  patri- 
archal custom  of  the  country,  there  were  ten 
guns  which  were  used  with  telling  effect  against 
the  police. 

It  was  finally  fired  from  the  inside  and  some 
of  its  inmates  burned.  The  rest  retired  to  the 
cellar,  where  they  had  stored  provisions  and 
water  for  a  siege.  The  police  soon  found  out 
that  there  were  people  there  still  alive  and  be- 
gan to  try  to  get  them  out.  Miss  McLaren,  hap- 
pening to  pass  at  the  time,  saw  a  lot  of  soldiers 
on  the  street  with  their  guns  pointed  towards 
the  building.  Police  with  beams  were  trying  to 
batter  down  the  cellar  walls,  always  keeping  out 
of  range  from  the  windows.  In  the  evening  two 
badly  wounded  little  boys  were  brought  from 
that  house  to  Sister  Martha.  The  men  had  been 
obliged  to  surrender  at  last.  The  father,  a 
lawyer  who  had  been  in  the  service  of  the  gov- 


54  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

ernment  many  years,  was  brought  from  the 
prison  to  view  the  remains  of  his  home  and  to 
see  what  it  meant  for  a  subject  to  defy  his  gov- 
ernment. 

This  was  the  strongest  resistance  to  arrest  in 
the  city.  In  most  cases  the  men  went  quietly, 
trusting  that  they  would  soon  be  released.  The 
government  succeeded  perfectly  in  deceiving 
the  people  with  its  assurances.  The  Americans 
also  were  more  than  once  misled  by  its  prom- 
ises. 

All  the  Armenian  nurses,  druggists  and  or- 
derlies in  the  hospital  were  also  taken.  It  mat- 
tered not  that  they  were  the  most  intelligent 
and  faithful  helpers,  and  that  there  was  no  one 
left  to  prepare  medicines  for  the  Turkish  pa- 
tients— all  had  to  go. 

The  first  victim  was  a  young  man  employed 
in  the  military  hospital,  a  graduate  of  Euphrates 
College,  Harpoot.  He  had  tried  to  give  his 
friends  at  home  some  idea  of  the  situation  in 
Bitlis  by  telling  about  the  swarms  of  locusts  that 
had  visited  the  province  shortly  before.  His 
allusion  was  understood  by  the  censor,  he  was 
arrested,  marched  off  under  guard,  and  a  Kurd- 
ish neighbour  told  the  Americans  that  he  was 


MASSACRE  OF  THE  MEN  56 

taken  only  a  short  distance  from  the  city  and 
there  killed. 

There  were  two  Armenian  surgeons  in  the 
city,  young  men,  earnest,  faithful  and  enthusi- 
astic over  their  work,  not  influenced  in  the  per- 
formance of  their  duties  by  the  thought  of  what 
was  being  done  to  their  people.  One  morning 
they  told  Sister  Martha  and  Miss  McLaren  that 
they  had  been  ordered  to  go  to  Sert  to  take 
charge  of  a  hospital  which  Djevdet  Bey  was 
starting  there.  A  Turkish  doctor  later  told  the 
missionaries  that  he  had  seen  their  bodies  lying 
by  the  roadside  about  six  miles  from  the  city. 

Sister  Martha  and  Miss  McLaren  had  brought 
with  them  from  Van  two  Armenian  boys  who 
had  been  working  in  the  military  hospital  there 
and  for  whom  Sister  Martha  had  secured  from 
the  miHtary  authorities  papers  insuring  their 
safety.  When  the  Bitlis  men  were  taken  from 
the  city,  one  of  these  lads  was  ill  in  a  hospital. 
Sister  Martha,  hearing  that  he  had  been  taken 
out  with  the  other  Armenians,  went  to  the  chief 
of  police  to  inform  him  of  these  papers  and  to 
ask  that  the  boy  might  be  sent  back.  The  chief 
said  that  he  would  send  an  order  to  this  effect. 
When  she  went  to  see  him  again  he  told  her  that 


66  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

it  was  impossible  to  bring  the  boy  back,  as  he 
had  been  killed  on  the  day  that  he  was  taken 
out.     His  companion  was  spared. 

For  several  days  the  Protestant  women  took 
food  to  the  prison  and  were  allowed  to  talk 
freely  with  the  men  who  crowded  around  the 
windows.  The  prisoners  sent  word  to  the  mis- 
sionaries that  they  had  done  right  in  not  permit- 
ting weapons  on  the  mission  premises;  that  the 
whole  afifair  had  been  so  fiendishly  planned  by 
the  government  that  there  had  been  no  chance 
of  escape  for  the  men  from  the  first;  they  were 
praying  that  the  efforts  made  to  save  the  women 
and  children  might  succeed. 

After  a  week  of  this  the  women  were  told  one 
morning  that  all  the  Protestants  had  been  put 
into  an  underground  dungeon.  Various  stories 
were  heard  later  as  to  what  happened  to  these 
men,  but  all  that  was  definitely  known  was  that 
they  were  taken  out  in  groups  and  killed  not  far 
from  the  city.  One  story,  the  truth  of  which 
Mr.  Knapp  believed  to  be  well  established,  was 
that  one  group  of  TOO  men  was  taken  out  to  a 
place  about  six  miles  from  the  city  and  lined  up 
on  either  side  of  trenches  already  prepared. 
Kurds  then  came  upon  them  and  killed  them. 


MASSACEE  OF  THE  MEN  57 

Several  of  the  men  on  the  mission  premises 
had  hidden  during  the  first  search  and  so  es- 
caped. One  of  these  was  Kevork  Effendi  Koo- 
yoomjian,  a  graduate  of  Central  College,  Ain- 
tab,  and  head  teacher  in  the  boys'  school.  But 
he  decided  that  he  could  not  hope  to  save  him- 
self and  that  if  he  were  discovered  it  might  work 
harm  to  the  women  and  children  under  the  care 
of  the  missionaries.  He  had  married  but  a  few 
years  before  one  of  the  teachers  in  the  girls' 
school,  a  girl  most  attractive  in  person  and 
lovely  in  character.  Their  courtship  had  been 
a  romantic  one,  their  betrothal  not  the  usual 
businesslike  arrangement  between  two  families, 
but  a  real  "  love  match."  At  her  wedding, 
Heghene,  instead  of  being  shrouded  Oriental 
fashion  in  a  shapeless  dark  silk  mantle,  had 
looked  like  an  American  bride  with  her  lace  veil, 
orange-flower  wreath  and  bridal  bouquet — a 
fair  vision  that  had  impressed  itself  upon  the 
imagination  of  all  the  young  people  who  had 
been  present.  Their  short  married  life  had  been 
a  very  happy  one,  except  for  the  death  of  their 
first  child ;  they  had  at  this  time  a  beautiful  little 
girl  one  year  old. 

The  day  after  Kevork  EflFendi  had  made  his 


58  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

decision  the  police  sent  word  that  they  were 
coming  to  search  the  American  premises  for 
men  who  were  in  hiding.  That  morning  the 
young  couple  spent  several  hours  alone  to- 
gether, then  joined  in  the  main  room  of  the 
school  the  others  who  meant  to  surrender,  and 
waited  calmly  the  event  that  would  too  surely 
separate  them.  She  sat  at  his  feet  with  the  baby 
in  her  arms. 

"  Miss  Shane,  if  we  should  both  be  taken  will 
you  not  keep  our  baby?  "  asked  Kevork  Effendi. 

When  the  police  came  he  and  his  young 
brother-in-law  shook  hands  with  their  friends  as 
composedly  as  if  they  were  merely  going  for  a 
walk,  and  no  one  seeing  the  sweet  look  of  cour- 
age on  Deegeen  Heghene's  face  would  have 
guessed  that  the  man  was  her  husband  and  the 
boy  her  brother.  Kevork  EflFendi  looked  strong 
and  triumphant,  for  although  he  knew  he  was 
going  to  his  death,  the  night  spent  in  prayer 
had  prepared  him  for  his  fate  and  he  had  no 
fear.  Had  those  around  him  had  eyes  to  see 
they  would  have  beheld  one  whose  form  was 
**  like  unto  the  Son  of  God,*'  walking  in  the 
fiery  furnace  beside  him. 


VIII 

DEPORTATION  OF  THE  WOMEN 

^— »-^WO  or  three  days  after  the  men  on  the 
■        American    premises    were    taken    to 


1 


prison  the  Vali  told  Mr.  Knapp  that  an 
order  had  come  for  a  general  deportation  of 
Armenians,  but  that  families  would  be  allowed 
to  go  in  safety  together.  Yet  within  a  few  days 
(June  29th  or  30th)  the  poHce  began  to  hound 
women  and  children  out  of  their  homes,  insult- 
ing and  beating  them  cruelly  and  forcing  by 
kicks  and  blows  and  curses  those  who  fell  by  the 
wayside  to  get  up  and  go  on.  A  few  escaping 
and  coming  back  with  faces  mutilated  and  hands 
cut  off  substantiated  the  rumours  concerning 
the  fate  of  those  who  were  driven  away.  The 
Americans,  whose  premises  were  still  strictly 
guarded,  were  not  allowed  to  take  these  poor 
creatures  in,  but  could  talk  to  them  at  the  gate, 
give  them  bread  and  a  little  money,  and  then 
they  would  be  gathered  up  and  driven  away 
again. 

59 


60  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

Miss  Shane  had  taken  up  her  residence  in  the 
girls'  school  where,  besides  her  girls,  there  were 
a  number  of  women  and  children  who  had  come 
to  her  for  protection.  A  day  or  two  after  their 
deportation  began  she  went  with  Miss  McLaren 
as  interpreter  to  the  Vali  and  requested  that  the 
schoolgirls  and  the  women  with  her  in  the 
school  building  be  allowed  to  remain.  He  said 
that  she  might  take  her  pupils  to  Harpoot  and 
put  them  in  the  school  there.  She  knew  that  the 
school  buildings  in  Harpoot  had  been  taken  by 
the  government  for  hospital  purposes,  and  that 
the  roads  were  covered  with  the  bodies  of  the 
dead ;  she  thought,  too,  of  the  fate  of  the  women 
and  little  children  who  would  be  left  behind,  and 
replied  that  if  he  were  sincere  in  assuring  her 
that  she  could  take  the  girls  safely  to  Harpoot 
he  would  be  willing  to  have  them  remajn  quietly 
in  Bitlis  till  travelling  was  safer.  He  answered 
that  an  order  had  come  from  Constantinople 
that  not  an  Armenian  should  remain  in  Bitlis; 
the  responsibility  was  not  his. 

"  In  that  case  I  will  not  give  them  up,"  she 
answered. 

She  meant  to  barricade  the  school  building. 
It  seemed  necessary  to  take  a  firm  stand  on  this 


DEPORTATION  OF  THE  WOMEN         61 

point,  and  neither  she  nor  her  associates  be- 
lieved that  the  authorities  would  proceed  to  ex- 
tremes to  get  possession  of  these  few  women 
and  girls. 

He  finally  consented  to  allow  the  girls  and 
women  in  the  school  to  remain  "  until  the  last." 
She  asked  to  whom  she  might  appeal  to  insure 
their  ultimate  safety  and  he  gave  her  the  name 
and  address  of  the  military  commandant,  who 
had  decided  the  matter  in  regard  to  the  women. 
This  man  was  at  the  front  with  his  army,  so  Miss 
Shane  immediately  wrote  to  him,  sending  a 
copy  of  the  letter  to  the  Vali  together  with  the 
list  of  her  women  and  girls  which  he  had  de- 
manded of  her.  To  this  letter  no  answer  was 
ever  received. 

The  missionaries  were  obliged  to  promise 
that  no  more  people  should  be  taken  into  the 
compound  and  tried  to  keep  this  promise  as 
their  only  hope  of  saving  a  few. 

The  police  seemed  to  have  gone  mad  in  their 
thirst  for  Armenian  blood.  One  day  Miss  Shane 
saw  from  her  window  a  white-haired  old  woman 
stumbling  along  the  street  beneath  a  rain  of 
blows  from  a  gendarme's  gun.  .A  younger 
woman,  herself  so  weak  she  could  scarcely  walk, 


62  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

was  trying  to  support  her.  Suddenly  the  gen- 
darme sprang  in  front  of  them  and  pointed  his 
bayonet  at  the  old  woman  as  if  to  run  it  through 
her  body.  She  fell  in  a  heap  at  his  feet.  Where- 
upon he  seized  her  first  by  the  girdle  and  then 
by  the  hair  and  dragged  her  along  the  rough 
street.  She  was  left  for  dead  near  the  girls' 
school  and  they  were  allowed  to  take  her  in. 
She  had  a  sweet  and  gentle  face  and  was  found 
to  be  a  member  of  a  well-to-do  family.  Officials 
were  very  angry  when  they  found  how  she  had 
been  treated,  for  she  was  supposed  to  know 
where  a  large  sum  of  money  was  concealed  and 
they  wanted  it.  The  poor  creature  did  not  live 
long  enough  to  tell  her  secret. 

Another  old  woman  died  in  the  school  who 
was  found  lying  in  the  street  outside  with  just 
strength  enough  to  Hft  her  hand  slightly  in  an 
eflFort  to  ward  off  a  dog  who  was  sniffing  at  her 
face.  Several  times  the  missionaries  were  al- 
lowed to  bring  inside  those  who  were  found  in 
a  dying  condition. 

The  screams  of  women  and  children  could  be 
heard  at  almost  any  time  during  the  day.  The 
cries  that  rang  out  through  the  darkness  of  the 
night  were  even  more  heartrending. 


DEPOETATION  OF  THE  WOMEN         63 

"  Once,"  writes  Miss  Shane,  "  I  was  startled 
from  sleep  by  a  woman's  shriek  of  terror,  fol- 
lowed by  cries  and  pleadings  which  were  an- 
swered only  by  the  jeering  laugh  of  men.  For 
about  two  hours  I  could  hear  the  woman's  low 
moans,  like  those  of  a  tortured  animal.  The 
sound  grew  fainter  and  fainter  and  at  last — 
silence. 

"  One  day  I  was  watching  a  crowd  of  women 
and  children  in  the  street  below.  They  were 
led  by  a  gendarme  to  a  spot  just  beneath  the 
window,  then  made  to  stop.  A  few  women  gave 
money  to  the  gendarmes  and  were  then  set  free. 
They  ran  frantically  hither  and  thither  like 
frightened  animals.  Where  could  they  go  for 
safety?  There  zvas  no  safety  for  them.  The 
fiendish  grin  on  the  face  of  the  man  who  had 
released  them  showed  that  he  relished  the  sport. 
This  incident  confirmed  to  my  mind  the  report 
that  gendarmes  accepted  bribes  from  the  women 
who  had  a  bit  of  money,  but  that  these  women 
were  captured  again  later  and  taken  down  the 
road. 

"  By  working  quietly  we  had  managed  to  take 
in  about  thirty  little  children  who  had  come 
starving  to  our  gates  and  the  guards  there  had 


64  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

not  objected.  The  first  few  indeed  had  been 
brought  to  us  by  Turkish  soldiers.  We  felt 
sure  we  should  not  be  able  to  keep  them  but 
would  provide  for  them  as  long  as  possible. 
One  of  these  was  the  daughter  of  our  teacher  in 
Tadvan.  Her  eyes  had  the  deep  blue  of  the  sky 
when  a  storm  is  threatening.  She  was  always 
quiet,  but  so  sweet  that  she  never  passed  un- 
noticed, her  little  face  so  serious,  so  solemn.  So 
were  the  faces  of  all  the  little  ones.  One  of  the 
things  that  impressed  me  most  was  that  the 
little  children  never  smiled,  always  that  look  of 
hurt  wonder  on  their  faces.  In  her  quaint  baby 
fashion  she  once  told  the  girls  the  name  of  the 
Kurd  who  had  killed  her  father,  and  added, 
'  May  he  die  a  death  like  that'  She  was  taken 
ill  after  a  while  and  did  not  recover. 

"  Finally  a  policeman  came  to  take  these 
orphans  away.  Among  them  was  a  little  girl 
between  two  and  three  years  of  age,  a  grand- 
child in  one  of  the  best  families  in  Bitlis.  She 
had  the  sweetest,  most  winning  baby  face  I  have 
ever  seen.  We  had  all  grown  to  love  her. 
When  she  was  put  in  line  with  the  others 
I  rushed  forward,  took  her  up  in  my  arms 
and    begged    to    be    allowed    to    keep    her. 


DEPOETATION  OF  THE  WOMEN         65 

The  policeman  refused.  Her  innocent,  trust- 
ful face  would  have  melted  a  heart  of  stone. 
She  toddled  along  with  the  others,  but  be- 
fore they  reached  the  gate  a  Turk  employed 
in  the  hospital  picked  her  up  and  was  permitted 
to  keep  her.  The  child,  however,  turned  her 
face  from  him  and  wriggled  and  twisted  to  get 
out  of  his  arms.  He  took  her  home  and  his  fam- 
ily tried  to  win  her  by  kindness,  but  she  was 
obdurate.  He  finally  gave  her  into  the  care  of 
one  of  our  women. 

"  As  far  as  I  know,  with  but  one  exception, 
the  choice  of  accepting  Islam  was  not  given  to 
men  and  boys  nor  to  the  poorer  classes  of 
women.  However,  many  of  those  belonging  to 
wealthy  families  were  urged  to  become  Mos- 
lems. Three  women  from  the  principal  ward  of 
the  city  came  to  tell  us  that  if  they  refused  to 
accept  Islam  they  would  be  sent  down  the  road. 
One  of  these  was  the  sister  of  a  teacher  in  our 
girls'  school.  I  was  later  (when  ill  in  bed)  told 
by  one  of  my  teachers  that  this  woman  had  re- 
fused to  accept  Islam  and  had  been  sent  off  with 
her  ten-year-old  daughter,  and  that  both  had 
been  taken  by  Kurds;  the  mother  had  come 
back  to  the  school  accompanied  by  a  Kurdish 


66  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITUS 

woman  and  asked  her  sister  for  ten  liras,  saying 
that  the  Kurds  had  threatened  to  kill  her  daugh- 
ter if  she  did  not  give  that  much  money,  but  if 
she  gave  it  she  would  be  allowed  to  take  her 
daughter  away.  She  received  the  money,  went 
away  and  was  never  heard  of  again. 

"  Some  time  after  my  illness  I  was  calling  on 
a  Turkish  officer's  wife;  she  and  her  husband 
had  shown  kindness  to  Armenians  and  were 
friendly  to  us.  She  said  they  had  found  that 
little  ten-year-old  girl  wandering  in  the  streets 
half  naked  and  in  a  terrible  condition,  having 
been  maltreated  in  most  inhuman  fashion. 
They  had  taken  her  in  and  were  having  an  old 
Armenian  woman  take  care  of  her.  She  said 
also  that  they  themselves  were  out  of  favour 
with  the  government  because  of  their  lack  of 
sympathy  with  the  way  in  which  Armenians 
were  being  treated  and  therefore  were  being 
sent  to  Aleppo. 

"  A  little  innocent-faced  lad,  one  of  our  school- 
boys who  had  found  his  way  back  to  our  prem- 
ises during  the  evacuation  of  the  city,  told  me 
that  he  was  one  of  a  large  party  of  women  and 
children  driven  down  the  road.  He  had  escaped 
a  short  distance  from  the  city  and  came  back  to 


DEPOETATION  OF  THE  WOMEN         67 

the  house  of  a  friendly  Turk.  The  Turk,  how- 
ever, insisted  on  his  becoming  Moslem,  so  he 
ran  away.  Before  his  escape  on  the  road  he  had 
seen  a  young  woman  who  was  carrying  a  baby 
shot  down  because  she  had  not  strength  to  keep 
up  with  the  others.  Her  body  was  left  lying 
where  it  fell,  the  baby  still  in  her  arms. 

"  One  of  our  pupils,  a  girl,  was  sent  to  prison, 
but  later  was  released  and  allowed  to  go  back  to 
the  house  of  Mustifa  Bey,  superintendent  of 
hospitals,  where  she  had  been  staying.  She  told 
me  that  the  prison  was  crowded  with  women 
and  children  kept  there  without  food  or  water.'' 

Many  women  were  kept  in  the  courtyard  of 
an  Armenian  church,  others  in  a  large  house 
just  across  the  street  from  the  American  prem- 
ises and  still  others  were  herded  together  like 
cattle  in  an  open  field  between  the  public  high- 
way and  the  river  at  a  place  called  the  "  Arab 
Bridge,"  not  far  from  the  city.  Soldiers  were 
stationed  near  by  to  guard  them.  There  was  no 
shelter,  no  privacy.  Day  after  day  these  women, 
many  of  them  accustomed  to  comfort  if  not  lux- 
ury in  their  homes,  were  kept  there  in  the  hot 
July  sun  and  entirely  at  the  mercy  of  the  beasts 
who  guarded  them.    A  few  managed  to  escape 


68  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

by  bribing  the  guards,  or  under  cover  of  the 
night,  and  the  stories  they  told  the  missionaries 
of  their  sufferings  at  the  hands  of  the  soldiers 
were  too  awful  to  repeat. 

After  a  while  the  young  and  attractive  women 
were  taken  into  Turkish  or  Kurdish  homes  and 
the  rest  sent  "  down  the  road,"  most  of  them  to 
death.  Many  threw  themselves  and  their  chil- 
dren into  the  river  to  escape  the  suffering  and 
abuse  they  were  unable  to  endure  longer. 

Some  of  the  prominent  citizens  had  provided 
their  families  with  poison,  which  they  took 
rather  than  fall  into  the  hands  of  the  Turks. 
Other  women  with  their  children  refused  to 
leave  their  burning  houses,  counting  that  kind 
of  death  preferable  to  life  in  a  Turkish  harem. 
The  thirteen-year-old  daughter  of  Pastor 
Khachig,  seeing  a  bottle  marked  "  Poison  "  in 
Miss  McLaren's  room,  told  the  women  in  the 
house,  "  There  is  a  bottle  of  poison  in  Miss 
McLaren's  room,  and  if  the  Turks  try  to  take 
me  away  I  am  going  to  drink  some." 

The  deportation  of  the  women  began  the  first 
week  in  July.  It  continued  for  months  with 
but  one  week's  interruption. 


IX 

THE  RUSSIAN  ARMY  APPROACHES 

THE  Russian  army,  after  its  occupation 
of  Van,  moved  slowly  westward,  meet- 
ing with  stubborn  resistance  at  many 
points.  The  motor-boat  which  had  brought 
Miss  McLaren  and  Sister  Martha  across  the 
lake  and  one  of  the  large  sailboats  were  loaded 
at  Tadvan  with  ammunition  to  be  taken  back 
to  the  Turkish  army.  They  were  ordered  first 
to  Vostan,  a  town  about  seven  hours  from  Van, 
from  there  ordered  back  across  the  lake  to  a 
village  called  Surp,  not  far  from  Tadvan  and 
near  to  where  a  battle  was  to  be  fought. 

On  arrival  at  Surp  the  captain  and  his  brother 
went  to  report  to  the  authorities,  leaving  the 
boats  in  charge  of  two  Armenian  boatmen,  with 
two  guards  on  shore.  The  boatmen  shot  the 
guards  with  the  captain's  gun  and  sailed  back  to 

the  Russians  with  the  ammunition. 

69 


70  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

The  people  of  the  village  of  Avantz,  the  sea- 
port of  Van,  were  mostly  sailors,  and  whether 
from  choice  or  by  compulsion  had  been  most 
faithful  in  their  service  to  the  government.  Had 
it  not  been  for  them  the  Turks  would  never 
have  been  able  to  transport  their  hospital  pa- 
tients and  equipment  across  the  lake  and  many 
of  the  civil  population  would  have  been  unable 
to  flee  towards  Bitlis  before  the  advancing 
enemy.  When  the  general  massacre  of  April 
19th  took  place  in  Van  province  this  place  was 
left  untouched.  Of  course  the  Turks  reaHzed 
how  much  depended  upon  the  loyalty  of  these 
villagers.  At  the  time  of  the  incident  related 
above  they  had  no  further  use  for  the  boats  and 
sailors,  and  saying  that  they  must  have  revenge 
for  the  murder  of  the  two  soldiers  and  the  loss 
of  the  ammunition,  they  gathered  together  all 
the  boatmen  who  could  be  found  in  Tadvan  and 
drowned  them  in  the  lake. 

About  the  middle  of  July  the  Russian  army 
drew  very  near  to  Bitlis ;  those  living  on  the  out- 
skirts of  the  city  could  hear  the  firing.  The 
Moslem  population  fled.  The  Governor  sent 
word  to  the  Americans  that  they  would  have  to 
go.    But  as  Miss  Shane  was  ill  at  the  time,  they 


THE  EUSSIAN  AEMY  APPEOACHES     71 

decided  to  remain.  They  had  been  constantly 
exposed  to  typhus,  and  Miss  Shane  had  fallen 
ill  on  July  4th. 

It  may  be  noted  in  passing,  that  at  this  very 
time  five  of  the  missionaries  in  Van  also  fell  ill 
of  typhus  which  they  had  contracted  from  Mos- 
lem refugees,  one  thousand  of  whom  they  cared 
for  on  their  premises  after  the  Russian  occupa- 
tion. But  there  was  absolutely  no  communica- 
tion between  the  two  cities;  the  Americans  in 
each  were  quite  ignorant  of  the  condition  of 
their  friends  in  the  other. 

Many  Moslems  when  they  fled  left  with  the 
missionaries  the  women  and  girls  whom  they 
had  taken  into  their  harems,  an  action  that 
seemed  to  show  that  their  intentions  in  the  first 
place  had  been  kind. 

Other  women  who  had  so  far  escaped  capture 
also  fled  to  the  Americans  for  protection  from 
the  Kurds,  who  were  swarming  into  the  city  for 
plunder,  knowing  that  before  the  arrival  of  the 
Russians  they  could  flee  back  to  safe  retreats  in 
the  mountains. 

"  We  told  them  that  the  Governor  had  for- 
bidden our  taking  any  more  Armenians  in,  but 
that  it  seemed  now  the  Governor  himself  would 


72  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

be  leaving  shortly  and  if  they  cared  to  take  their 
chance  with  us,  we  would  do  what  we  could,  but 
if  the  government  should  demand  them  we 
could  probably  not  prevent  their  being  taken. 
They  said  that  if  they  remained  in  the  city  they 
would  undoubtedly  fall  victims  to  the  Kurds  and 
would  take  their  chance  with  us." 

Even  the  soldiers  fled.  The  Turkish  patients 
who  could  be  moved  were  sent  off  towards  Diar- 
bekir,  and  the  others  were  brought  to  the  Prot- 
estant church  and  the  English  Consulate  (a 
near-by  building  which  had  once  been  the  Con- 
sulate), and  were  given  over  to  the  care  of  Mr. 
Knapp  and  Sister  Martha.  American  flags  were 
put  up  over  the  buildings  for  protection.  Later, 
one  of  the  accusations  brought  against  Mr. 
Knapp  was  that  he  had  put  up  flags  to  guide 
the  enemy. 

There  was  a  branch  of  the  Ottoman  bank  in 
Bitlis.  The  bankers,  a  Greek  and  an  Italian, 
afraid  to  remain  in  the  business  district  on  ac- 
count of  the  Kurds,  left  it  and  came  to  stay 
with  Mr.  Knapp.  The  danger  was  so  great  that 
the  Vali,  who  was  still  in  the  city  with  a  few 
ofificers  and  soldiers,  was  asked  for  a  guard  and 
gave  it.    The  bankers  watched  half  of  the  night 


THE  RUSSIAN  ARMY  APPROACHES     73 

and  Mr.  Knapp  the  other  half  for  a  week.  Then 
the  bankers  left  the  city,  telling  the  Americans 
before  they  did  so  that  they  (the  Americans) 
were  in  great  danger  of  being  attacked  by 
Kurds  at  the  instigation  of  the  government  to 
prevent  their  giving  information  to  the  enemy. 

Sister  Martha  was  free  to  act  independently 
of  the  Americans,  of  course,  and  the  Turks  took 
for  granted  that  she  would  leave  with  the  hos- 
pital authorities.  She  had  great  fears  of  becom- 
ing a  prisoner  of  the  Russians  and  the  Ameri- 
cans supposed  she  would  go.  One  morning  she 
came  to  Miss  Shane,  whom  she  had  been  nurs- 
ing, and  said,  "  I've  made  my  decision.  Mustifa 
Bey  just  came  on  his  horse  and  was  surprised 
that  I  was  not  ready  to  go,  but  I  told  him  I 
wasn't  going.  Whatever  may  be  my  fate  in 
Russia  I  will  not  go  one  step  farther  with  the 
Turks." 

A  few  hours  after  it  was  reported  that  the 
Vali  was  on  the  point  of  leaving,  the  news  was 
brought  that  the  Russians  were  retreating. 
Word  was  immediately  sent  out  to  the  fleeing 
populace  to  return  and  by  the  24th  the  Turks 
were  back  again. 


THE  PASSING  OF  MISS  CHARLOTTE  ELY 

THE  shock  of  these  events  proved  too 
great  for  Miss  Charlotte  Ely,  now  in 
her  seventy-sixth  year,  to  endure.  She 
did  her  utmost  to  relieve  and  comfort  the  people 
she  loved,  spending  much  of  her  time  among 
the  village  refugees,  of  whom  many  had  once 
been  her  pupils,  listening  to  their  stories  and 
praying  for  them  most  wonderful  prayers.  But 
she  suffered  so  intensely  through  her  sympathy 
with  them  that  body  and  mind  weakened  under 
the  strain ;  she  sank  into  a  state  of  unconscious- 
ness at  last,  from  which  she  rallied  only  once  or 
twice,  and  on  July  11th  she  passed  beyond  all 
care  and  sorrow. 

Charlotte  and  Mary  Ely,  daughters  of  an 
American  clergyman  and  a  gifted  English 
mother,  were  born  in  America  and  spent  their 
childhood  in  Philadelphia.  Early  orphaned, 
they  were  given  a  home  and  a  very  unusual  edu- 
cation for  those  days  by  their  uncle,  Ezra  S. 

74 


Charlotte   E.   El> 


Alzina    Churchill    Knapp 


Mary  A.  C.  Ely 


Georgc   Perkins   Kiiapp 


THE  PASSING  OF  MISS  CHARLOTTE  ELY    75 

Ely,  of  Buffalo.  He  sent  them  to  Elmira  Col- 
lege and  to  Mt.  Holyoke  Seminary,  whence  they 
graduated  with  the  "  war  class  "  of  *61,  then 
sent  them  abroad.  Charlotte  studied  music  un- 
der famous  masters  in  Heidelberg,  both  studied 
languages  in  Germany  and  France,  visited  Italy, 
where  they  met  Garibaldi,  and  made  the  ac- 
quaintance of  their  mother's  family  in  England. 

At  the  end  of  two  years  they  returned  to 
America.  On  the  home-going  steamer  they  be- 
came acquainted  with  Rev.  and  Mrs.  George  C. 
Knapp,  from  Turkey,  and  this  proved  to  be  a 
turning  point  in  their  lives,  for  their  hearts  were 
deeply  touched  by  what  Mrs.  Knapp  had  to  tell 
them  of  the  narrow,  meager,  burdened  lives  of 
Oriental  women  and  of  the  little  school  she  had 
started  for  girls  in  Bitlis.  Charlotte  promised 
to  find  a  teacher  for  this  school,  but  before  long 
she  decided  to  be  herself  that  teacher;  her  sister 
came  independently  to  the  same  conclusion,  and 
the  two  joined  the  Knapps  on  their  return  to 
Bitlis  in  1868. 

From  the  first  they  were  charmed  with  the 
romantic  situation  of  that  isolated  mountain 
city  and  became  so  deeply  in  love  with  their 
work  there  that  they  could  not  be  induced  to 


76  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

leave  it,  though  more  than  once  Charlotte, 
noted  for  her  executive  and  administrative  abil- 
ity, v^as  asked  to  become  the  head  of  much 
larger  schools  in  (seemingly)  more  important 
missions.  One  v^inter  she  consented  to  take 
charge  of  the  school  in  Van,  but  she  could  be 
torn  av^ay  from  her  Bitlis  home,  even  for  needed 
rest  and  change,  only  against  her  v^ill.  In  her 
forty-seven  years  of  missionary  life  she  re- 
turned to  America  but  twice,  and  in  1915  had 
not  had  a  furlough  for  eighteen  years.  A 
woman  of  private  fortune,  many  friends,  culti- 
vated tastes,  love  for  the  best  in  music,  art,  lit- 
erature, great  capacity  for  enjoyment,  she  gave 
up  without  regret  all  that  civilization  offered 
her,  buried  herself  in  this  remote  corner  of 
Kurdistan  and  devoted  all  her  powers  to  the 
service  of  its  people. 

The  sisters  developed  Mrs.  Knapp's  school 
into  ''The  Mt.  Holyoke  Seminary  of  Bitlis.'* 
Girls  from  the  most  primitive,  sordid  village 
homes ;  girls  from  homes  of  material  prosperity 
but  mental  and  spiritual  vacuity;  wild,  ignorant 
girls  who  had  worked  like  beasts  of  burden  in 
the  fields;  girls  bejewelled  and  petted  whose 
outlook  was  early  marriage  to  strangers  of  their 


THE  PASSING  OF  MISS  CHABLOTTE  ELY    77 

parents'  choosing,  and  responsibilities  for  which 
they  were  totally  unfitted — these  were  taken  in, 
trained  to  obedience,  self-control,  truth-telling, 
thrift  and  neatness,  brought  into  intimate  asso- 
ciation with  these  two  wonderful  women  and 
surrounded  with  an  atmosphere  of  love  and 
prayer.  Character  was  what  the  Elys  were 
striving  for;  with  infinite  patience  they  hewed 
and  chiselled  till  the  rough  shapeless  marble 
took  on  form  and  beauty  under  their  hands ;  into 
those  young  lives  they  poured  the  rich  treasures 
of  their  own  hearts  and  minds  and  souls ;  their 
graduates  became  noble  women  whose  influence 
as  teachers,  wives  and  mothers  civilized  and 
Christianized  the  communities  in  which  they 
lived. 

Mary  Ely  was  no  whit  behind  Charlotte  in 
her  self-forgetful  devotion  to  her  work,  and  to 
this  she  added  a  peculiar  devotion  to  her  sister. 
Hers  was  a  more  practical  temperament;  the 
financial  management  of  the  school  and  the 
charge  of  its  domestic  department  fell  to  her 
share ;  common  sense  characterized  her,  shrewd 
insight  into  character,  a  sincere  humility,  a 
tender  love  for  the  weak  or  suffering  and  espe- 
cially for  little  children. 


78  THE  TEAGEDT  OF  BITLIS 

The  efforts  of  the  sisters  were  not  confined 
to  the  Seminary.  They  toured  the  villages 
frequently,  establishing  and  superintending 
secondary  schools  and  organizing  work  for 
women  everywhere. 

To  all  this  was  added  the  management  of 
orphanages  after  the  massacres  of  1895-96. 
This  meant  more  than  feeding,  clothing,  train- 
ing and  teaching  the  homeless  waifs  gathered 
in  from  the  street;  it  meant  providing  for  their 
future  when  they  reached  maturity,  choosing 
good  husbands  for  them,  and  seeing  to  it  that 
they  were  well  treated  in  their  new  homes. 
Many  a  betrothal  was  solemnized  in  the  Elys' 
parlour;  many  a  modest  trousseau  they  pre- 
pared with  motherly  solicitude  and  truly  femi- 
nine pleasure  in  the  task. 

For  a  good  many  years  after  Mrs.  Knapp's 
departure  from  Bitlis  Miss  Charlotte  had  the 
charge,  also,  of  the  boarding  department  of  the 
boys'  school.  She  was  as  successful  in  the 
management  of  boys  as  of  girls,  thoroughly 
understanding  boy  nature  and  skillful  in  deaHng 
with  it,  and  many  a  capable  and  useful  preacher, 
teacher,  man  of  business,  has  affectionately 
acknowledged  that  the  good  in  him  he  owed  to 


THE  PASSING  OP  MISS  CHAELOTTE  ELY    79 

Mire-Varzhoohee*s  (Mother-Teacher's)  care 
and  guidance. 

She  planned  her  school  buildings  and  super- 
vised their  erection;  minutely  supervised  the 
work  of  carpenters,  masons,  gardeners,  etc.,  in 
her  employ,  teaching  them  new  methods  and 
the  accuracy  foreign  to  the  Oriental  mind. 
Hers  was  a  many  sided  personality;  contrasted 
with  her  great  strength  of  character  and  almost 
masculine  abilities  were  peculiar  weaknesses 
due  to  an  extremely  nervous,  intense,  sensitive 
temperament.  The  fear  of  high  winds,  thunder- 
storms and  earthquakes  was  an  acute  torment 
all  her  life,  and  every  time  she  crossed  the  ocean 
she  was  almost  beside  herself  with  terror 
throughout  the  voyage.  Yet  she  continued  to 
live  where  earthquakes  were  of  common  occur- 
rence and  where  she  was  separated  by  that 
dreaded  ocean  from  her  early  home  and  friends 
and  relatives,  because  she  loved  her  work  witK 
all  her  heart  and  soul. 

In  her  wonderful  memory  was  stored  not 
only  the  names  of  all  her  boys  and  girls,  of  her 
neighbours  and  of  the  members  of  the  Protes- 
tant community,  but  also  an  immense  amount 
of  detail  concerning  their  characters  and  per- 


80  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

sonalities,    their    relationships    and    the    main 
events  in  their  Hves. 

Both  sisters  identified  themselves  wholly  with 
the  interests  of  their  people  and  possessed  their 
unbounded  confidence  and  affection.  Moslems 
as  well  as  Christians  trusted  and  revered 
them. 

Mary  Ely  fell  ill  in  the  fall  of  1912.  Dr. 
Ussher,  hastily  summoned  from  Van,  pro- 
nounced her  trouble  heart  disease,  advised  a 
lower  altitude,  and  took  her  to  Mardin,  where 
she  spent  the  winter  under  the  care  of  Dr. 
Thom.  At  first  she  improved  in  health,  but 
later  grew  worse  and  sea-level  and  the  care  of  a 
specialist  seemed  necessary.  She  would  allow 
no  one  to  inform  Charlotte  of  her  condition,  but 
Miss  Uline,  one  of  her  associates  at  Bitlis, 
obliged  at  this  time  (April)  to  go  to  Beirut  on 
business,  joined  her  at  Mardin  and  the  two 
travelled  together  to  the  sea-coast. 

Arrived  in  Beirut,  Mary  Ely  sank  rapidly. 
The  habit  of  sparing  her  idolized  sister  all 
possible  anxiety  persisted  to  the  last.  She  sent 
word  that  she  was  comfortable  and  well  cared 
for  and  that  Charlotte  was  on  no  account  to 
come  to  her.    She  would  not  permit  physicians 


THE  PASSING  OF  MISS  CHARLOTTE  ELY    81 

and  nurses  to  telegraph  the  whole  truth.  On 
May  5,  1913,  she  peacefully  fell  asleep  in  the 
arms  of  the  beloved  young  friend  who  had  most 
tenderly  cared  for  her  during  those  last  days 
of  weakness  and  pain. 

Very  bravely  did  Miss  Charlotte  bear  her  loss 
and  loneliness,  but  half  her  life  seemed  gone. 

And  now  that  her  spirit  had  taken  flight  her 
pupils  dressed  her  in  the  gown  she  had  worn 
at  her  graduation  from  Mt.  Holyoke  and  she 
was  laid  to  rest  in  the  garden  she  had  tended 
for  many  years.  Only  a  few  Armenians  were 
allowed  to  attend  the  funeral  service.  After- 
wards one  of  the  teachers  said,  "  To  think 
that  she  who  had  taught  us  so  many  lovely 
songs  should  be  laid  away  without  one  song 
from  her  Armenian  girls,  and  that  she  who 
had  given  her  life  to  the  Armenian  people 
should  have  to  be  carried  to  her  grave  by 
strange  Turkish  soldiers !  " 

Yet  this  very  end,  strange  and  sad  as  it  seems, 
significantly  sealed  the  renunciations  of  her 
lifetime.  And  who  can  doubt  that  she  was 
greeted  in  the  new  life  by  the  "  new  song  **  on 
the  lips  of  her  Armenian  girls,  gone  before  her 
up  "  the  steep  ascent  of  Heaven  through  peril, 
toil  and  pain  "  ? 


XI 

AFTER  THE  RUSSIAN  RETREAT 

WHEN  they  had  been  waiting  hourly 
for  word  that  the  Governor  and  the 
few  remaining  officers  were  leaving, 
the  Americans  had  got  everything  in  readiness 
to  barricade  their  buildings  against  an  attack 
by  Kurds.  A  young  Armenian  who  came  to 
them  disguised  as  a  woman  was  allowed  to  stay 
on  condition  he  deliver  up  his  firearms.  He 
was  also  forbidden  to  enter  the  girls'  school. 

Shortly  after  the  retreat  of  the  Russians  and 
while  the  Turks  were  returning  to  the  city  two 
mounted  gendarmes  rode  into  the  school  prem- 
ises.   Mr.  Knapp  asked  them  what  they  wanted. 

"  That  is  our  business." 

"  These  are  American  premises  and  you  have 
no  right  to  come  in  this  way  without  an  order.** 

"You  are  the  man  we  want;  you  come 
with  us." 

They  drew  their  guns  to  force  him  to  accom- 

82 


AFTEE  THE  EUSSIAN  EETEEAT         83 

pany  them.  Mr.  Knapp  carried  no  arms:  it 
will  be  remembered  that  the  Armenian  men  ad- 
mitted to  the  premises  early  in  June  had  been 
asked  to  give  up  their  arms  and  he  would  not 
assume  a  privilege  refused  to  them.  Just  out- 
side the  school  gate  they  encountered  a  soldier 
who  protested  against  their  action  and  while  the 
controversy  was  on  Mr.  Knapp  left  them  and 
went  on  to  the  Ely  residence. 

The  incident  seemed  significant  in  the  light 
of  an  experience  of  his  following  the  massacres 
of  1896  (see  Chapter  XIV),  and  he  told  Miss 
Shane  there  was  a  possibility  of  his  being 
obliged  to  leave. 

A  few  days  later  officers  came  and  asked  him 
to  accompany  them  to  a  neighbouring  house 
as  they  had  an  official  communication  to  make 
to  him,  and  they  threatened  to  use  force  if  he 
did  not  immediately  accede  to  their  request. 
Miss  McLaren,  at  that  time  nursing  Sister 
Martha,  who  was  ill  with  typhus,  heard  of  this 
and  made  up  her  mind  to  go  with  him. 

"  Escorted  to  a  room  where  there  were  sev- 
eral civil  and  military  officials,  we  were  given 
the  'highest  seats  in  the  synagogue.*  The 
spokesman  as  I  remember  was  the  chief  of 


84  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

police,  and  he  began  by  telling  us  that  as  for- 
eigners living  in  Turkish  territory  we  were  the 
honoured  guests  of  the  Ottoman  Government 
and  as  such  entitled  to  all  the  protection  they 
could  provide.  Bitlis  was  in  the  war  zone  and 
therefore  we  must  move  to  safer  quarters.  It 
was  then  four  o'clock  in  the  afternoon,  and  we 
were  to  be  ready  to  leave  at  seven  the  next 
morning.  Miss  Shane  was  to  go  also.  In  vain 
I  pleaded  for  permission  to  remain  as  long  as 
Sister  Martha  lived.  No,  they  had  hospitals 
and  she  could  be  cared  for  in  one  of  them.  In- 
dignation and  wrath  increased  as  I  listened,  and 
then  I  gave  them  my  opinion  of  Turkish  grati- 
tude that  would  permit  them  to  treat  thus 
lightly  the  care  of  one  who  was  dying  because 
of  what  she  had  done  for  their  soldiers.  They 
looked  at  me  in  amazement  (perhaps  in  amuse- 
ment) but  repeated  that  I  could  not  stay.  As 
there  seemed  nothing  further  to  be  said  or  done, 
I  went  back  to  my  patient,  feeling  sure  that  I 
would  stay  with  her  until  the  end,  but  not  know- 
ing how  it  was  to  be  brought  about." 

The  officers  told  Mr.  Knapp  that  they  wished 
to  look  over  the  premises  and  see  how  many 
people  were   still   there.     The   persecution  of 


AFTER  THE  RUSSIAN  RETREAT         85 

defenseless  women  and  children  had  been  re- 
sumed immediately  on  the  return  of  the  Turks 
and  gendarmes  had  come  to  take  away  those 
who,  when  the  city  had  been  practically  evacu- 
ated, had  come  to  the  American  premises  for 
protection  from  the  plundering  Kurds  (see 
Chapter  IX).  Word  was  sent  Miss  Shane  that 
those  who  had  been  with  her  in  the  school  from 
the  first  (the  sixty  or  seventy  who  had  been 
listed)  would  not  be  molested.  Unable  to  re- 
main quietly  in  bed,  however,  in  this  critical 
situation.  Miss  Shane  dressed  hurriedly  and 
went  across  the  hall  to  where  the  women  and 
girls  were  congregated.  Mr.  Knapp,  down- 
stairs, was  urging  the  gendarmes  to  leave  the 
women  where  they  were,  but  they  declared  they 
were  under  orders  and  must  take  them. 

Suddenly  a  shot  rang  out;  Mr.  Knapp  and 
two  gendarmes  ran  up  into  the  hall  but  finding 
all  quiet  on  the  second  floor  went  below  and  dis- 
covered that  the  shot  had  been  fired  from  a 
window  in  the  kitchen.  Some  of  the  women 
upon  the  arrival  of  the  gendarmes  had  taken 
into  the  schoolhouse  the  young  man  who  had 
come  to  the  premises  a  week  earlier  disguised 
as  a  woman;  he  had  somehow  succeeded  in 


86  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

securing  a  gun,  had  concealed  himself  and, 
thinking  perhaps  that  a  thorough  search  would 
be  made,  had  aimed  at  and  wounded  a  soldier. 
He  must  have  been  half-crazed  with  fear  or  he 
would  have  known  that  such  a  foolhardy  action 
could  only  insure  his  own  capture  and  would 
endanger  the  safety  of  all  the  rest. 

The  Turks,  fearfully  enraged,  surrounded 
Mr.  Knapp  in  the  small  entry  leading  to  the 
kitchen,  levelling  their  guns  at  him.  Miss 
Shane,  hearing  from  the  women  that  he  was  in 
great  danger,  made  her  way  down-stairs,  cling- 
ing to  the  rail.  Mr.  Knapp,  on  seeing  her,  called 
to  her  to  go  back,  adding  that  they  were  in- 
sisting on  his  entering  the  kitchen  to  disarm  the 
Armenian.  One  of  the  gendarmes  ordered  her 
away.  She  went  on.  A  policeman  who  seemed 
to  be  in  command  then  motioned  her  away; 
when  she  refused  to  go  he  raised  his  gun  to 
strike  her,  his  face  distorted  with  wrath. 
Realizing  the  uselessness  of  attempting  to  op- 
pose him  further,  she  turned  to  go  up-stairs. 
He  barred  the  way,  speaking  rapidly  in  Turkish, 
not  a  word  of  which  could  she  understand,  then 
called  a  common  soldier  and  indicated  that  she 
was  to  follow  him.     She  learned  later  that  she 


AFTEE  THE  EUSSIAN  EETEEAT         87 

was  thus  sent  away  because  they  intended  to 
burn  the  building  to  prevent  the  escape  of  the 
Armenian. 

As  Mr.  Knapp  approached  the  kitchen  door 
another  shot  rang  out;  entering,  he  found  the 
young  man  dead  by  his  own  hand. 

Meanwhile  Miss  Shane  was  taken  to  a  large 
house  across  the  way  which  was  being  used  as  a 
hospital.  The  principal  of  the  girls'  school 
joined  her  before  she  reached  the  gate,  and 
when  Miss  Shane  sank  weak  and  exhausted  into 
a  chair  placed  for  her  in  one  of  the  hallways,  she 
sat  beside  her  supporting  her,  and  began  to 
scold  vigorously  the  Turks  who  occasionally 
passed  them,  because  Miss  Shane  had  been 
forced  to  leave  the  schoolhouse  in  her  weakened 
condition. 

The  two  women  were  allowed  to  remain  in 
this  hallway  safe  and  unmolested,  as  Turks  not 
acting  under  government  orders  did  not  as  a 
rule  concern  themselves  with  whatever  might 
be  going  on.  Indeed,  in  many  instances  they 
had  ere  this  shown  regret  that  such  things  must 
be.  The  women  and  girls  in  the  schoolhouse 
were  brought  over  to  this  hospital;  later,  word 
was  sent  to  Miss  Shane  that  she  might  go  back 


88  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

to  the  schoolhouse,  for  the  building  would  not  be 
burned  now  that  the  young  Armenian  was  dead. 
Meanwhile  several  of  the  officers  had  gone 
immediately  after  the  shooting  incident  to  Miss 
McLaren  in  the  Ely  house. 

"  I  had  heard  the  shot  and  had  seen  the  body 
being  dragged  away,  but  knew  nothing  further. 
The  enraged  men  proceeded  to  enlighten  me  by 
saying  that  Mr.  Knapp  had  hidden  that  man 
purposely  to  shoot  one  of  them.  I  tried  to  con- 
vince them  that  this  was  not  true,  giving  as 
proofs  the  facts  that  we  had  refused  to  allow 
armed  men  on  the  premises,  and  that  Mr.  Knapp 
had  disarmed  several.  This  statement,  instead 
of  establishing  our  innocence,  had  the  opposite 
effect. 

"  *  Where  are  the  arms  that  he  took?  ' 
"  *  They  are  locked  up  in  his  safe.' 
" '  Why  did  he  not  turn  them  over  to  us  at 
once?     See,  he  keeps  arms  on  the  American 
compound !     We  must  have  them  at  once,*  and 
they  arose  to  go. 

"  I  did  not  see  fit  to  tell  them  that  under  the 
couch  on  which  some  of  them  had  been  sitting 
there  were  two  guns  with  ammunition,  put  there 
for  use  in  case  of  an  attack  by  Kurds  if  the  gov- 


AFTER  THE  RUSSIAN  RETREAT         89 

ernment  had  been  obliged  to  leave  the  city. 
While  they  were  gone,  however,  I  had  the  guns 
taken  out  and  put  in  a  less  suspicious  place, 
ready  to  be  handed  over  on  demand.  On  their 
return  all  looked  as  if  they  had  unearthed  a 
great  plot  against  the  government  and  had 
escaped  a  great  danger.  I  helped  them  to 
search  our  house  for  weapons  and  then  renewed 
my  plea  that  I  be  allowed  to  remain,  saying  that 
they  might  do  with  me  what  they  liked  after 
Sister  Martha  was  gone. 

"  Referring  again  to  what  they  chose  to  call 
Mr.  Knapp's  perfidy,  they  said  I  must  go.  Just 
at  that  time  the  superintendent  of  the  hospitals, 
Mustifa  Bey,  walked  in  and  asked  what  the 
trouble  was.  On  being  told  he  pointed  to  me 
and  asked,  *  Is  she  going  too?  I  need  her  in 
my  hospital.  She  does  not  belong  to  Bitlis,  but 
came  over  from  Van  with  us  and  I  cannot  run 
my  hospital  without  her.'  Neither  he  nor  I  be- 
lieved this  last,  but  it  put  matters  in  a  new 
light,  and  after  a  little  whispered  consultation 
it  was  decided  that  I  might  remain.  The  doctor 
also  put  in  a  word  for  Miss  Shane  and  per- 
mission was  given  her  to  remain  until  her 
temperature  came  down  to  normal." 


90  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

The  gendarmes  and  soldiers  withdrew  from 
the  premises  with  the  exception  of  the  usual 
guard.  There  was  no  sleep  for  any  of  the 
Americans  that  night.  The  next  morning  it 
was  found  that  the  women  and  girls  in  the  house 
across  the  way  had  been  left  unmolested,  but 
it  was  still  reported  that  they  would  be  taken 
from  the  city  later  in  the  day.  Permission  was 
given  Miss  Shane  to  see  them. 

"  Supported  by  two  of  our  women,  I  made 
my  way  across  the  street  and  to  the  part  of  the 
building  where  they  were  being  held.  The 
pastor's  wife  rushed  into  the  room,  sank  at  my 
feet  and  buried  her  face  in  my  lap.  The  others 
crowded  about  me.  I  told  them  that  I  had  sent 
word  to  Mustifa  Bey,  the  superintendent  of  hos- 
pitals, to  intercede  for  them. 

"  Those  were  sad  moments  for  all  of  us  as  we 
knew  what  the  future  might  hold  in  store  for 
them.  For  the  most  part  they  were  calm  and 
quiet,  and  most  earnest  were  the  prayers  that 
went  up  as  we  knelt  together. 

"  I  was  allowed  to  remain  only  fifteen  min- 
utes. Just  before  I  left  three  soldiers  came  into 
the  room  and  tried  to  persuade  several  of  the 
girls  to  go  with  them  to  another  room  to  do 


AFTEE  THE  EUSSIAN  EETEEAT        91 

some  work  for  them.  The  girls  refused  and  the 
men  did  not  insist.  One  young  woman,  urged 
more  than  the  others,  turned  on  the  soldier  and 
with  fearless  eyes  full  of  scorn  said,  *  You  can 
kill  me  here  but  I  will  not  go.'  This  was  the 
spirit  of  the  girls,  shown  on  various  occasions, 
and  I  was  proud  of  them. 

"  Up  to  this  time  I  had  been  staying  in  the 
girls*  school.  But  it  seemed  that  Mr.  Knapp 
would  leave  that  day  and  as  all  our  girls  and 
women  might  be  sent  away  at  any  time,  he  in- 
sisted that,  owing  to  my  weak  condition,  I 
should  go  back  to  the  Ely  residence. 

"  In  the  evening  Mustifa  Bey  came  in  to  tell 
us  that  the  girls  would  be  allowed  to  stay.  He 
said  that  the  Governor  expressed  himself  as  be- 
ing sorry  that  matters  had  turned  out  as  they 
had,  that  he  had  not  intended  my  girls  to  be 
troubled  in  any  way,  but  since  the  shooting  on 
our  premises  investigation  was  likely  to  be 
made  from  Constantinople,  and  he  could  allow 
them  to  remain  only  on  condition  that  they 
assist  in  the  hospital. 

"  Mr.  Knapp  was  allowed  to  do  his  packing 
and  no  limit  placed  on  the  amount  he  could  take 
with  him.     Monday  afternoon  he  came  in  to 


92  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

give  me  the  station  books  and  advise  me  as  to 
the  managing  of  affairs  after  his  departure.  At 
ten  o'clock  he  came  in  to  say  good-bye  to  us. 
He  was  very  sad  and  depressed,  more  on  ac- 
count of  having  to  leave  us  alone  in  that  critical 
situation  than  on  his  own  account,  although  he 
was  of  the  opinion  that  he  would  not  be  al- 
lowed to  travel  safely.  For  a  long  time  he  had 
been  under  intense  strain,  practically  working 
alone.  He  seemed  never  to  think  of  himself 
and  had  never  wavered  in  his  self-sacrificing 
devotion  and  service  to  those  under  his  protec- 
tion. He  was  greatly  troubled  now  because  he 
had  allowed  the  young  man  to  come  into  the 
premises.  But  I  reminded  him  that  the  re- 
sponsibility was  not  his  only,  nor  was  any  one 
at  fault.  We  could  not  foresee  that  the  Rus- 
sians would  retreat  or  that  the  Armenian  would 
secure  firearms  and  do  the  insane  thing  that  he 
had  done. 

"  Before  he  left  the  house  we  had  prayers  to- 
gether. Some  time  past  midnight  I  heard  the 
soft  tread  of  camels  and  horses  in  the  street  be- 
low, and  knew  that  he  was  on  his  way — alone." 

And  the  two  American  women  were  left  with 
their  dying  friend. 


XII 

SISTER  MARTHA 

ONCE  when  Sister  Martha  had  pleaded 
in  vain  for  a  sick  boy  that  he  might  be 
allowed  to  remain  in  the  compound  un- 
til he  recovered  instead  of  being  taken  away 
from  the  city  to  his  death — as  she  knew,  a  Turk- 
ish officer  took  her  aside  and  said,  "  Why  do 
you  mix  in  this  business?  This  is  an  American 
home  and  you  are  a  German ;  you  may  get  into 
trouble ;  keep  away." 

Her  reply  was,  "  Even  if  I  am  a  German,  this 
is  as  much  my  business  as  the  Americans'  and  I 
won't  keep  away  as  long  as  I  think  I  can  help 
the  Armenians." 

The  Turks  talked  with  her  freely  about  their 
treatment  of  the  Armenians,  expecting  her  to 
see  the  matter  from  their  point  of  view  because 
she  was  a  German,  and  constantly  reminded  her 
that  they  were  allies.  They  went  so  far  as  to 
say  that  Germany  was  responsible  for  the 
massacres  and  hardly  a  day  passed  that  some 

93 


94  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

Turkish  official  did  not  step  up  to  her,  put  his 
forefingers  together  and  say,  "  We  are  brothers, 
we  are  allies."  Such  remarks  seemed  little 
short  of  sacrilege  to  her,  for  she  believed  the 
Kaiser  incapable  of  doing  wrong. 

"  Oh !  "  she  would  say  to  the  Americans,  "  we 
love  our  Kaiser.    He  would  not  do  such  things." 

Later  she  evidently  began  to  suspect,  or  had 
reason  to  believe,  that  Germany  was  responsible 
for  the  massacres,  and  this  belief  broke  her 
heart.  Physically  she  had  suffered  greatly  for 
many  months  though  she  had  never  permitted 
her  health  to  interfere  with  her  work;  mentally 
she  now  suffered  even  more  keenly  because  of 
her  sympathy  with  the  Armenians  and  her  love 
for  her  fatherland.  The  strain  was  too  great 
for  her  to  bear;  she  often  said  to  Miss  McLaren, 
"  I  want  to  go  home.  Not  to  my  home  in 
Konigsberg  but  to  my  Father's  home."  And 
every  morning  before  going  to  her  work  she 
would  sing  the  hymn,  "  Ich  mochte  Heim." 

Her  desire  was  soon  fulfilled.  She  fell  ill  with 
typhus  and  from  the  first  there  seemed  to  be  no 
chance  of  her  recovery.  In  her  delirium  she 
would  scream  "  Herrlichkeit! "  then  add  in  a 
lower  voice,  "Ja  Vater,  du  weiz."    Miss  Mc- 


SISTER  MARTHA  95 

Laren  nursed  her  throughout  her  illness  and 
wrote  at  her  dictation  little  loving  messages  to 
her  friends  and  relatives.  After  ten  days  of  in- 
tense suffering  she  entered  her  "  Father's 
Home  "  on  July  29,  1915. 

There  was  no  one  in  the  city,  Moslem  or 
Christian,  who  could  make  even  a  rough  box  for 
a  coffin,  so  Miss  McLaren  took  a  bier  used  for 
carrying  Turkish  soldiers  to  the  grave,  cleansed 
it,  lined  it  and  made  it  more  fit  for  her  purpose. 
She  conducted  the  burial  service  which  Miss 
Shane,  two  doctors  and  a  few  Armenian  women 
and  girls  attended. 

No  notice  was  taken  by  the  Turkish  Govern- 
ment of  Sister  Martha's  death,  although  she  had 
given  her  life  for  its  soldiers.  A  few  weeks 
later  the  Vali  asked  Miss  McLaren  who  Sister 
Martha  was,  as  an  inquiry  about  her  had  come 
from  the  German  ambassador.  Miss  McLaren 
had  good  reason  to  believe  that  he  never  took 
the  trouble  to  answer  this  inquiry.* 
*See  Chapter  XV. 


XIII 

THE  PIONEER  PARENTS  OF  GEORGE 
PERKINS   KNAPP 

ONE  October  morning  in  1855  a  newly 
married  couple  set  out  from  New  Eng- 
land on  what  proved  a  unique  wedding 
journey.  They  were  to  sail  across  the  Atlantic 
and  the  Mediterranean,  but  they  had  no  sooner 
left  port  than  a  terrific  storm  arose;  the  first 
mate  was  washed  overboard;  the  voyage  lasted 
so  much  longer  than  expected  that  before  its 
end  the  water  and  food  supply  was  exhausted; 
crew  and  passengers  secured  drinking  water  by 
setting  vessels  out  on  deck  to  catch  the  rain. 
Worst  of  all,  the  captain  was  drunk  when  the 
ship  reached  the  ^gean  Sea  and  there  was  no 
other  officer  capable  of  navigating  the  ship 
through  the  dangerous  archipelago. 

There  were  seven  missionaries  on  board :  the 

newly  married  pair,  George  Gushing  Knapp  and 

96 


THE  PARENTS  OF  GEORGE  P.  KNAPP    97 

his  wife  Alzina  Churchill  Knapp,  Rev.  and  Mrs. 
Edward  Aiken,  Rev.  and  Mrs.  O.  P.  Allen  and 
Dr.  H.  B,  Haskell.  The  four  men  were  fresh 
from  theological  seminary  or  medical  school 
and  had  never  set  foot  on  a  sailing  vessel  be- 
fore, but  they  were  equal  to  the  emergency: 
locking  the  drunken  captain  into  his  cabin  they 
took  the  chart,  studied  it,  and  navigated  the 
ship  successfully  to  port. 

At  Smyrna  the  seven  travelling  companions 
separated.  Dr.  Haskell  carried  on  medical 
work  in  Mosul  for  a  while ;  the  wife  ^  he  married 
two  years  later,  who  visited  Bitlis  and  became 
a  warm  friend  of  the  Knapps,  is  still  living.  Mr, 
and  Mrs.  Aiken  joined  the  mission  at  Beirut 
and  Mr.  and  Mrs.  Allen  were  stationed  at  Har- 
poot  and  a  son  and  a  daughter  of  theirs  also 
became  missionaries  in  Turkey.  Mr.  Allen, 
the  last  survivor  of  this  little  group,  died  in 
Constantinople  in  the  spring  of  1918. 

Mr.  and  Mrs.  Knapp  joined  what  was  then 
called  the  Assyrian  Mission,  and  were  stationed 
in  Diarbekir  with  Rev.  and  Mrs.  Augustus 
Walker  and  Dr.  and  Mrs.  David  O.  Nutting. 
In  1858,  however,  they  begged  to  be  permitted 
*  Mrs.  S.  B.  Tibbals  of  New  Haven. 


98  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

to  establish  a  station  in  a  city  whose  need  had 
greatly  appealed  to  them  during  a  summer  spent 
there  away  from  the  great  heat  of  the  Diarbekir 
plain. 

BitHs  is  situated  on  a  plateau  so  high  and  so 
abrupt  that  in  six  hours  of  horseback  travel  one 
can  pass  from  a  region  of  heavy  winter  snows 
to  a  land  of  perpetual  summer.  It  is  the  "  door 
between  highlands  and  lowlands,"  as  the  valley 
of  the  Bitlis  River  is  the  avenue  of  communica- 
tion between  the  plateaus  of  the  northeast  and 
east  and  the  Mesopotamian  plains. 

The  houses  are  built  of  large  hewn  blocks  of 
a  sort  of  lava  which  is  silvery  gray  and  soft 
enough  to  be  cut  with  a  knife  when  fresh  from 
the  quarry,  but  turns  hard  and  brown  after  long 
exposure  to  the  weather.  Earthquakes  have 
been  very  frequent;  in  1906  a  series  of  earth- 
quakes of  unusual  severity  did  much  damage  in 
the  villages  of  the  region,  but  the  houses  of 
Bitlis  with  their  three-foot-thick  stone  walls 
were  injured  in  but  few  cases.  Near  the  city 
is  an  extinct  volcano,  Nimroud  Dagh,  which  has 
a  crater  second  in  size  only  to  Crater  Lake, 
Oregon. 

Mr.  Knapp  immediately  started  a  class  for 


THE  PARENTS  OF  GEORGE  P.  KNAPP    99 

young  men  which  met  every  evening  at  his 
home.  Mrs.  Knapp  taught  daily  a  class  of  girls 
and  women.  Mr.  Trowbridge  was  their  asso- 
ciate the  first  winter;  the  next  they  were  left 
alone.  The  opposition  of  the  jealous,  ignorant 
Gregorian  priesthood  was  very  severe  at  first 
and  at  one  time  a  mob  set  upon  Mr.  Knapp  and 
his  helpers  in  the  market-place.  Dr.  and  Mrs. 
Nutting  were  with  them  for  a  while  in  1860  and 
that  summer  the  two  men  explored  a  field  which 
included  two  hundred  towns  and  villages,  of 
which  one  hundred  and  twenty-eight  were 
Armenian.  But  this  explored  region  was  less 
than  half  of  the  territory,  fifteen  hundred  square 
miles  in  area,  belonging  to  Bitlis  "  station  "  and 
the  missionaries  in  Bitlis  must  evangelize  this 
territory  if  it  was  to  be  evangelized  at  all. 
Rev.  and  Mrs.  Lysander  T.  Burbank  joined 
them  in  1861  and  remained  nine  years.  After 
their  departure  the  Knapps  and  the  Misses  Ely, 
whom  they  had  brought  back  with  them  on 
their  return  from  furlough  in  1868,  were  the 
only  missionaries  in  this  great  field  for  fourteen 
years. 

The  work  was  a  pioneer  work  indeed.     The 
people  were  amazingly  ignorant  and  geographic- 


100  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

ally  and  chronologically  remote  from  civiliza- 
tion. There  were  no  railroads  in  Kurdistan ;  no 
post  horses,  even,  came  to  Bitlis  in  the  sixties, 
and  the  Americans  had  to  send  a  man  once  a 
month  to  Erzerum  for  their  mail.  People  lived 
and  laboured  as  their  ancestors  had  done  before 
them  for  hundreds  of  years.  Women  were 
despised,  overworked,  led  lives  of  dreary,  slavish 
subjection.  The  almost  incredible  ignorance  of 
mothers,  the  absence  of  any  medical  help  what- 
soever, the  lack  of  sanitation,  were  the  causes 
of  a  seventy-five  per  cent  infant  mortality  and 
an  immense  amount  of  physical  suffering,  de- 
formity and  blindness. 

The  American  missionaries  educated  girls  as 
well  as  boys — an  unheard  of,  and  at  first  bitterly 
opposed,  experiment.  They  sought  first  of  all 
to  build  up  strong  helpful  Christian  characters. 
Knowledge,  a  wider  outlook,  new  ideals,  new 
ambitions,  the  personal  influence  and  example 
of  these  American  teachers,  gradually  raised  the 
whole  level  of  civilization  in  the  region.  Homes 
like  those  of  Pastor  Khachig  and  his  wife, 
Kevork  Effendi's  and  Deegeen  Heghene's — 
cultured,  happy,  love-filled  homes;  characters 
like  theirs  that  bore  triumphantly  the  supreme 


THE  PARENTS  OF  GEORGE  P.  KNAPP    101 

test  at  the  last,  were  the  bright  flowering  of  this 
new  civilization. 

For  this  work  Mr.  and  Mrs.  Knapp  were  pe- 
culiarly fitted :  the  pioneer  blood  of  six  genera- 
tions of  New  England  ancestry  ran  in  their 
veins;  theirs  was  the  resourcefulness,  ambition 
and  "  grit  *'  that  seems  the  heritage  of  those 
born  and  bred  on  New  England  farms;  and 
theirs  a  whole-hearted,  enthusiastic  devotion  to 
the  service  of  their  Master. 

Mr.  Knapp  had  the  true  Yankee  ingenuity, 
inventiveness  and  mechanical  ability.  He  taught 
his  pupils  to  make  the  furniture  of  their  school- 
room, and  helped  them  pay  their  way  with  the 
work  of  their  hands.  He  introduced  the  use  of 
window-glass,  and  dark  germ-breeding  dwell- 
ings were  thus  opened  to  the  purifying  sunlight. 
He  planted  a  garden,  raising  in  it  many  vege- 
tables unknown  to  that  region,  two  of  which, 
the  potato  and  tomato,  became  staple  products 
and  articles  of  diet  thereafter.  He  was  not  a 
physician,  but  the  sick  constantly  appealed  to 
him  for  relief  and  he  and  his  wife  dispensed 
simple  remedies  with  common  sense  advice  con- 
cerning the  care  of  the  sick  and  of  little  children. 

A   good   boys'   school,   a   girls'    seminary,   a 


102  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

strong  evangelical  church  and  community  de- 
veloped in  a  comparatively  short  time  from  very 
modest  beginnings.  Schools  and  preaching 
centers  were  established  in  the  surrounding  vil- 
lages until  there  were  twenty-eight  in  the 
vilayet  from  which  came  girls  and  boys  pre- 
pared for  entrance  into  the  two  boarding-schools 
in  Bitlis  and  from  which  radiated  enlightenment 
and  helpful  influence  to  all  parts  of  the  province. 

The  Havedorig  region  was  a  remarkable  ex- 
ample of  the  changes  wrought  by  these  centers. 
Its  inhabitants  when  Mr.  Knapp  first  visited 
them  were  bloodthirsty,  thievish  brigands;  fif- 
teen years  later  the  church  at  Havedorig  was 
working  a  reform  among  the  hundred  villages 
of  Moush  plain,  and  the  people  were  gradually 
becoming  peaceful,  law-abiding,  prosperous  and 
intelligent. 

The  unusual  experiences  of  the  missionaries 
both  at  home  and  while  travelling  and  touring 
the  villages  would  fill  a  volume.  One  of  Mr. 
Knapp's  journeys  was  a  voyage  down  the  Tigris 
River  to  Mosul  on  a  raft  made  of  wood  resting 
on  over  a  hundred  inflated  goat-skins.  At  night 
the  travellers  would  anchor  the  raft  near  some 
village.     Passing  through  the  narrows  between 


Home   lite  in   an   Armenian   village 


Life   in  an  Armenian   refngee   camp — Port   Said 


THE  PAEENTS  OF  GEOEGE  P.  KNAPP   103 

high  rocky  bluffs  they  were  shot  at  by  robber 
Kurds. 

During  another  journey  he  and  his  com- 
panion, Dr.  George  C.  Raynolds  of  Van,  were 
attacked  and  robbed  by  the  noted  brigand, 
Mousa  Bey. 

When  the  Russo-Turkish  war  broke  out  Mr. 
Knapp  was  taking  his  oldest  son  George  to 
Constantinople  to  send  him  thence  to  America. 
He  had  to  consign  the  boy  to  the  care  of  the 
captain  of  a  Black  Sea  steamer  and  hasten  back 
to  his  other  children  and  the  three  American 
ladies,  left  alone  in  Bitlis.  Troops  from  Bagdad 
on  their  way  to  the  front  near  Erzerum  passed 
through  the  city;  several  thousand  Kurdish 
Volunteers  from  the  South  plundered  the 
Armenians  of  Bitlis,  outraging  and  killing  many ; 
they  said  they  had  come  north  not  to  fight  but 
to  plunder.  Many  Armenians  brought  their 
most  cherished  possessions  to  Mr.  Knapp  for 
safe  keeping.  His  presence  restrained  these 
Kurds  to  an  appreciable  extent. 

War  was  followed  by  terrible  famine  and  the 
missionaries  opened  a  soup  kitchen  for  the 
destitute.  Among  those  who  came  to  this  soup 
kitchen  for  relief  was  a  high-spirited,  handsome 


104  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

boy  from  the  highlands  of  Sassun  who  later 
worked  his  way  through  the  mission  school  and 
theological  seminary,  married  a  graduate  of  the 
Mt.  Holyoke  Seminary  of  BitHs,  was  for  a  time 
a  preacher  and  teacher  in  the  villages,  and  finally 
became  pastor  of  the  church  in  Bitlis.  This  was 
Khachig  Vartanian,  the  story  of  whose  martyr- 
dom and  that  of  his  wife  has  been  told  in  the 
preceding  chapters. 

At  the  time  this  young  lad  first  entered 
Bitlis  the  pastor  of  its  Protestant  Church  was 
Rev.  Simon  Tavitian,  who  was  another  remark- 
able product  of  the  mountain  fastnesses  of 
Sassun,  a  man  of  originaHty  of  character,  ex- 
traordinary learning  and  great  practical  ability — 
a  revered  leader  of  his  people. 

Except  for  two  years,  1902-1904,  when  Dr. 
Herbert  Underwood  was  stationed  there,  never 
was  there  an  American,  and  seldom  a  native, 
physician  in  Bitlis,  and  this  lack  was  the  cause 
of  many  hard  experiences.  At  one  time  when 
Mrs.  Knapp  was  dangerously  ill  her  husband 
consulted  by  telegraph  with  Dr.  Parmelee  in 
Erzerum  and  followed  his  directions  success- 
fully. After  Dr.  C.  D.  Ussher  went  to  Van  in 
1899  he  considered  himself  responsible  for  the 


THE  PAEENTS  OF  GEOBGE  P.  KNAPP   105 

Bitlis  station  as  well,  and  often  crossed  the  lake 
or  made  the  hard  four-days'  journey  over  the 
mountains,  to  minister  to  its  missionaries  in 
their  need.  But  this  was  after  Mr.  and  Mrs. 
Knapp's  time. 

Sixteen  years  elapsed  between  Mr.  Knapp's 
first  and  second  furlough.  In  1884  he  was  re- 
leased for  greatly  needed  rest  by  the  transfer 
of  Rev.  Royal  M.  Cole  and  his  wife  from 
Erzerum  to  Bitlis,  where  they  remained  until 
1907.  During  the  Russo-Turkish  war,  Mr.  Cole 
had  cared  very  efHciently  for  the  wounded  sol- 
diers in  Erzerum.  This  city  was  one  of  the 
strategic  points  of  the  war  and  was  taken  by 
the  Russians  in  1878. 

In  1890  Mr.  Knapp's  own  son  George  became 
his  associate  in  the  work  at  Bitlis  and  three 
years  later  a  daughter  also.  His  last  days  were 
passed  among  the  people  he  had  laboured  for; 
he  was  spared  the  terrible  grief  of  witness- 
ing the  massacres  of  1895-96,  for  he  died  on 
March  12,  1895. 

The  missionaries  had  been  bitterly  opposed 
by  the  Gregorian  priesthood  at  the  first.  But 
now  the  Gregorians  requested  that  Mr.  Knapp's 
grave  should  be  within  their  church  and  begged 


106  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

the  privilege  of  taking  a  share  in  the  burial 
services.  These  vi^ere  exceedingly  impressive 
and  deeply  significant  of  the  changes  brought 
about  in  the  space  of  one  man's  lifetime,  largely 
through  the  quiet  influence  of  his  own  per- 
sonality. 

George  Gushing  Knapp's  preeminent  gift  was 
the  gift  of  inspiring  confidence  and  affection. 
His  people  beHeved  absolutely  in  his  sincerity, 
his  interest  in  them,  his  desire  to  help  them, 
his  devotion  to  the  Master  he  served.  He  won 
the  respect  and  admiration  of  those  who  were 
hostile  to  his  religion,  who  were  incapable  of 
understanding  his  motives.  One  of  his  staunch- 
est  friends  was  a  Kurdish  neighbour,  a  man  of 
position  and  influence,  whose  loyalty  was  in 
war  and  massacre  put  severely  to  the  test  and 
did  not  fail. 

His  was  never  the  critical  censorious  spirit 
that  mars  so  many  forceful  personalities;  his 
never  the  tongue  to  wound  with  cruel  thrust 
like  that  of  a  rapier.  He  would  live  at  peace 
with  all  men.  But  underneath  all  his  gentle- 
ness was  the  granite  of  his  native  state:  he 
could  never  be  moved  by  physical  danger  or  the 
fear  of  men  where  principle  was  at  stake. 


THE  PAEENTS  OF  GEOEGE  P.  KNAPP   107 

Mrs.  Knapp  was  a  very  important  factor  in 
the  success  of  the  mission  at  Bitlis.  In  her  girl- 
hood she  had  had  an  intense  craving  for  knowl- 
edge, and  secured  with  much  hard  work  an 
education  for  herself  and  later  for  two  younger 
sisters.  She  became  assistant  principal  of 
Castleton  Seminary,  having  charge  of  its  girl 
students  and  governing  them  with  love  and 
sympathetic  understanding. 

After  she  had  passed  over  to  the  Misses  Ely 
the  school  for  girls  she  had  estabHshed  in  Bitlis, 
she  gave  much  of  her  time  to  the  boys*  school, 
always  teaching  a  number  of  classes  and  having 
full  charge  of  the  boarding  department.  She 
mothered  the  boys  far  from  their  own  village 
homes,  looking  after  their  clothing,  giving  them 
work  with  which  to  pay  their  way,  and  super- 
vising their  discipline.  No  boy  so  stubborn  and 
insubordinate  but  could  be  melted  and  subdued 
by  an  interview  with  "  Khanum."  She  had  a 
remarkable  gift  for  dealing  with  people,  for 
calming  their  angry  passions  and  making  them 
"  see  reason,"  obey  the  dictates  of  common 
sense  and  good  judgment  and  forget  their 
prejudices  and  animosities.  Throughout  her 
life   she  was  constantly  called  upon  to  settle 


108  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

quarrels  and  adjust  difficulties,  and  many  a 
delicate  and  complicated  situation  did  she 
handle  with  the  skill  of  a  born  diplomat. 

Besides  her  school  work  she  had  the  teaching 
of  her  own  children  and  the  cares  of  house- 
keeping, A  notable  cook  herself,  she  trained 
successive  Armenian  women  to  something  ap- 
proaching her  own  perfection  in  that  line,  and 
her  hospitable  home  was  an  oasis  in  the  desert 
of  miserable  Oriental  khans  for  the  infrequent 
European  travellers  through  that  region. 

Her  busy  days,  with  their  great  number  and 
variety  of  regular  tasks  which  left  not  a  moment 
unoccupied,  were  further  filled — to  overflow- 
ing— by  incessant  interruptions:  the  visits  of 
Turkish  men — wives  of  high  officials — the  visits 
of  families  of  wealth  and  influence,  the  appeals 
of  all  sorts  and  conditions  of  men  and  women 
for  advice,  comfort,  or  assistance.  "  Khanum  " 
meant  one  woman  and  no  other  to  the  people  of 
Bitlis:  an  American  woman  with  a  vivid,  force- 
ful personality  radiating  sunny  cheer  and  stimu- 
lating sympathy,  strong,  true,  intensely  loving, 
Christlike. 

A  hot  summer  spent  in  an  Oriental  town 
utterly  lacking  in   sanitation  seriously   injures 


THE  PARENTS  OF  GEORGE  P.  KNAPP    109 

the  health  of  children  of  Occidental  parentage. 
So  Mrs.  Knapp  moved  her  family  every  year 
to  a  mountain  three  miles  from  the  city.  There 
was  a  small  Armenian  village  here;  its  tiny 
fields  of  cabbage  and  turnips,  millet,  wheat  and 
clover,  rose  one  above  another  on  terraces  like 
a  green  flight  of  stairs.  On  two  terraces  above 
the  highest  of  these  camped  the  missionaries  in 
tents  and  dug-outs,  and  here  Mrs.  Knapp  planted 
a  garden  and  tended  it  with  never-failing  de- 
light, reliving  in  memory  the  childhood  days 
spent  on  her  father's  Vermont  farm. 

The  Elys  brought  their  school  up  here  for  the 
summer  term  each  year — no  great  undertaking 
since  desks,  chairs,  tables  and  bedsteads  did 
not  have  to  be  moved  also.  The  girls  from 
secluded  Oriental  homes  revelled  in  the  un- 
wonted physical  freedom  and  simple  pleasures 
of  this  outdoor  life.  Often  after  the  studies  and 
household  tasks  of  the  day,  they  would  play 
"  Tag  "  and  "  Fox  and  Geese  "  and  many  an- 
other old-fashioned  game  on  the  terrace  in  the 
light  of  a  full  moon. 

A  small  river  almost  encircled  the  mountain 
at  its  base ;  a  waterfall  in  a  ravine  opposite  filled 
the  air  with  its  mild  musical  thunder;  a  brook 


110  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

rushed  down  past  the  camp  to  water  the  fields 
of  the  village  whose  ant-hill-like  houses  in  their 
setting  of  green  trees  were  just  visible  from 
the  edge  of  the  Knapp  terrace. 

It  was  a  place  absolutely  shut  in  by  moun- 
tains and  the  world  shut  out — "  a  haunt  of 
ancient  peace."  The  word  "  home  "  has  always 
brought  instantly  the  picture  of  this  quiet  re- 
treat before  the  inner  eye  of  one,  at  least,  whose 
childhood  summers  were  spent  there. 

But  now  the  picture  is  as  instantly  followed 
by  the  stabbing  reminder  that  Cindian  also 
became  in  1915  the  scene  of  hideous  carnage; 
that  those  simple  villagers  were  then  butchered; 
that  many  of  the  girlish  playmates  of  long  ago 
have  as  women  endured  torture,  shame  and 
death. 

The  death  of  her  husband,  the  massacre  of 
1895,  the  deportation  of  her  son,  events  which 
followed  each  other  within  a  year,  almost 
crushed  Mrs.  Knapp's  brave  spirit.  She  re- 
turned to  America  in  1896.  Here  she  found 
new  service  awaiting  her,  service  in  behalf  of 
those  she  loved,  and  to  it  she  gave  herself  un- 
stintedly, self-sacrificingly,  year  after  year. 

Always  keenly  interested  in  affairs,  keeping 


THE  PABENTS  OP  GEOEGE  P.  KNAPP    111 

in  close  touch  with  scores  of  old  friends  in  all 
parts  of  the  world,  constantly  making  devoted 
new  friends,  youthful  in  her  enthusiasms,  phys- 
ically active,  she  lived  a  full  life  to  the  very  end. 
Her  grave  lies  under  the  shadow  of  the 
mighty  Rockies,  the  grave  of  her  husband  un- 
der the  shadow  of  the  Taurus  Mountains,  half 
the  width  of  the  world  away.  The  work  they 
estabhshed  has  been  destroyed — the  people  they 
loved  and  laboured  for  have  been  nearly  an- 
nihilated, the  son  who  most  closely  followed  in 
their  footsteps  has  died  a  martyr's  death.  But 
their  spirit  can  never  die  out  of  the  world;  in 
the  new  Turkey,  in  the  new  Bitlis,  it  will  live 
on.  The  little  town,  reconstructed  by  the  sur- 
viving Armenians  who  call  it  home,  and  by  the 
Americans  helping  them,  will  become  the  center 
of  a  work  greater  than  the  past  has  ever  known 
that  will  civilize  and  Christianize  the  whole  of 
Kurdistan. 


XIV 

GREATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN 

GEORGE  PERKINS  KNAPPinaunique 
sense  laid  down  his  life  for  his  friends, 
the  Armenians.  He  died  because  he 
loved  them,  literally.  This  is  the  firm  convic- 
tion of  those  who  know  most  about  the  circum- 
stances of  his  last  days. 

With  such  a  parentage  as  his,  with  a  child- 
hood and  early  boyhood  spent  in  Bitlis,  his  only 
playmates  and  schoolmates — aside  from  brother 
and  sisters — Armenian  lads,  it  was  perhaps  not 
to  be  wondered  at  that  when  he  came  to 
America  at  the  age  of  fourteen,  he  resolved  to 
return  to  Bitlis  after  completing  his  education. 
Boy  though  he  was  when  that  resolve  was 
made,  he  never  changed  his  mind  but  held  to 
that  single  purpose  throughout  his  school  and 
college  life. 

Working  his  way  through  Harvard  he  was 
graduated  with  the  class  of  1887  and  entered 
Hartford   Theological   Seminary.     During   his 

112 


GEEATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN       113 

Junior  year  at  college  he  became  engaged  to 
Anna  Jay  Hunt,  daughter  of  Addison  A.  and 
Clara  E.  Thomas  Hunt  of  Barre,  Massachusetts, 
who  was  graduated  from  Mt.  Holyoke  Seminary 
in  1886  and  taught  in  Salt  Lake  City  under  the 
New  West  Educational  Commission  until  their 
marriage  in  July,  1890.  A  few  weeks  after  the 
wedding,  Mr.  and  Mrs.  Knapp  set  sail  for 
Turkey. 

The  people  of  Bitlis  had  a  pleasant  way  of 
greeting  new  or  returning  missionaries;  they 
would  walk  two  or  three  miles  out  of  the  city  to 
meet  the  travellers:  the  schoolboys  and  school- 
girls would  line  up  on  each  side  of  the  road,  sing 
a  song  written  for  the  occasion  and  present 
flowers,  after  which  every  one  would  press  for- 
ward for  a  handshake  and  word  of  greeting. 

An  unusually  large  concourse  turned  out  to 
meet  "  Mr.  George "  and  his  young  wife. 
Middle-aged  or  old  men  who  had  known  him 
as  a  boy,  young  men  who  had  been  his  child- 
hood playmates,  were  won  to  renewed  and 
deeper  affection  by  his  quick  recognition  of  old 
friends  in  spite  of  changes  wrought  by  the  inter- 
vening years,  and  by  his  ready  use  of  the  lan- 
guage he  had  not  allowed  himself  to  forget. 


114  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

Such  things  mean  more  to  Orientals  than  to 
other  people;  his  deep  and  continued  and  sin- 
cere interest  in  individuals  and  in  the  race  as  a 
race  wronged  and  oppressed,  his  sympathy,  his 
appreciation  of  all  that  was  admirable  in 
Armenian  character,  customs,  literature  and  re- 
ligion completed  his  conquest  of  their  hearts. 

Four  years  after  his  coming  something  hap- 
pened that  increased  this  affection  almost  to 
hero-worship.  Petty  disturbances  in  the  Sassun 
highlands  west  of  Bitlis  were  magnified  by 
Tahsin  Pasha,  governor  of  the  vilayet,  into  a 
"  rebellion  "  which  was  "  suppressed  "  by  him 
with  fiendish  cruelty.  Refugees  escaping  to 
Bitlis  brought  stories  of  fearful  atrocities  per- 
petrated in  those  remote  fastnesses.  Afire  with 
indignation  and  horror,  Mr.  Knapp  wrote  an  ac- 
count of  what  had  happened  and  sent  it  to  the 
London  Times,  Refugees  escaped  to  Europe 
also  and  told  their  story  there. 

A  commission  of  investigation  was  sent  to 
Moush,  the  town  nearest  the  Sassun  district. 
Although  Mr.  Knapp's  name  had  not  appeared 
in  connection  with  the  Times  article,  the  un- 
looked-for publicity  the  affair  had  gained  was 
ascribed  to  him  by  both  Turks  and  Armenians. 


GEEATEE  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN       115 

The  latter — or  rather  some  of  the  hot-headed 
young  men  among  them — ^jubilant  over  the 
coming  of  the  commission,  were  rather  unwise 
in  their  demonstrations  of  gratitude  and  thus 
increased  the  newly  aroused  hostiUty  towards 
him  of  the  government  officials. 

It  was  beHeved  in  Bitlis,  at  least,  at  that  time, 
that  Europe,  pledged  to  secure  good  govern- 
ment for  the  Armenians,  would  now  begin  to 
fulfill  her  promises.  The  massacres  of  1895-96 
proved  how  vain  were  these  hopes. 

The  massacre  in  Bitlis  took  place  in  October, 
1895.  Many  took  refuge  on  the  mission  prem- 
ises and  here  a  number  of  the  victims  were 
buried.  The  Turks  showed  their  animosity  to- 
wards Mr.  Knapp  by  more  than  one  attempt  to 
shoot  him.  At  the  very  first,  a  Turkish  mob 
rushed  towards  his  house  but  was  checked  and 
finally  dispersed  by  the  intervention  of  the 
Kurdish  neighbour  who  had  been  his  father's 
friend  and  his  own. 

The  massacres  were  represented  by  the  Turk- 
ish Government  as  "  uprisings  "  of  the  Armeni- 
ans and  due  to  Armenian  revolutionary  agents. 
After  the  secret  arrangement  between  Russia 
and  Turkey,  made  when  th^  fleets  of  the  Powers 


116  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

had  assembled  in  the  Bay  of  Salonica,  and 
the  coercing  of  Turkey  by  a  display  of  naval 
strength  before  Constantinople  had  almost  been 
decided  upon,  it  began  to  be  "  whispered  "  that 
the  missionaries  were  at  the  back  of  the  revo- 
lutionary agents  and  that  upon  them  should  fall 
the  real  blame  for  the  blood  shed  by  the  Turks 
in  "  suppressing  disorder."  This  was  a  plausible 
pretext  for  getting  rid  of  them  in  order  to  make 
way  for  the  priests  of  the  Russian  Church,  as 
the  first  step  in  Russianizing  the  empire.  The 
Sultan  prepared  an  irade  providing  for  their  ex- 
pulsion. 

It  was  decided  to  begin  with  Mr.  Knapp.  He 
was  openly  charged  with  inciting  the  Armenians 
of  Bitlis  to  revolt,  and  although  Mr.  Hampson, 
the  British  vice-consul  who  had  been  sent  to 
Bitlis  after  the  massacres,  reported  that  these 
charges  were  absurd,  Mr.  Knapp  was  summoned 
before  the  criminal  court.  On  telegraphing  to 
the  American  minister  for  instructions,  he  was 
told  not  to  obey  the  summons.  But  during  a 
temporary  absence  of  the  British  consul  he  was 
"  invited  "  to  leave  the  city  and  a  large  guard 
came  to  his  house  to  escort  him  to  the  coast. 

Mr.  Knapp  went  with  them,  believing  that  his 


GEEATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN        117 

helpless  people  would  be  punished  for  resistance 
on  his  part.  The  Vali  at  Aleppo  detained  him 
five  days  trying  to  make  him  sign  an  agree- 
ment not  to  return  to  Bitlis  under  any  circum- 
stances. He  steadily  refused  to  sign,  on  the 
ground  that  the  charges  brought  against  him 
were  entirely  unfounded,  and  he  was  finally  al- 
lowed to  proceed,  still  treated  as  a  prisoner,  to 
Alexandretta. 

Fortunately,  Mr.  John  W.  Riddle  was  then 
the  United  States  charge  d'affaires  at  Constan- 
tinople, and  took  up  the  matter  vigorously,  aided 
and  supported  by  Sir  Philip  Currie,  the  British 
ambassador.  The  Turkish  Government  prom- 
ised to  have  the  missionary  delivered  to  the 
American  consul  at  Alexandretta  on  his  arrival 
there  but  the  consul  wired  Mr.  Riddle  on  April 
23rd  that  the  Alexandretta  authorities  had  re- 
fused to  give  up  Mr.  Knapp  and  intended  to 
expel  him  from  Turkish  territory  by  compelling 
him  to  embark  on  a  steamer  saiHng  for  Europe 
April  24th.  Mr.  Riddle  made  energetic  repre- 
sentation to  the  Turkish  Government  demand- 
ing that  the  latter  respect  its  engagements,  and 
in  order  to  give  emphasis  to  his  remarks  he  tele- 
graphed to  the  commander  of  the  United  States 


118  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

cruiser,  Marblehead,  anchored  at  Mersina,  to  go 
to  Alexandretta  and  place  the  cruiser  at  the 
disposal  of  the  consul  at  that  port.  The  Porte 
no  sooner  became  aware  of  this  telegram  than 
orders  were  sent  to  Alexandretta  for  the  release 
of  Mr.  Knapp. 

The  next  step  should  have  been  to  insist  on 
Mr.  Knapp*s  rights  as  an  American  citizen,  to 
treat  the  charges  brought  against  him  as  ab- 
surd, and  to  demand  that  he  be  permitted  to 
return  at  once  to  his  mission.  Such  action  was 
taken  by  Sir  Philip  Currie  in  the  case  of  Rev. 
F.  W.  MacCallum,  who  was  also  deported  from 
his  station  some  months  later,  but  who  was  a 
British  subject,  a  Canadian.  The  Porte  imme- 
diately complied  with  the  ambassador's  de- 
mands. The  cases  of  these  two  missionaries 
were  object  lessons  in  the  difference  between 
the  policies  of  England  and  of  the  United  States 
with  respect  to  the  status  of  their  citizens 
abroad.*  Dr.  MacCallum  returned  immediately 
to  his  station ;  Mr.  Knapp  waited  in  Constanti- 
nople for  a  "  trial,"  but  in  vain. 

*  These  cases,  however,  put  an  end  to  the  plan  for  the 
general  expulsion  of  missionaries.  The  irade  referred  to 
was  never  made  public. 


GEEATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN        119 

Finally  he  gave  up  the  attempt  to  secure  the 
trial  and  came  to  America,  his  wife  and  children 
and  mother,  who  had  left  Bitlis  soon  after  his 
deportation,  having  preceded  him  hither.  For 
two  years  he  worked  hard  to  secure  funds  in 
this  country  for  the  care  of  thousands  of  Arme- 
nian orphans  left  desolate  by  the  massacres. 

In  1899  he  returned  to  Turkey,  going  to  Har- 
poot  to  take  charge  of  fifteen  hundred  of  these 
orphans.  The  mission  here  had  suffered 
severely  during  the  massacres;  most  of  its 
buildings  were  in  ruins.  The  orphans  were 
scattered  here  and  there  where  room  could  be 
found  for  them ;  Mr.  Knapp  bought  land  ad- 
joining the  mission  premises,  put  up  a  building 
suitable  for  a  home  for  the  girls,  centralized 
the  preparation  of  food  as  an  economical 
measure,  and  established  a  bakery  which  be- 
came a  source  of  revenue  as  well  as  a  saving  of 
expense.  The  whole  orphanage  work  was  en- 
larged and  splendidly  organized.  Rev.  Thomas 
C.  Richards,  in  an  article  published  in  The  Con- 
gregationalist  for  December  9,  1915,  gives  some 
details  concerning  it: 

"  His  perfect  mastery  of  the  language  and 
intimate   knowledge   of  Armenian   ideals   and 


120  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

ideas  made  him  just  the  man  for  the  place.  He 
secured  financial  help  for  the  work  in  Eng- 
land and  Switzerland  and  from  Armenians  in 
America  who  had  great  confidence  in  him. 

"  His  aim  was  to  help  these  orphans  to  help 
themselves.  The  boys  were  all  taught  some 
trade,  tailoring,  shoemaking,  carpentering,  and 
the  like.  The  girls,  besides  learning  to  do  all 
kinds  of  domestic  work,  were  taught  to  weave 
ginghams  and  make  thread  lace.  The  late 
George  C.  Williams,  president  of  the  Chemical 
National  Bank  of  New  York,  believed  in  Mr. 
Knapp  and  his  work  so  much  that  he  gave  the 
funds  to  start  a  plant  for  the  making  of  Oriental 
rugs.  In  the  State  Department  at  Washington 
is  a  magnificent  specimen  of  the  work  accom- 
plished. It  is  a  double-faced  silk  rug  in  the 
form  of  an  American  flag,  twelve  feet  by  four, 
representing  two  years'  work  if  done  by  one 
individual.  On  the  flag  is  this  inscription, 
'  Presented  in  gratitude  to  the  United  States 
Government  by  the  Armenian  Orphans  of  Har- 
poot,  Turkey.' 

"  Much  more  might  be  written  of  the  agri- 
cultural training,  of  the  silk  culture,  of  the  mills 
and   bakery   that   could   turn   the   wheat  into 


GEEATER  LOYE  HATH  NO  MAN        121 

bread,  but  enough  has  been  shown  of  this  one 
venture  and  reHef  measure  to  remind  one  of 
Cyrus  Hamlin  and  his  resourcefulness. 

"  In  1908  a  massacre  occurred  at  Adana  and 
Minot  Rogers  was  killed.  At  that  time,  by 
grape-vine  telegraphy,  news  of  an  impending 
massacre  came  to  Harpoot.  Mr.  Knapp's  two 
daughters  had  gone  to  Ichme,  a  village  five  or 
six  hours  away,  with  a  native  Armenian  pas- 
tor's family  to  spend  their  spring  vacation. 
Convinced  of  the  danger,  George  Knapp  went 
to  the  VaH  of  Harpoot  and  found  the  most 
prominent  Armenians  in  the  city  there  on  a 
like  errand.  The  Governor  pooh-poohed  the 
idea  of  any  danger;  besides,  he  had  sent  four 
soldiers  out  there  for  protection.  Finding  the 
missionary  determined  to  go  that  night  to  the 
village  where  his  daughters  were,  the  Vali  gave 
him  an  escort  of  twenty  soldiers  and  one  officer. 
As  day  broke  they  reached  Ichme  to  find  the 
children  and  village  safe. 

*'Why  didn't  you  do  it  before?  You  can't, 
now  the  *  Hat-wearer '  is  come,"  said  one  of  the 
soldiers  to  the  Moslems,  not  realizing  how  well 
the  missionary  understood  Turkish. 

"  The  Kurds  were  massed  in  a  ravine  back  of 


1?2  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

the  town.  Another  company  were  in  the 
mosque.  They  had  planned  just  as  deadly  and 
brutal  work  as  actually  happened  at  Adana,  but 
were  forestalled.  The  four  soldiers  sent  the 
day  before  arrived  much  later  in  the  day. 

"  Now,  hardest  of  all,  this  father  had  to  go 
back  in  a  few  hours  to  his  post  at  Harpoot,  for 
no  one  could  foretell  what  would  happen  there. 
If  he  took  his  girls  back  with  him,  a  panic  would 
certainly  follow.  So  he  left  those  daughters  of 
his,  dearer  than  life  to  him,  as  hostages  of  peace 
and  security.  With  two  soldiers  he  went  back 
and  was  in  Harpoot  on  duty  that  night.  A 
week  later  those  girls  came  home  under  the 
escort  of  the  brave  Armenian  pastor,  whose 
courage  had  done  much  to  stay  the  massacre 
until  Mr.  Knapp  arrived.  Who  can  tell  the 
courage  it  took  to  leave  those  girls  behind? 

"All  this  was  in  the  day's  work  to  him.  He 
was  as  modest  as  he  was  brave.  Only  by  re- 
peated cross-examination  could  one  extract  his 
story.  He  absolutely  refused  to  be  regarded  as 
a  hero,  but  he  was  one  of  the  noblest. 

"  His  ideals  of  duty  never  took  himself  into 
account.  If  he  had  so  willed  his  great  linguistic 
ability  and  his  business  enterprise  might  have 


GEEATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN        123 

won  him  fame  and  fortune  in  the  Near  East. 
Nothing  could  tempt  him  from  his  service  to 
his  Master  and  his  brother,  the  Armenian." 

Mr.  Knapp's  efforts  at  Harpoot  were  not  con- 
fined to  the  orphanages.  He  taught  classes  in 
the  college  and  theological  seminary,  he  toured 
the  villages,  he  was  station  treasurer;  indeed, 
he  had  too  many  kinds  of  work  to  do — the  usual 
experience  of  missionaries  in  undermanned  sta- 
tions— and  yet  he  was  always  reaching  out  to 
grasp  new  opportunities,  try  new  experiments. 
A  big  farm  on  which  the  orphan  boys  in  his 
charge  should  learn  efficient  Western  methods 
of  cultivating  the  soil  was  a  project  dear  to  his 
heart  which  he  was  forced  to  abandon. 

With  it  all  he  never  ceased  to  study,  to  per- 
fect himself  in  the  languages  of  the  country, 
and  a  knowledge  of  the  history,  the  customs, 
the  prejudices  of  its  people.  He  was  always 
very  patient  with  the  Armenians,  considerate, 
making  allowances  for  their  ignorance  and  the 
deteriorating  effect  of  centuries  of  oppression 
on  their  character.  He  was  not  always  patient 
or  tactful  with  his  associates,  a  little  quick  to 
criticize,  somewhat  hasty  and  impulsive  in  action 
and  judgments. 


124  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

But  there  never  was  a  man  more  quick  to 
acknowledge  a  mistake  or  fault,  more  eager  to 
make  reparation  or  apology;  his  humility  was 
very  great  and  very  sincere. 

In  1909  he  came  to  America  on  furlough  in 
time  to  be  with  his  mother  during  the  last 
month  of  her  life.  He  returned  to  Turkey  the 
following  year,  going  to  Bitlis,  which  greatly 
needed  another  missionary.  His  wife  remained 
in  America  for  the  sake  of  their  children,  ex- 
pecting to  join  him  within  a  year,  but  was  de- 
tained by  circumstances.  In  1914  she  had  en- 
gaged passage  on  a  steamer  to  return  to  Turkey 
when  the  outbreak  of  the  war  caused  all  sail- 
ings to  be  cancelled  by  the  Board. 

During  the  awful  events  of  June  and  July, 
1915,  in  Bitlis,  Mr.  Knapp  was  tireless  in  his 
efforts  to  relieve  suffering,  and  to  mediate  with 
the  Turkish  officials  in  behalf  of  his  people. 
He  had  been  **  much  respected  by  and  accept- 
able to  the  Turks  in  a  business  and  social  way  " 
during  the  whole  of  his  missionary  life,  in  spite 
of  the  1896  experience,  but  now  all  was  changed. 
The  Turks  were  anxious  to  get  rid  of  all  in- 
convenient witnesses  of  what  they  had  done  to 
the  Armenians.     The  story  of  their  attempt  to 


GEEATER  LOVE  HATH  NO  MAN        126 

deport  all  the  Americans  from  Bitlis  has  been 
told  in  the  eleventh  chapter,  together  with  the 
incident  of  the  shot  fired  by  the  disguised 
Armenian,  which  was  the  pretext  seized  upon 
by  the  officials  for  sending  off  Mr.  Knapp  with- 
out delay. 

He  was  allowed  to  take  with  him  an  Armenian 
boy  and  a  Turkish  servant.  The  latter  returned 
from  Sert. 

"  We  waited  in  vain  for  a  telegram  from 
Diarbekir,"  wrote  Miss  McLaren.  "  The  serv- 
ant told  us  that  Mr.  Knapp  planned  to  go  to 
Harpoot  as  soon  as  he  could  get  a  conveyance. 
It  was  not  until  some  time  had  passed  that  the 
doctor  (Mustifa  Bey)  came  and  told  us  that  it 
was  reported  that  Mr.  Knapp  was  ill  in  Diar- 
bekir.  This  was  only  to  prepare  us  for  the 
worst,  for  in  a  moment  or  two  he  said  that  it 
was  reported  that  Mr.  Knapp  had  died  of 
typhus.  From  his  manner  and  the  way  he  told 
the  story,  I  judged  that  he  felt  that  Mr.  Knapp's 
death  had  not  been  a  natural  one.  No  very 
satisfactory  reply  to  inquiries  was  ever  received 
from  the  government.  A  doctor  who  claimed 
to  have  attended  him  gave  a  detailed  account  of 
the  run  of  the  fever  and  the  pulse  evidently 


126  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

made  up  entirely  by  a  man  who  knew  little  or 
nothing  of  typhus  fever," 

The  Armenian  boy  was  sent  from  Diarbekir 
to  Harpoot  at  Consul  Davis's  demand  but  could 
give  no  information  concerning  the  cause  of  Mr. 
Knapp's  death.  After  investigation,  both  Dr. 
Atkinson  of  Harpoot  and  the  American  consul 
arrived  at  the  conviction  that  it  was  not  a 
natural  one.  The  truth  will  probably  never  be 
known,  but  that  he  died  the  death  of  a  martyr 
is  practically  certain.  Dr.  Andrus,  Dr.  Thorn 
and  Miss  Fenenga,  later  deported  from  Mardin, 
were  shown  his  grave  by  a  soldier  who  claimed 
to  be  one  of  those  who  had  borne  him  to  his 
last  resting  place.  It  is  a  lonely  and  unmarked 
grave,  but  a  cenotaph  has  been  placed  in  the 
cemetery  at  Forest  Hills,  Boston,  by  his  cousin, 
Mr.  George  B.  Knapp,  whose  fatherly  affection 
and  interest  followed  him  throughout  his  whole 
career.  His  life  ended  in  the  city  where  the 
missionary  life  of  his  parents  began,  but  the 
manner  of  its  end  has  made  his  memory  not 
only  especially  dear  and  sacred  to  hundreds  of 
survivors  of  the  martyr  race  he  loved  and 
worked  for  but  a  vital  influence  in  their  lives. 
These  lives  will  be  his  best  eulogy. 


XV 

MISS  McLaren  falls  ill;  GERMAN 
OFFICERS  VISIT  BITLIS 


T^ 


HE  girls  and  women  who  were  per- 
■  mitted  to  remain  in  Bitlis  on  condition 
that  they  assist  in  the  hospital,  began 
to  do  washing,  sewing  and  cooking  for  the  sol- 
diers, but  in  their  own  schoolhouse  and  under 
Miss  Shane's  supervision.  The  pastor's  wife 
was  very  helpful  in  overseeing  this  work. 

After  Mr.  Knapp  was  sent  away  it  was  re- 
ported that  Miss  Shane  must  go  as  soon  as  she 
was  strong  enough  to  travel.  For  several 
weeks  her  trunk  was  packed  in  readiness  to 
leave  at  a  moment's  notice.  One  day  the  mili- 
tary commandant  came  to  see  Miss  McLaren 
in  company  with  Mustifa  Bey;  Miss  Shane 
happened  to  step  into  the  room  and  the  com- 
mandant demanded  the  reason  for  her  still  be- 
ing in  Bitlis.  Mustifa  Bey  said  that  she  was 
still  having  fever  and  was  not  able  to  travel. 

This  was  true :  she  had  overtaxed  her  strength 

127 


128  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

after  her  illness  and  her  temperature  had  gone 
up  to  102  and  stayed  there  for  several  days. 
The  explanation  was  accepted  and  the  matter 
allowed  to  drop. 

During  the  weeks  when  she  thought  she 
would  have  to  leave,  Miss  Shane  decided  to 
ask  the  Vali  if  she  might  take  some  of  her  girls 
with  her.  She  talked  the  matter  over  with  the 
women  and  it  was  known  that  the  pastor's 
daughter  was  one  for  whom  she  would  make  a 
special  plea.  But  the  girl  herself  came  to  Miss 
Shane's  room  with  this  request: 

"  Miss  Shane,  I  hear  that  you  are  going  to 
ask  the  Governor  for  permission  to  take  me  with 
you.  If  that  is  true,  please  do  not,  please  ask 
him  if  you  can  take  my  mother.  They  think 
she  has  money  and  it  is  more  dangerous  for  her 
to  stay  than  for  me." 

The  mother,  a  woman  of  great  beauty  of 
character,  died  August  27th  of  typhus. 

Deegeen  Heghene,  Kevork  Efifendi's  widow, 
had  acted  as  Miss  Shane's  nurse  during  part  of 
her  illness,  at  the  same  time  taking  almost  the 
entire  responsibility  for  the  care  of  the  girls. 
Later  she  became  her  most  valuable  helper  in 
the  care  of  the  orphans  and  of  the  household. 


MISS  MoLAEEN  FALLS  ILL  129 

and  often  acted  as  her  interpreter.  Her  quiet 
demeanour  won  the  respect  of  all  the  Turks 
with  whom  they  had  to  deal. 

Not  long  after  her  husband's  martyrdom  her 
baby  died.  This  was  the  only  occasion  on  which 
she  seemed  to  be  unable  to  control  her  grief. 
It  was  heart-breaking  to  see  her  chnging  to  the 
dead  child,  kissing  its  cold  face  and  calling  its 
name.  It  was  thought  best  she  should  not  at- 
tend the  burial  service  but  her  piteous  cries 
followed  the  little  coffin  as  it  was  carried  out  of 
her  sight. 

It  seemed  to  Miss  McLaren  that  her  chief 
business  that  summer  was  burying  the  dead  or 
seeing  that  it  was  done,  preparing  the  bodies 
herself,  often,  because  people  were  afraid  of  con- 
tracting typhus.  After  Sister  Martha's  death 
she  resumed  her  work  in  the  Turkish  hospitals, 
of  which  there  were  ten  or  twelve  in  the  neigh- 
bourhood which  had  to  be  visited  every  day. 

In  September  she  herself  fell  ill  with  typhus, 
was  attended  by  a  Syrian  doctor  on  the  hospital 
staff  and  nursed  by  Miss  Shane  and  two  Arme- 
nian girls. 

The  bankers  who  had  fled  from  the  city  when 
the  Turks  evacuated  it  on  the  approach  of  the 


130  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

Russians,  a  few  days  after  their  return  called  on 
the  two  ladies  and  told  them  that  they  would 
never  forget  the  horror  of  what  they  had  seen 
on  the  road.  The  Bitlis  River,  a  shallow  moun- 
tain stream,  was  filled,  and  the  banks  covered, 
with  bodies  in  all  stages  of  decomposition; 
bodies  were  lying  on  both  sides  of  the  road  and 
sometimes  the  highway  itself  was  obstructed 
by  heaps  of  the  dead.  In  one  place,  for  the 
space  of  about  two  rods,  the  road  was  covered 
with  corpses  over  which  Turks  would  force 
their  horses  to  go. 

What  had  impressed  them  most  was  the  sight 
of  children  alive  and  alone  among  the  dead, 
wailing  piteously  for  the  help  and  comfort  that 
could  not  come,  or  sitting  quietly,  too  young  to 
realize  the  horror  of  what  had  happened. 

A  few  days  before  the  bankers  themselves 
had  left  the  city  a  company  of  one  thousand 
Armenian  soldiers  had  been  sent  from  Bitlis 
entrusted  with  government  books  and  papers. 
They  had  been  set  upon  and  killed  and  their 
bodies  left  where  they  had  fallen.  The  govern- 
ment archives  were  scattered  all  over  the  hillside. 

Hundreds  of  the  fleeing  Moslem  ci\  Hans  died 
from  illness  and  exposure.     The  Vali  on  one 


MISS  McLAEEN  FALLS  ILL  131 

occasion  said  to  Miss  McLaren :  "All  this  suffer- 
ing through  sickness  and  war  has  come  upon  the 
Moslems  as  a  just  punishment  from  a  righteous 
God,  because  of  what  we  have  done  to  the 
Armenians.  Some  of  them  deserved  punish- 
ment but  we  went  too  far,  and  now  God  is 
punishing  us  for  it."  This  conviction  did  not 
make  him  put  an  end  to  the  atrocious  treatment 
of  women,  however. 

In  the  latter  part  of  September  he  was  re- 
placed by  a  man  who  was  proud  of  the  fact  that 
he  had  cleaned  out  the  Christian  population  of 
Erzingan — a  brother-in-law  of  Djevdet  Bey. 

In  October  two  German  officers  on  their  way 
to  Persia  stopped  at  Bitlis  with  instructions  to 
learn  what  had  become  of  Sister  Martha,  as  the 
German  Embassy  was  unable  to  get  any  satis- 
factory answer  to  its  telegrams.  To  these  men 
were  entrusted  letters  to  her  friends  giving  an 
account  of  her  experiences  in  Bitlis,  her  last 
days  and  her  dying  messages,  and  these  were 
safely  delivered. 

None  of  the  Americans'  letters  were  leaving 
the  Bitlis  post-office  and  their  telegrams  were 
changed  and  curtailed  so  that  they  often  failed 
to   convey   the   intended   message.     Therefore 


132  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

Miss  Shane  asked  the  senior  officer  if  he  would 
get  a  letter  to  the  American  Embassy.  He  re- 
plied that  he  would  send  it  to  the  German  Em- 
bassy asking  to  have  it  passed  on  to  the  Amer- 
ican. She  thereupon  wrote  a  fairly  detailed 
account  of  the  events  of  the  few  days  preceding 
Mr.  Knapp's  deportation,  and  this  letter  also 
reached  its  destination. 

These  officers  listened  with  interest  to  the 
story  of  what  had  taken  place  in  Bitlis.  They 
sent  food  to  the  women  kept  in  prison  in  a 
starving  condition,  and  later  they  gathered  up 
children  and  brought  them  to  the  American 
ladies.  Because  of  their  evident  sympathy  for 
the  Armenians  they  incurred  the  suspicion  of 
the  government  and  were  constantly  shadowed 
by  spies. 


XVI 

MUSTIFA  BEY  AND  THE  SCHOOLGIRLS 

AFTER  the  departure  of  the  two  young 
Armenian  surgeons  whose  fate  is  de- 
scribed in  the  seventh  chapter  the  hos- 
pitals had  been  left  without  a  surgeon  and  this 
had  caused  a  great  deal  of  suffering.  At  last 
another  doctor  had  said  that  he  would  do  the 
best  he  could  if  Sister  Martha  would  help  him. 
She  really  knew  more  than  he  did  and  he  would 
ask  her  how  to  make  an  incision  and  would  fol- 
low her  directions.  After  that  he  was  obliged 
to  perform  all  the  operations,  and  unlike  most 
Turkish  doctors  he  did  his  best  and  improved 
noticeably.  Later  he  was  promoted  to  be 
superintendent  of  the  hospitals. 

This  was  Mustifa  Bey,  who  saved  the  women 
and  girls  in  the  school  by  representing  that  he 
needed  their  assistance  in  the  hospital.  He  was 
an  Arab,  had  been  educated  in  France  and  Ger- 
many, and  said  to  the  Americans  on  one  occa- 
sion that  he  was  ashamed  of  being  an  Ottoman 

133 


134  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

subject,  was  horrified  by  the  massacres,  and 
that  if  ever  he  had  the  opportunity  he  would 
give  himself  up  to  the  Russians. 

The  responsibility  he  assumed  was  not  a 
light  one.  As  he  saw  a  great  deal  of  the  other 
officials  he  knew  that  the  presence  of  the  girls 
in  the  school  was  a  constant  thorn  in  the  flesh 
to  the  government.  The  girls  were  better  edu- 
cated than  the  majority  of  Armenian  girls  and 
many  of  them  were  very  attractive ;  the  military 
officers  stationed  in  the  town  constantly  brought 
pressure  to  bear  on  the  authorities  to  deport 
them  in  order  that  they  might  be  able  to  take 
their  pick  of  them. 

"At  one  time,"  wrote  Miss  Shane,  "  it  really 
seemed  as  if  they  would  have  to  go  and  Mustifa 
Bey  seemed  quite  stirred  up  over  the  situation. 
He  told  me  that  the  government  was  continu- 
ally finding  fault  with  him  because  so  many  sol- 
diers in  the  hospital  were  dying,  but  it  would 
not  give  him  the  material  to  work  with  nor  the 
necessary  help.  He  had  been  feeling  rebellious 
for  some  time  past,  but  when  the  Governor  said 
the  girls  must  be  taken  away  he  was  aroused  to 
the  point  of  resistance.  He  told  me  that  unless 
I  feared  that  Miss  McLaren  and  myself  might 


MUSTIFA  BEY  AND  THE  SCHOOLGIRLS    135 

become  involved  in  case  the  government  at- 
tempted to  take  the  girls,  he  would  gather  his 
hospital  forces  and  resist.  He  had  stood  all  he 
cared  to  stand  from  the  government,  had  begged 
to  be  allowed  to  resign  his  position  as  hospital 
superintendent;  had  even  remained  in  his  house 
two  days  feigning  illness  to  avoid  responsibility 
under  such  circumstances,  but  he  could  not  do 
this  indefinitely  and  he  might  as  well  meet  his 
fate  defending  his  own  rights. 

"  I  told  him  that  as  far  as  the  government 
was  concerned  the  girls  had  really  been  placed 
under  his  protection,  and  that  if  he  opposed 
their  being  taken  on  the  ground  that  he  needed 
their  assistance  I  hardly  saw  how  we  could  be 
held  responsible — the  decision  was  his  to  make, 
and  I  would  be  more  than  willing  to  have  him 
resist  any  attempt  to  take  the  girls  when  the 
matter  came  to  a  final  issue. 

"  Before  he  spoke  to  me  he  had  written  to 
Djevdet  Bey  to  countermand  the  order  for  the 
taking  of  the  girls.  No  answer  had  come  and 
several  days  of  uncertainty  had  passed.  In  the 
meantime  the  two  German  officers  had  arrived 
in  the  city  and  had  called.  I  regretted  not  hav- 
ing appealed  to  them  on  the  subject  and  wrote 


136  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

a  letter  to  the  senior  officer  explaining  the  situa- 
tion and  asking  him  to  use  his  influence  with  the 
Governor.  He  and  his  aide  called  again,  said 
they  were  on  their  way  to  see  the  Vali  and 
thought  it  best  that  I  go  with  them  that  we 
might  present  the  matter  together.  Miss  Mc- 
Laren was  just  recovering  from  typhus  at  the 
time  and  could  not  go  with  us. 

"  We  found  Djevdet  Bey  with  the  Governor 
and  after  some  discussion  the  former  gave  his 
assurance  that  the  girls  would  be  allowed  to 
remain  as  long  as  they  were  assisting  in  the 
hospitals.  The  Governor  also  gave  his  consent. 
Djevdet  Bey  later  complained  to  Miss  McLaren 
because  Mustifa  Bey  had  thought  it  necessary 
to  get  him  mixed  up  in  the  affair  by  writing  the 
letter,  but  on  this  occasion  he  did  not  seem 
averse  to  assuming  responsibility  for  the  de- 
cision. 

"  We  could  never  be  certain  that  Djevdet  Bey 
would  not  change  his  mind  even  if  he  sincerely 
meant  what  he  said  at  this  time  and  of  this  we 
could  not  be  sure.  He  was  in  the  city  only 
occasionally  and  then  for  short  periods  of  time 
and  the  Vali  always  kept  us  in  a  state  of  uncer- 
tainty. 


MUSTIPA  BEY  AND  THE  SCHOOLGIELS    137 

"  Commander  Khaleel  Bey  sent  word  from 
Moush  that  he  needed  more  doctors  and  Bitlis 
must  furnish  its  quota.  Mustifa  Bey  appealed 
to  higher  authorities  in  Erzerum  and  was  told 
not  to  send  any  as  they  were  needed  in  BitHs. 
Khaleel  Bey  replied  that  if  they  were  not  sent 
his  men  would  come  and  take  them  by  force. 
The  hospital  building  opposite  us  was  prepared 
for  the  siege.  The  girls  were  in  the  school 
building  and  all  doors  and  gates  were  barred. 
However,  Khaleel  Bey  thought  better  of  his 
decision  to  use  force  and  we  escaped  being 
dangerously  near  a  scene  of  battle. 

"  Complaint  was  constantly  being  made  that 
the  girls  were  not  doing  enough  to  warrant 
their  staying.  Mustifa  Bey  said  that  he  him- 
self was  placed  in  a  very  embarrassing  situation, 
that  he  was  being  made  the  butt  of  ridicule  and 
censure  for  keeping  the  girls.  Since  he  could 
not  guarantee  their  ultimate  safety  he  could  not 
understand  why  I  would  not  allow  them  to  be- 
come the  wives  of  officers  who  wanted  them.  I 
told  him  that  our  religion  did  not  sanction  this, 
that  there  was  not  a  girl  in  the  school  who  was 
not  free  to  become  the  wife  of  a  Turk  if  she 
chose  to  do  so,  but  that  I  was  staying  in  Bitlis 


138  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

>. 
for  the  very  purpose  of  preventing  their  being 

forced  into  Turkish  homes  against  their  vi^ill. 

"  That  he  did  not  attempt  to  make  the 
situation  easier  for  himself  by  forcing  the  girls 
to  marry  Turks  is  to  his  credit.  Later,  how- 
ever, he  insisted  on  having  seven  girls  as  as- 
sistants in  the  operating  room.  Up  to  this  time 
the  girls  had  been  working  in  the  school  build- 
ing under  my  supervision  and  I  disliked  the  idea 
of  their  going  out  among  the  Turks.  When  I 
objected  he  became  very  angry,  said  it  was 
necessary  that  their  work  should  be  more  in 
evidence  if  they  were  to  be  allowed  to  stay;  he 
needed  their  assistance;  if  I  did  not  give  my 
consent  he  would  not  employ  them  in  the  hos- 
pital longer,  and  the  government  could  do  what 
it  pleased  with  them. 

"  Later  he  seemed  ashamed  of  his  show  of 
anger,  said  I  could  choose  those  who  were  to 
assist  him,  and  assured  me  that  they  would  be 
treated  with  respect  and  that  I  was  free  to  visit 
the  operating  room  often  to  see  how  they  were 
getting  along.  I  chose  seven  of  the  teachers, 
young  women  who  had  been  brought  up  from 
their  early  years  under  the  care  of  the  Ely  sis- 
ters, and  said  to  them : 


MUSTIFA  BEY  AND  THE  SCHOOLGIRLS    139 

"  '  The  real  test  has  now  come  for  you.  If 
you  cannot  make  the  Turk  realize  that  there  is 
a  vital  difference  between  your  religion  and  his, 
your  principles  and  his;  that  there  is  something 
in  you  which  makes  it  impossible  for  you  to 
descend  to  his  plane  of  living  and  thinking,  and 
that  you  do  not  shrink  from  death  when  the 
question  of  principle  and  loyalty  to  your  re- 
ligion is  at  stake,  your  only  means  of  protection 
is  gone  and  any  breaking  down  of  barriers 
means  danger  for  yourselves  and  all  the  others.' 

"  The  girls  never  had  cause  for  complaint. 
Miss  McLaren  in  her  work  in  the  hospital  often 
had  occasion  to  visit  the  operating  room  and 
she  reported  that  they  were  faring  well  and 
were  getting  some  valuable  training. 

"  Some  of  the  women  were  sent  out  to  the 
more  distant  hospitals  to  work.  They  were 
kindly  and  respectfully  treated,  with  the  excep- 
tion of  a  few  who  were  sent  to  the  monastery 
outside  of  the  city  which  was  used  as  a  hospital 
for  convalescents.  These  women  were  in  con- 
stant danger  until  Mustifa  Bey  was  prevailed 
upon  to  replace  the  superintendent  of  this  work 
by  a  more  trustworthy  man." 


XVII 

MISS  McLaren  and  miss  shane 

OBLIGED  TO  LEAVE  BITLIS 

THE  two  ladies  could  send  out  no  letters 
and  but  few  telegrams.  In  November 
the  American  ambassador  at  Constan- 
tinople urged  them  to  leave.  Three  telegrams 
were  sent  in  reply  stating  that  they  were  re- 
maining voluntarily  and  did  not  wish  to  go,  but 
he  thought  these  telegrams  not  genuine,  sent 
an  order  for  them  to  go  to  Harpoot,  and  had  the 
American  consul  in  that  city  send  his  kavass  to 
Bitlis  to  accompany  them. 

Miss  McLaren  and  Miss  Shane  left  BitHs  on 
November  30th.  Women  and  children  were 
still  being  hunted  from  house  to  house  through- 
out the  city  and  a  few  days  earlier  the  two 
ladies  had  seen  a  number  held  under  guard  in 
the  open  without  food  or  shelter,  huddled  to- 
gether in  small  groups.  Their  faces  did  not 
seem  human,  so  emaciated  were  they  with  hun- 
ger and  suffering. 

140 


OBLIGED  TO  LEAVE  BITLIS  141 

The  road  to  the  south  had  been  partially 
cleared  up  in  October,  just  before  some  German 
officials  were  expected  to  pass  that  way,  going 
to  Mosul,  but  evidences  of  the  summer's  work 
were  still  to  be  seen;  in  every  gully  were  the 
remains  of  human  bodies. 

While  the  ladies  were  in  Diarbekir  a  new 
massacre  took  place,  and  during  the  next  two 
days  they  saw  bodies  lying  on  or  near  the  road, 
some  of  them  stripped  of  their  clothing,  many 
terribly  mutilated;  the  faces  of  three  in  one 
group  had  been  so  mutilated  that  no  features 
were  discernible  and  the  bodies  were  one  mass 
of  gashes.  A  dog  was  standing  over  one  body ; 
as  the  travellers  drew  near  they  could  see  that 
he  had  already  gnawed  a  part  of  the  flesh  from 
the  bones. 

They  passed  the  spot  where  the  men  had  evi- 
dently been  led  ofiE  the  road.  It  was  far  from 
any  village,  a  wild  desolate  hilly  region,  with 
enormous  jagged  rocks  covering  the  hillsides. 
At  this  point  some  had  evidently  tried  to  escape 
the  torture  and  death  that  awaited  them  in  the 
ravines.  They  had  been  shot  and  left  where 
they  fell;  many  bodies  were  in  plain  view,  of 
others  an  arm  or  a  leg  could  be  seen  projecting 


142  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

from  behind  some  rock.  Further  on  was  the 
body  of  an  old  white-haired  woman  lying  near 
the  road,  a  deep  gash  in  her  forehead. 

All  along  the  way  were  seen  villages  com- 
pletely destroyed  by  fire. 

The  travellers  passed  a  group  of  at  least  fifty 
men  who  were  marching  along  under  guard, 
and  were  told  that  these,  too,  were  soon  to  be 
killed.  They  were  all  that  had  been  left  of  a 
very  large  party  of  Armenian  soldiers  who  had 
come  from  Erzerum.  Two  of  the  Erzerum 
mission  schoolboys  had  been  with  them  but  suc- 
ceeded in  escaping  and  found  refuge  as  helpers 
in  the  American  hospital  at  Harpoot. 

Miss  McLaren  assisted  in  this  hospital  after 
her  arrival  in  Harpoot,  Miss  Shane  in  the  girls' 
school  and  among  the  Armenian  refugees  from 
further  north. 

In  the  summer  of  1917  after  the  breaking  of 
diplomatic  relations  with  the  United  States, 
they  left  with  the  Harpoot  missionaries  for 
America.  Not  until  they  reached  Switzerland 
did  they  learn  the  truth  about  what  had  taken 
place  in  Van  in  the  spring  of  1915,  and  that 
there  had  been  no  "  rebellion  "  there. 

They  had  known  that  the  entire  population 


OBLIGED  TO  LEAVE  BITLIS  143 

of  the  town  and  province  had  fled  into  the 
Caucasus  when  the  Russian  army  retreated  in 
August,  for  Djevdet  Bey  had  entered  the 
evacuated  city  and  later  returned  to  BitHs.  He 
told  Miss  McLaren  that  Mrs.  Ussher  had  died 
of  typhus  in  July  and  he  had  spoken  with  deep 
feeling  of  the  kindness  shown  by  the  mission- 
aries towards  the  Moslem  refugees  whom  they 
had  cared  for  on  their  premises  during  the 
Russian  occupation. 

"  I  can  never  forget  it,"  said  he. 


XVIII 
SEQUELS 

AGAIN  the  Russians  entered  Turkey, 
occupied  Van  and  pushed  westward, 
reaching  Tadvan  once  more  about  the 
last  of  January,  1916.  It  took  the  army  a  month 
to  cross  the  plain,  eighteen  miles  in  width,  be- 
tween Tadvan  and  Bitlis.  About  midway  a 
terrible  battle  was  fought  and  the  noise  of  it 
was  heard  in  the  city. 

Mustifa  Bey,  faithful  to  his  trust,  had  refused 
to  yield  to  the  great  pressure  brought  to  bear 
on  him  to  make  him  give  up  the  schoolgirls  left 
in  his  charge.  A  few,  fearing  a  worse  fate,  had 
consented  to  become  the  wives  of  Turkish  of- 
ficers, and  two  whom  he  had  sent  south,  assur- 
ing them  of  safety  in  the  home  of  his  brother  in 
Aleppo,  were  stopped  at  Diarbekir  and  obliged 
to  work  in  the  military  hospital  there.  But  up 
to  this  time  he  had  succeeded  in  protecting  the 

rest  from  molestation. 

144 


SEQUELS  145 

When  the  Russians  drew  near  the  city,  how- 
ever, the  Turks  slaughtered  in  the  most  brutal 
manner — ^with  axes  instead  of  with  bullets  or 
bayonets — the  few  women  who  had  not  as  yet 
been  deported,  and  Djevdet  sent  word  to  Mustifa 
Bey  that  he  must  give  up  his  charges  to  be  put 
to  death.  Mustifa  Bey  in  an  effort  to  postpone 
the  evil  hour  made  illness  an  excuse  for  not 
obeying  at  once,  saying  he  would  attend  to  the 
matter  on  the  morrow.  He  then  went  to  the 
girls  and  bid  them  prepare  for  a  long  journey, 
as  they  were  to  be  sent  into  exile  at  last. 

It  may  be  supposed  they  had  no  thought  of 
sleep  that  night  as  they  busied  themselves  fol- 
lowing his  instructions.  About  an  hour  after 
midnight  they  were  startled  by  the  sudden  noise 
of  battle  in  the  city  itself.  The  furious  firing 
seemed  to  be  almost  under  their  very  windows, 
as  the  schoolhouse  stood  near  the  edge  of  the 
bluff  overlooking  the  most  densely  built-up  part 
of  the  town.  The  girls  believed  that  the  regular 
troops  were  engaged  with  plundering  hordes  of 
Kurds,  and  when  there  came  a  thunderous 
knocking  at  their  gate  at  five  o'clock  in  the 
morning  they  thought  that  either  a  band  of 
these  Kurds  had  come  to  ravish  and  kill  or  that 


146  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

the  Turkish  soldiers  were  about  to  hurry  them 
"  down  the  road." 
"  Open !  We  are  friends — ^Armenians." 
Trembling,  they  obeyed,  to  find  outside  a  band 
of  Armenian  Volunteers,  part  of  the  advance 
guard  of  the  Russian  army,  which,  by  sliding 
down  the  trackless,  snow-covered  hills  sur- 
rounding Bitlis,  had  taken  the  Turks  by  sur- 
prise and  captured  the  city.  The  Moslems  who 
did  not  succeed  in  escaping  were  put  to  death, 
but  Mustifa  Bey*s  life  was  spared  through  the 
intercession  of  the  girls  whom  he  had  protected. 
A  week  later  these  girls  were  taken  to  Van, 
where  some  of  them  remained  till  the  second 
evacuation  of  the  province,  while  a  few  went  on 
almost  immediately  to  the  Caucasus. 

Among  the  Armenian  Volunteers  who  cap- 
tured Bitlis  were  two  young  men  originally 
natives  of  Kultig,  a  large  village  not  far  from 
the  city,  which,  like  all  the  other  villages  of  the 
vilayet,  had  sufifered  from  massacre  and  de- 
portation, but  some  weeks  later  than  the  rest. 
One  of  these  young  men,  Caspar,  by  bribing  a 
Turkish  friend,  managed  to  elude  the  soldiers 
surrounding  his  home,  and  after  remaining  con- 
cealed in  the  mountains  for  a  while,  succeeded 


SEQUELS  147 

in  escaping  to  the  Russian  army,  then  very  near 
the  city.  When  it  retreated  he  went  with  it  to 
Russia,  to  return  as  a  volunteer  in  1916. 

The  other  young  man,  Levone,  had  emigrated 
to  America  some  years  before.  After  the  war 
broke  out  he  started  for  Russia  with  the  inten- 
tion of  fighting  in  the  Russian  army  against  the 
Turks.  He  sailed  on  the  Lusitania  and  when 
that  ship  was  sunk  was  saved  by  a  piece  of 
timber  by  means  of  which  he  kept  himself  afloat 
for  hours  until  rescued.  After  which  he  carried 
out  his  original  intention  and  was  with  the  Rus- 
sian army  which  raised  the  siege  of  Van  in  May, 
1915.  Not  sent  on  to  Bitlis  at  this  time  with 
the  troops  that  never  reached  their  objective, 
he  entered  his  old  home  with  a  victorious  army 
ten  months  later. 

These  Kultig  men  married  two  of  the  rescued 
schoolgirls  who  were  sisters.  Levone  Seferian, 
after  a  three  months*  stay  in  Van,  brought  his 
wife,  Lucia,  on  to  New  York.  The  other  young 
couple  remained  behind  and  no  word  has  been 
received  from  them  since.  If  living  they  are 
probably  in  the  Russian  Caucasus,  where  there 
are  now  330,000  Armenian  refugees.  In  August, 
1915,  there  were  about  250,000  refugees  from 


148  THE  TRAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

the  evacuated  Van  province  and  about  100,000 
from  the  Erzerum  and  Bitlis  provinces  and  their 
condition — homeless,  starving,  strangers  in  a 
strange  land — was  desperate  indeed. 

The  Russian  Government  gave  a  bread  ration 
for  a  while,  but  it  was  the  American  Committee 
for  Armenian  and  Syrian  Relief  that  organized 
permanent  and  really  efficient  relief  in  this  con- 
gested district.  It  sent  there  Mr.  Richard  Hill, 
late  in  1915,  and  soon  after  Dr.  Samuel  Wilson 
from  Persia;  both  were  American  missionaries. 
Dr.  F.  W.  MacCallum  of  the  Constantinople 
Mission  and  Mr.  George  F.  Gracey  of  Ourfa 
went  there  early  in  1916  and  were  joined  some 
months  later  by  Dr.  George  C.  Raynolds  and 
Rev.  and  Mrs.  Ernest  A.  Yarrow,  formerly  of 
the  Van  Mission,  and  Rev.  and  Mrs.  Harrison 
A.  Maynard,  who  had  left  Bitlis  for  their  fur- 
lough in  May,  1915. 

Mr.  and  Mrs.  Maynard  found  in  the  Caucasus 
the  women  and  girls  who  had  so  strangely  sur- 
vived the  tragedy  of  Bitlis.  Deegeen  Heghene 
became  matron  of  an  orphanage.  Pastor  Kha- 
chig's  daughter  and  her  little  brother  were 
taken  into  another  orphanage.  The  little  tot 
who  was  rescued  from  deportation  and  inevi- 


Ifel^ 

pH"  L  p 

l€:  .iiti 

W       ^— ■'^'Lwjjijp 

HLML-^ 

Shoc-niakiiisj'. 


Lace-work 

InDUSTKI.M.      KkI.IKK     of     the     AmKKUA.N      CuMMITTEli     FOR 

1\.f:lief  in  the  Near  East. 


SEQUELS  149 

table  death  by  a  Turk  but  would  have  none  of 
him  and  was  consigned  to  the  care  of  an  Arme- 
nian woman  (see  p.  66)  was  among  those  who 
were  saved. 

The  Americans  immediately  began  to  organ- 
ize industrial  relief.  Crude  wool  and  cotton 
were  bought  and  cleansed,  carded,  spun,  woven 
and  made  into  garments  and  blankets  by 
refugees,  for  refugees.  Refugees  made  spinning- 
wheels,  handlooms,  sandals  and,  later,  farm  im- 
plements. Every  dollar  of  relief  money  was 
thus  made  to  do  the  work  of  two.  Every  in- 
dividual employed  supported  a  family  averag- 
ing five  or  six  members.  The  aged,  infirm  and 
helpless  were  given  money  and  needy  widows 
with  children  to  support  were  given  a  small 
sum  monthly  for  each  child.  Children  were 
taught  trades ;  a  small  hospital  was  opened  and 
a  daily  clinic  held  by  Dr.  Kennedy,  who  had 
been  sent  out  by  the  Lord  Mayor  of  London's 
Committee  for  Armenian  ReHef.  Another  Eng- 
lishman who  worked  with  the  American  Com- 
mittee most  efficiently  was  Mr.  Thomas  Dann 
Heald  of  Bristol,  while  Mr.  Backhouse  and  Mr. 
Catchpool  of  the  Lord  Mayor's  Committee  co- 
operated with  it  in  friendly  and  effective  fash- 


160  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITUS 

ion.  In  1917  Messrs.  Compton,  Elmer,  Par- 
tridge, James,  White,  Williams,  Mrs.  White, 
Mrs.  Compton  and  Miss  Orvis  were  sent  from 
America  to  assist  in  the  work  which  had  reached 
proportions  beyond  the  strength  of  those  who 
had  originally  organized  it.  Had  not  their 
Armenian  superintendents  been  men  trained  in 
the  mission  work  of  Van — educated,  capable, 
trustworthy  men,  filled  with  the  spirit  of  service 
and  cooperation,  the  task  of  the  Americans 
would  have  been  an  almost  impossible  one. 

Russia's  separate  peace  with  Germany  spelled 
catastrophe  to  the  relief  work.  The  American 
consul  at  Tiflis,  Mr.  F.  Willoughby-Smith,  sent 
the  American  workers  away.  Wrote  Mr.  Yar- 
row later: 

"The  following  argument  put  forth  by  the 
consul,  I  think  appealed  to  us  all  and  it  was  on 
this  ground  that  we  decided  to  leave.  It  seemed 
most  likely  that  the  Germans  had  designs  on  the 
Caucasus  and  if  they  sent  even  a  small  force 
from  Odessa  there  was  nothing  to  oppose  them. 
Then  our  being  with  the  Armenians  would  do 
them  more  damage  than  good.  We  would  im- 
mediately be  interned,  our  equipment  con- 
fiscated and  probably  the  activity  of  the  Com- 


SEQUELS  151 

mittee  be  entirely  stopped.  On  the  other  hand, 
if  we  should  withdraw  and  leave  the  work  of 
the  Committee  in  the  hands  of  local  Armenian 
committees  the  Germans  might  allow  them  to 
continue.  And  the  consul  assured  us  that  he 
could  arrange  for  the  transfer  of  funds  through 
the  Swedish  consul  or  some  other  neutral 
agency.  I  think  it  was  harder  for  us  to  come 
away  than  it  would  have  been  to  stay,  but  we 
tried  to  weigh  the  question  calmly  and  logically 
and  I  still  believe  we  decided  wisely.  The 
situation  was  entirely  different  from  the  one  we 
faced  in  Van  three  years  before.*  We  were 
warned  then  of  what  was  to  happen  and  with 
our  eyes  open  we  decided  to  stay  and  share  the 
fate  of  the  people  with  whom  we  had  lived  and 
worked  for  so  many  years,  but  now  our  position 
was  entirely  different.  We  were  in  a  land  for- 
eign to  ourselves  and  to  the  refugees  to  whom 
we  were  ministering.  We  had  given  them  all 
our  strength  and  intelligence,  but  new  condi- 
tions over  which  we  had  no  control  made  it  im- 
possible to  help  further;  on  the  contrary,  our 
presence  with  them  might  be  a  real  element  of 
danger  to  their  security,  and  with  heavy  hearts 
*^ee  Dr.  Ussher*s  "An  American  Physician  in  Turkey." 


152  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

but  free  consciences  we  left  the  work  to 
which  we  had  been  giving  the  best  that  was  in 
us." 

The  party  left  Erivan  March  19th.  The 
chance  of  getting  anywhere  with  a  whole  skin 
seemed  very  uncertain;  the  train  was  searched 
at  every  stop  by  the  Tartars ;  the  stations  were 
almost  all  destroyed  and  villages  were  burning 
all  along  the  way. 

Mr.  James  ArroU  and  Mr.  John  Elder,  two 
young  Americans,  had  been  doing  Y.  M.  C.  A. 
work  among  the  soldiers  in  the  Caucasus  for  a 
short  time.  They  secured  consent  from  the 
district  secretary  to  remain  a  while  at  least. 
Mr.  Heald  remained  for  a  few  days  in  Erivan  to 
complete  the  transfer  of  the  work  to  the  Arme- 
nian Committees  aided  by  Mr.  McDowell  of  the 
Persian  Branch  of  the  Relief,  then  in  British 
service,  and  Mr.  Gracey  who  had  become  a  cap- 
tain in  the  British  army.  Mr.  Heald  left  Tiflis 
on  the  last  train  allowed  to  pass  by  the  Tartars, 
Mr.  McDowell  was  ordered  to  Alexandropol 
and  Captain  Gracey  to  Tiflis.  (He  was  after- 
wards made  prisoner  by  the  Bolshevists  and 
not  set  free  till  late  in  the  spring  of  1919.)  One 
of  the  two  Y.  M.  C.  A.  men  became  very  ill. 


SEQUELS  163 

the  other  cared  for  him;  on  his  recovery  they 
divided  the  reUef  work  between  them. 

So  the  industrial  rehef  at  Erivan  was  never 
discontinued,  the  orphanages  and  hospital  never 
closed,  throughout  all  the  changes  that  took 
place  in  that  harassed  region  during  the  next 
few  months,  though,  at  one  time,  informed  by 
the  Armenian  Dictator,  Aram  Pasha,  that 
Erivan  would  be  in  Turkish  hands  before  many 
days,  Mr.  Arroll  and  Mr.  Elder  prepared  to 
leave.  But  the  tide  of  battle  at  Sadar  Abad 
turned  and  Erivan  was  saved. 

Consul  Willoughby-Smith  left  the  relief  work 
in  Tiflis  in  charge  of  Madame  Plavsky,  a  Rus- 
sian lady,  and  her  assistant,  Mr.  Booman,  who 
was  a  Lett.  Mr.  Montesanto,  vice-consul  at 
Vladikavkaz,  cared  for  the  refugees  fleeing  from 
the  Caucasus  into  Russia,  of  whom  over  fifty 
thousand  passed  through  this  opening  in  the 
great  mountain  barrier  between  the  two  conti- 
nents :  food  and  medical  assistance  was  given  to 
thousands,  milk  to  the  children  and  the  sick. 

When  the  armistice  was  signed  Mr.  Maynard 
at  once  dropped  the  relief  work  in  Persia  in 
which  he  had  engaged  not  long  after  leaving 
the   Caucasus,   and   hastened  back   to   Erivan. 


164  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

Mr.  Yarrow  left  Army  Y.  M.  C.  A.  work  in 
Vladivostok  and  travelled  thither  via  India  and 
Egypt.  The  American  Committee  for  Arme- 
nian and  Syrian  Relief  in  the  meantime  planned 
a  great  work  of  relief  and  reconstruction  in  the 
Near  East — where,  by  the  way,  it  is  entitled  the 
American  Committee  for  Relief  in  the  Near 
East,  or  the  A.  C.  R.  N.  E.  It  sent  out  early 
in  January,  1919,  a  Relief  Commission  of  seven, 
headed  by  Dr.  James  L.  Barton,  to  investigate 
conditions  and  organize  relief.  President  Main 
of  Grinnell  College  was  the  Relief  Commissioner 
for  the  Caucasus.  He  cabled  to  New  York 
early  in  April : 

"  I  have  been  handling  refugee  concentra- 
tion along  the  former  boundary  line  between 
Russian  and  Turkish  Armenia.  Alexandropol, 
a  large  center,  and  Etchmiadzin,  a  small  one, 
are  typical.  In  the  one  are  68,000  refugees  by 
actual  census  at  our  bread  and  soup  kitchens. 
In  the  other  are  7,000.  Refugees  have  streamed 
into  these  places  hoping  to  find  it  possible  to 
cross  the  border  into  their  former  homes  in 
Turkish  Armenia  near  Kars.  Concentration  at 
these  two  places  and  many  others  without  food 
or  clothing  and  after  a  winter  of  exile  in  the 


SEQUELS  156 

Caucasus  and  beyond  has  produced  a  condition 
of  horror  unparalleled  among  the  atrocities  of 
the  great  war.  On  the  streets  of  Alexandropol 
on  the  day  of  my  arrival  192  corpses  were 
picked  up.  This  is  far  below  the  average  per 
day.  One-seventh  of  the  refugees  are  dying 
each  month.     .     .     . 

"  The  refugees  dare  not  go  forward.  They 
halt  on  the  borderland  of  their  home.  The 
Turks,  the  Kurds  and  the  Tartars  have  taken 
possession  of  their  land  and  will  hold  it  by  force 
of  arms.  A  line  almost  Hke  a  battle  line  from 
the  Black  Sea  region,  where  is  located  the 
Southwestern  Republic  with  Kars  as  its  capital, 
to  the  Caspian  Sea,  where  Baku  is  the  capital 
of  the  Azerbeijan  Republic,  together  with  a  Hne 
of  Turks,  Kurds  and  Tartars  between  these  two 
extremes,  holds  the  refugees  where  they  are. 
The  total  number  is  more  than  330,000.  To 
these  must  be  added  the  local  inhabitants  also 
suflFering  indescribable  hardships.  The  world 
appears  to  be  unconscious  of  the  overwhelming 
human  tragedy  that  is  being  enacted  in  the 
Caucasus.  The  Turk  and  his  racial  confed- 
erates are  carrying  forward  with  growing  ef- 
ficiency the  policy  of  extermination  developed 


156  THE  TRAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

during  the  war  by  the  method  of  starvation. 
Starvation  is  aided  by  typhus,  and  already,  as 
if  in  anticipation  of  the  hot  season,  cholera  is 
developing.     .    .     ."* 

Later  in  January  forty  relief  workers,  all  men, 
sailed  on  the  Pensacola,  which  carried  a  cargo  of 
food,  clothing,  medical  supplies,  hospital  units, 
ambulances,  etc.,  for  the  sufferers  in  the  Near 
East.  Among  the  workers  was  Dr.  Ussher  of 
the  Van  Mission,  and  on  their  arrival  in  Con- 
stantinople he  was  sent  with  several  new  men 
up  into  the  Caucasus. 

The  Caesar y  the  MercuriuSy  the  Western  Belle 
and  the  Newport  News  have  in  quick  succession 
carried  out  supplies  of  food,  clothing  and  every- 
thing needed  for  reUef  and  rehabilitation.     On 

*  Cables  sent  from  the  Caucasus  June  1st  and  7th  state: 
"  First  relief  and  food  ships  momentarily  checking  tide 
starvation  and  death.  Increased  and  continuous  aid  im- 
perative. Repatriation  into  Turkish  Armenia  beginning." 
"  Conservative  estimates  British  and  our  Committee  read 
amount  immediately  needed  Caucasus  $1,500,000  monthly. 
Committee  only  relief.  Situation  worse  daily."  "  History 
has  no  record  of  human  suffering  on  such  a  scale." 

Mr.  Hoover  has  cooperated  with  the  Committee  in 
every  possible  way  but  his  organization  is  scheduled  to 
go  out  of  existence  July  1,  1919.  Mr.  Yarrow  has  been 
appointed  Deputy  Commissioner  for  the  Caucasus  with 
oversight  of  Erzerum,  Van  and  Bitlis  when  these  are 
opened  up. 


SEQUELS  157 

the  Leviathan  sailed  in  February  about  two  hun- 
dred and  fifty  more  relief  workers — doctors, 
nurses,  expert  agriculturists  and  mechanics, 
sanitary  engineers  and  civil  engineers,  with 
other  technically  trained  men  and  women, 
teachers  and  orphanage  workers,  and  smaller 
groups  have  followed  these  from  time  to  time/ 
Miss  Shane  went  out  on  the  Leviathan.  Miss 
McLaren  also  intends  to  return  to  Turkey  when 
she  has  completed  the  nurses'  training  course 
she  entered  upon  soon  after  her  return  to  this 
country. 

This  is  the  program  of  the  American  Com- 
mittee for  Armenian  and  Syrian  Relief:  first,  to 
save  the  lives  of  the  thousands  upon  thousands 
of  the  victims  of  Turkish  cruelty  who  are  now 
starving  to  death;  next,  to  repatriate  the  de- 
ported exiles  (as  well  as  the  exiles  in  the  Cau- 
casus who  were  not  deported,  but  fled  from 
their  homes)  who  since  the  armistice  was  signed 
have  been  striving  to  return  to  their  homes  from 
the  desert  where  they  have  been  wandering  for 
three  years;  to  help  them  rebuild  their  houses, 

'J.  Herbert  Knapp,  brother  of  George  Knapp,  went 
out  as  a  civil  engineer  with  a  group  of  relief  workers 
that  sailed  June  24,  1919. 


158  THE  TEAGEDY  OF  BITLIS 

many  of  which  have  been  destroyed;  to  supply 
peasants  with  seed  and  farm  implements  so  that 
they  may  gain  their  own  living  from  the  soil 
and  avert  famine  from  the  whole  country;  to 
supply  artisans  with  the  few  tools  and  the  small 
sum  of  money  which  would  in  a  very  short  time 
enable  them  to  support  their  families;  to  create 
industries  by  which  the  thousands  of  women 
left  without  male  relatives  may  support  them- 
selves; most  important  of  all,  to  care  for  the 
children,  most  of  them  orphans,  so  efficiently,  so 
wisely,  that  they  may  become  a  great  asset  in 
the  economic,  intellectual,  social  and  spiritual 
development  of  the  country.  The  reconstruc- 
tion of  Turkey,  the  "  key  to  the  Old  World,"  is 
in  the  hands  of  American  philanthropy. 

Here  is  one  example  of  the  problems  the 
A.  C.  R.  N.  E.  has  to  solve:  "The  present 
movement  by  which  the  Turks  are  releasing 
women  and  children  who  have  been  sequestered 
in  their  homes  is  almost  startling  in  its  sweep 
across  the  country,  putting  upon  us  enormous 
responsibilities.  There  is  no  other  organization 
in  the  country  to  meet  this  situation.  While 
native  communities  are  doing  everything  in 
their  power  to  take  in  these  discharged  people 


SEQUELS  159 

and  give  them  a  home,  they  find  it  impossible 
to  do  anywhere  near  what  is  necessary  to  do, 
and  all  parties  turn  to  us.  It  is  pathetic  to  see 
the  way  in  which  all  classes  of  people  look  upon 
this  Commission  as  almost  sent  from  heaven  to 
save  this  stricken  land  from  ruin." 

From  the  one  town  of  Aintab  30,000  were 
driven  out  into  the  desert  to  die,  and  now  there 
are,  so  far  as  can  be  ascertained,  only  4,000  or 
5,000  alive.  Whether  this  proportion  holds 
true  for  the  rest  of  Turkey  we  cannot  tell. 
Undoubtedly  more  of  the  former  inhabitants  of 
Van  are  still  living  than  of  any  other  Armenian 
city.  And  of  Bitlis,  alas!  the  fewest.  In  the 
fall  of  1915  the  government  of  that  city  had 
issued  a  proclamation  that  all  men  who  were  in 
hiding  could  come  out,  would  be  forgiven  (  !  ) 
and  set  to  work.  Some  did  come  out  of  their 
holes  looking  like  skeletons  risen  from  the 
grave.  What  their  ultimate  fate  was  Miss  Mc- 
Laren and  Miss  Shane  do  not  know  and  aside 
from  these  they  know  of  but  one  or  two  who 
escaped  massacre. 

Although  few  survivors  may  return  to  Bitlis, 
it  is  of  the  utmost  importance  that  the  town 
should  be  fully  rehabilitated.     It  has  been  said 


160  THE  TEAGEDY  OP  BITLIS 

that  it  IS  the  "  door  between  highlands  and  low- 
lands," the  avenue  of  communication  between 
the  northern  and  northeastern  plateaus  and  the 
Mesopotamian  plains,  between  Persia  and  the 
coast  of  the  Mediterranean.  The  strategical 
value  of  its  position  is  therefore  immense  from 
the  economic  point  of  view;  from  the  spiritual 
point  of  view  no  less  great,  for  from  this  center 
the  Kurds  of  Eastern  Turkey  can  be  most 
readily  reached,  civilized,  Christianized,  and  for 
the  sake  of  the  future  of  Turkey  this  must  be 
done. 

The  tragedy  of  BitHs  was  one  of  the  crudest 
of  the  war.  May  the  future  of  the  little  town 
be  a  future  of  such  peace,  prosperity,  far-reach- 
ing, civilizing  influence  and  steady  growth  in 
righteousness  as  to  compensate  in  some  meas- 
ure for  the  hideous  suffering  of  the  past. 


Printed  in  the  United  States  of  America 


Deacidified  using  the  Bookkeeper  p 
Neutralizing  agent:  Magnesium  Oxi( 
Treatment  Date:       J|J/^  ; 

PreservationTechnoli 

A  WORLD  LEADER  IN.  PAPER  PRESEH 

111  Thomson  Park  Drive 
Cranberry  Township,  PA  16( 
(724)  779-2111